Skip to main content

Stability of 56/[s(s⁴+7s³+6s²+42s+8)] feedback system

Short answer

Characteristic equation s^5+7s^4+6s^3+42s^2+8s+56=0. Routh array yields a zero row; auxiliary equation gives roots ±j√2 and ±j2. No sign changes, so system is marginally stable with sustained oscillations at 1.414 and 2 rad/s.

Check stability of the system as given below in block diagram. [Figure: unity negative feedback system with forward path G(s) = 56/[s(s⁴ + 7s³ + 6s² + 42s + 8)]]

Result: the system is marginally stable. It has roots at ±j2\pm j\sqrt2 and ±j2\pm j2, one root at s=−7s=-7, and none in the RHP.

For unity negative feedback, the characteristic equation is 1+G(s)=01+G(s)=0. Its Routh array is formed and the first column is examined.

Characteristic equation

s(s4+7s3+6s2+42s+8)+56=0s5+7s4+6s3+42s2+8s+56=0\begin{aligned} s(s^4+7s^3+6s^2+42s+8) + 56 &= 0 \\ s^5 + 7s^4 + 6s^3 + 42s^2 + 8s + 56 &= 0 \end{aligned}

Routh array

RowCol 1Col 2Col 3
s5s^5168
s4s^474256
s3s^37(6)−427=0\frac{7(6)-42}{7}=07(8)−567=0\frac{7(8)-56}{7}=0

The s3s^3 row is all zeros. Auxiliary equation from the s4s^4 row:

A(s)=7s4+42s2+56,dAds=28s3+84sA(s) = 7s^4 + 42s^2 + 56, \qquad \frac{dA}{ds} = 28s^3 + 84s
RowCol 1Col 2
s3s^32884
s2s^228(42)−7(84)28=21\frac{28(42)-7(84)}{28}=2156
s1s^121(84)−28(56)21=9.33\frac{21(84)-28(56)}{21}=9.33
s0s^056

First column: 1, 7, 28, 21, 9.33, 561,\ 7,\ 28,\ 21,\ 9.33,\ 56. No sign change, so no root is in the RHP.

Roots on the imaginary axis

7s4+42s2+56=7(s2+2)(s2+4)=0⇒s=±j1.414, ±j27s^4+42s^2+56 = 7(s^2+2)(s^2+4) = 0 \Rightarrow s = \pm j1.414,\ \pm j2

The fifth root: q(s)(s2+2)(s2+4)=s+7\frac{q(s)}{(s^2+2)(s^2+4)} = s+7, so s=−7s=-7.

RegionRoots
RHPnone
jωj\omega axis±j1.414\pm j1.414, ±j2\pm j2 (non-repeated)
LHP−7-7

Conclusion

The poles on the jωj\omega axis are simple (non-repeated), and none are in the RHP. The system is marginally stable: its response contains sustained oscillations at 1.414 rad/s and 2 rad/s.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Control Systems chapter 4 questions →