- Asked 2/13
- 2074 Asoj · 4 marks
- 2072 Chaitra · 2+3 marks
Ampere's law vs continuity equation
Short answer
Static Ampere's law ∇×H = J implies ∇·J = 0, contradicting continuity ∇·J = −∂ρ_v/∂t for time-varying fields. Maxwell corrected it by adding displacement current ∂D/∂t: ∇×H = J + ∂D/∂t, making it consistent.
How does ∇×H = J conflict with the continuity equation in time varying fields? How is this conflict rectified (corrected) in such fields?
The conflict
Ampere's law for static fields is ∇×H = J. Take the divergence of both sides. The divergence of a curl is always zero:
∇·(∇×H) = 0 = ∇·J
So Ampere's law demands ∇·J = 0. But the continuity equation (conservation of charge) states
∇·J = −∂ρ_v/∂t
For time-varying fields ∂ρ_v/∂t ≠ 0 (for example, charging a capacitor), so ∇·J ≠ 0. The two equations contradict each other. Ampere's law is valid only for steady (DC) currents.
The correction (Maxwell's displacement current)
Add an unknown term J_d to the right side: ∇×H = J + J_d. Then ∇·J + ∇·J_d = 0, so ∇·J_d = −∇·J = ∂ρ_v/∂t. Using Gauss's law ρ_v = ∇·D:
∇·J_d = ∂(∇·D)/∂t = ∇·(∂D/∂t) → J_d = ∂D/∂t
The corrected equation is
∇×H = J + ∂D/∂t
Now ∇·(J + ∂D/∂t) = 0, which agrees with continuity. The term ∂D/∂t is the displacement current density (A/m²). It flows in the dielectric between capacitor plates and completes the current loop, even though no real charges move across the gap. In integral form: ∮H·dl = I_conduction + I_displacement.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Fields from time varying B · Electromagnetism, chapter 3
- State Ampere's circuital law · Electromagnetism, chapter 3 · asked 2×
- Ampere's law and boundary H components · Electromagnetism, chapter 3
- Relaxation time constant from continuity · Electromagnetism, chapter 2 · asked 2×
- Derive continuity equation · Electromagnetism, chapter 2 · asked 2×
- Faraday's law and modified Maxwell equations · Electromagnetism, chapter 3
- Biot-Savart vs Ampere's law, coil axis · Engineering Physics, chapter 8
- Ampere's law, Maxwell's modification · Engineering Physics, chapter 9
- Ampere's law, field of straight wire · Engineering Physics, chapter 8 · asked 5×
- Maxwell's equations and continuity equation · Engineering Physics, chapter 9 · asked 2×