- 2068 Chaitra · 5 marks
Determinant identity proof
Prove that [a b c; b c a; c a b]² (determinant squared) = [2bc−a² c² b²; c² 2ac−b² a²; b² a² 2ab−c²] (determinant) = (a³ + b³ + c³ − 3abc)².
Let D = |a b c; b c a; c a b| and let Δ be the determinant on the right-hand side:
Δ = | 2bc−a² c² b² |
| c² 2ca−b² a² |
| b² a² 2ab−c² |
Step 1: Evaluate D
Add C₂ and C₃ to C₁: every entry of C₁ becomes s = a + b + c.
D = s | 1 b c |
| 1 c a |
| 1 a b |
R₂ → R₂ − R₁, R₃ → R₃ − R₁:
D = s | 1 b c |
| 0 c−b a−c |
| 0 a−b b−c |
= s[(c−b)(b−c) − (a−c)(a−b)]
= −s[(b−c)² + (a−c)(a−b)]
= −s(a² + b² + c² − ab − bc − ca)
= −(a³ + b³ + c³ − 3abc)
So D² = (a³ + b³ + c³ − 3abc)², which proves the first and last members are equal.
Step 2: Show Δ = D²
Let G = [−a −b −c; c a b; b c a]. Multiply D by G (row by column):
D·G = [a b c][−a −b −c]
[b c a][ c a b]
[c a b][ b c a]
- (1,1): −a² + bc + cb = 2bc − a²
- (1,2): −ab + ab + c² = c²
- (1,3): −ac + b² + ac = b²
- (2,1): −ab + c² + ab = c²
- (2,2): −b² + ac + ca = 2ca − b²
- (2,3): −bc + bc + a² = a²
- (3,1): −ac + ac + b² = b²
- (3,2): −bc + a² + bc = a²
- (3,3): −c² + ab + ba = 2ab − c²
So D·G is exactly the matrix whose determinant is Δ. Therefore Δ = |D|·|G|.
Step 3: |G| = D
Take (−1) out of R₁ of G: |G| = −|a b c; c a b; b c a|. The matrix [a b c; c a b; b c a] is D with R₂ and R₃ interchanged, so its determinant is −D. Hence |G| = −(−D) = D.
Conclusion
Δ = |D|·|G| = D · D = D² = (a³ + b³ + c³ − 3abc)²
Thus |a b c; b c a; c a b|² = Δ = (a³ + b³ + c³ − 3abc)². ∎
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Determinant identity proof · Mathematics III, chapter 1 · asked 9×
- Determinant identity proof · Mathematics III, chapter 1 · asked 9×
- Determinant identity proof · Mathematics III, chapter 1 · asked 9×
- Determinant identity proof · Mathematics III, chapter 1 · asked 9×
- Determinant identity proof · Mathematics III, chapter 1 · asked 6×
- Determinant identity proof · Mathematics III, chapter 1 · asked 6×
- Scalar triple product squared identity · Mathematics, chapter 5 · asked 3×
- Proof that √2 is irrational · Discrete Structure, chapter 1 · asked 3×