Skip to main content

Meissner effect and hard superconductors

Short answer

The Meissner effect is the complete expulsion of magnetic flux from a superconductor below T_c, making it a perfect diamagnet (B=0). Type-I have a single low H_c, sharp transition; type-II have two critical fields (H_c1, H_c2) and a mixed vortex state. Type-II is hard because flux vortices get pinned at defects, causing hysteresis and enabling high critical current densities in strong fields.

What is Meissner effect? Explain the difference between type I and type II superconductors. Type II superconductor is also called hard superconductor, why?

Meissner effect

Meissner effect is the complete expulsion of magnetic flux from the interior of a material when it is cooled below its critical temperature TcT_c in a weak magnetic field (H<HcH < H_c). The superconductor becomes a perfect diamagnet.

Inside the superconductor:

B=μ0(H+M)=0⇒M=−H,χm=MH=−1\begin{aligned} B &= \mu_0 (H + M) = 0 \\ \Rightarrow M &= -H, \quad \chi_m = \frac{M}{H} = -1 \end{aligned}

Screening currents flow in a thin surface layer (the London penetration depth, λL≈10\lambda_L \approx 10 to 100100 nm) and create a field that exactly cancels the applied field inside.

   T > Tc (normal)        T < Tc (superconducting)
   | | | | | | |           \ \         / /
   | |+-----+| |            \ \ +---+ / /
   | ||     || |   cool      ) )|   |( (
   | ||     || |   ---->    / / +---+ \ \
   | |+-----+| |           / /         \ \
   | | | | | | |      flux lines bend around it

The effect is independent of history: whether the field is applied before or after cooling, the flux is expelled. This shows a superconductor is not just a perfect conductor (a perfect conductor would trap the flux present at cooling).

Type-I vs type-II superconductors

 -M                         -M
  |    /|                    |   /\
  |   / |                    |  /  \
  |  /  |                    | /    \_
  | /   |                    |/       \__
  |/    |____ H              +----|------|--- H
  0    Hc                    0   Hc1    Hc2
   Type-I                     Type-II
PointType-IType-II
Critical fieldsOne, HcH_cHc1H_{c1} and Hc2H_{c2}
Meissner effectComplete up to HcH_cComplete only below Hc1H_{c1}
TransitionSharpGradual, via mixed (vortex) state
Field valuesLow (below about 0.2 T)Hc2H_{c2} up to tens of tesla
ExamplesPb, Hg, Sn, AlNbTi, Nb3_3Sn, YBCO

Why type-II is called a hard superconductor

  • It stays superconducting up to a very high field Hc2H_{c2}, so superconductivity is hard to destroy.
  • In the mixed state, flux vortices get pinned at defects, dislocations and impurities. This makes the magnetization irreversible with a large hysteresis loop, just like a hard magnetic material.
  • Because of pinning, it can carry a large critical current density in strong fields.
  • Most are alloys or compounds that are mechanically hard and brittle (e.g. Nb3_3Sn).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Electrical Engineering Material chapter 5 questions →