Skip to main content

Statically determinate/indeterminate; beam SFD and BMD

Short answer

A statically determinate structure has unknowns equal to equilibrium equations (e.g., simply supported beam); an indeterminate structure has more unknowns, requiring compatibility equations (e.g., propped cantilever). For the beam, reactions are RA = 41.35 kN↑, RB = 64.15 kN↑. Maximum bending moment is 76.98 kN·m at x = 6.6 m under the 65 kN load; a contraflexure point occurs at x ≈ 1.87 m.

What do you understand by statically determinate and indeterminate structure? Explain with an example for each. Write the equations for shear force and bending moment for the beam shown in figure below. Plot the variation of the shear force and bending moment in the beam. Also indicate the salient features associated with the shear force and bending moment. [Figure: simply supported beam, roller at left and pin at right; triangular load from 0 to W = 15 kN/m over the first 1.8 m + 3.6 m; 65 kN point load; segments 1.8 m, 3.6 m, 1.2 m, 1.2 m.]

Statically determinate and indeterminate structures

A structure is statically determinate if all support reactions and internal forces can be found from the equations of static equilibrium alone (ΣFx = 0, ΣFy = 0, ΣM = 0 in 2D). It is statically indeterminate when the unknowns exceed the available equations, so extra equations from deformation (compatibility) are needed.

DeterminateIndeterminate
Unknown reactions (beam)r = 3 (or r = 3 + number of hinge conditions)r > 3 + hinge conditions
MethodEquilibrium onlyEquilibrium + compatibility (slope-deflection, moment distribution, flexibility)
Effect of settlement, temperatureNo stressesStresses develop
ExampleSimply supported beam (pin + roller, r = 3)Propped cantilever or continuous beam (r = 4 or more)

Degree of indeterminacy of a beam: D = r − 3 − (number of internal hinges). A propped cantilever has r = 3 + 1 = 4, so D = 1.

Reading of the figure

Origin at the free left end O; roller at A (x = 1.8 m), pin at B (x = 7.8 m). The triangular load rises from 0 at O to w = 15 kN/m at x = 5.4 m (intensity 2.778x kN/m); a 65 kN point load acts at x = 6.6 m.

  • Total triangular load = ½ × 15 × 5.4 = 40.5 kN, acting at 2/3 × 5.4 = 3.6 m from O.
   w=15 kN/m               65 kN
  /||||||||||||||           ↓
 O/_______________________________
 ^  A(roller)                      B(pin)
 |<-1.8->|<--3.6-->|<1.2>|<1.2>|

Reactions

  • ΣM_B = 0: R_A(7.8 − 1.8) = 40.5(7.8 − 3.6) + 65(1.2), so 6R_A = 170.1 + 78 = 248.1 and R_A = 41.35 kN ↑.
  • ΣFy = 0: R_B = 40.5 + 65 − 41.35 = 64.15 kN ↑. (r = 3, so the beam is determinate.)

Equations of V and M (x measured from O)

Load intensity w(x) = (15/5.4)x = 2.778x kN/m, load up to x = ½·2.778x·x = 1.389x².

RangeShear force V (kN)Bending moment M (kN·m)
0 ≤ x ≤ 1.8−1.389x²−0.463x³
1.8 ≤ x ≤ 5.441.35 − 1.389x²41.35(x − 1.8) − 0.463x³
5.4 ≤ x ≤ 6.60.850.85x + 71.37
6.6 ≤ x ≤ 7.8−64.1564.15(7.8 − x)

(Sagging moment and the usual sign convention: upward force on the left of the section gives positive shear.)

Ordinates

x (m)V (kN)M (kN·m)
000
1.8⁻ (left of A)−4.50−2.70
1.8⁺ (right of A)+36.85−2.70
3.623.3541.35(1.8) − 0.463(3.6)³ = 52.83
5.40.8575.96
6.6⁻0.8576.98
6.6⁺−64.1576.98
7.8−64.150

Diagrams and salient features

 SFD (kN):  +36.85 just right of A
            decreases (parabola) to +0.85 at x = 5.4
            stays +0.85 to x = 6.6, jumps to −64.15
            constant −64.15 to B

 BMD (kN·m): 0 at O, −2.70 at A (hogging),
            0 at x = 1.87, +75.96 at x = 5.4,
            +76.98 at x = 6.6 (maximum), 0 at B
  • Shear changes abruptly by +41.35 kN at the roller A, and by −65 kN at the point load (from +0.85 to −64.15 kN).
  • The shear is 0.85 kN, almost zero, between x = 5.4 m and 6.6 m, so the bending moment is nearly flat there: the maximum moment is 76.98 kN·m at x = 6.6 m (under the 65 kN load), where the shear changes sign.
  • A small hogging moment of 2.70 kN·m occurs over the support A (cantilever overhang); the moment changes sign at x ≈ 1.87 m (point of contraflexure, from 41.35(x − 1.8) = 0.463x³).
  • Shear is a parabola over the triangular load (V falls by 1.389x²); the moment is a cubic curve there, a straight line under no load.
  • The moment is zero at the pin B (end of the simply supported span).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Applied Mechanics chapter 6 questions →