Skip to main content

Periodic signal whose Fourier series fails

"Even if a signal is periodic, its Fourier series might not exist." Justify the statement using three different examples.

A periodic signal has a Fourier series that converges to it only if it meets the Dirichlet conditions over one period: (1) absolutely integrable, (2) finite number of maxima and minima, (3) finite number of finite discontinuities. Periodicity alone is not enough. Three periodic signals (period T=1T = 1) that each break one condition:

Example 1: not absolutely integrable

x(t)=1t,0<t≤1,repeated with period 1x(t) = \frac{1}{t}, \quad 0 < t \le 1, \quad \text{repeated with period } 1 ∫01∣1t∣dt=[ln⁡t]01=∞\int_0^1\left|\frac{1}{t}\right|dt = \left[\ln t\right]_0^1 = \infty

The coefficients ak=∫011te−j2πktdta_k = \int_0^1 \frac{1}{t}e^{-j2\pi kt}dt are not finite, so the series does not exist.

Example 2: infinite number of maxima and minima

x(t)=sin⁡(2πt),0<t≤1,period 1x(t) = \sin\left(\frac{2\pi}{t}\right), \quad 0 < t \le 1, \quad \text{period } 1

It is bounded and absolutely integrable (∫01∣x∣ dt<1\int_0^1|x|\,dt < 1), so its coefficients can be computed. But as t→0t \to 0 it oscillates infinitely fast, giving infinitely many maxima and minima in one period, so the series is no longer guaranteed to converge to x(t)x(t).

Example 3: infinite number of discontinuities

A staircase signal over 0≤t<10 \le t < 1 that equals 1 on [0,1/2)[0, 1/2), 1/21/2 on [1/2,3/4)[1/2, 3/4), 1/41/4 on [3/4,7/8)[3/4, 7/8), and so on (each step half the height and half the length of the previous one), repeated every 1 s.

It is bounded and ∫01∣x∣ dt<1\int_0^1|x|\,dt < 1, but it has an infinite number of discontinuities within one period, so it violates the third condition and convergence of its series to x(t)x(t) is not guaranteed.

ExampleCondition violated
1/t1/t on (0,1](0, 1]absolute integrability
sin⁡(2π/t)\sin(2\pi/t)finite maxima/minima
halving staircasefinite discontinuities

So even though all three are periodic, a proper Fourier series representation is not guaranteed: for the first signal the coefficients do not even exist, and for the other two the series is not guaranteed to converge to the signal. Such signals are mathematical curiosities; practical signals usually meet the Dirichlet conditions.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Signals and Systems chapter 2 questions →