Skip to main content

Arch 32 m: two rolling loads, max +/- moment at 8 m

Short answer

32 m span, 8 m rise three-hinged parabolic arch with rolling loads 80 kN (leading) and 40 kN, 3 m apart moving right to left. At 8 m: max +BM = 285 kN m (V=46.96 kN, N=98.95 kN) when loads at 8 m and 11 m; max −BM = –225 kN m (V=0, N=125.78 kN) when loads at crown and 19 m.

A three hinged symmetric parabolic arch has a span of 32 m and a rise of 8 m. It is subjected to two rolling loads of magnitudes 80 kN and 40 kN separately by a distance of 3 m. The load moves from right to left with 80 kN load leading. Determine the maximum positive moment and negative moment at a section 8 m from the left support.

Data: symmetrical parabolic three-hinged arch, L=32L = 32 m, f=8f = 8 m, y=4×8 x(32−x)322=x(32−x)32y = \dfrac{4\times 8\,x(32-x)}{32^2} = \dfrac{x(32-x)}{32}. Two loads, 80 kN (leading) and 40 kN, 3 m apart, move from right to left (so the 40 kN load is 3 m to the right of the 80 kN load). Section at x=8x = 8 m from the left support: y=6y = 6 m, tan⁡θ=32−1632=0.5\tan\theta = \dfrac{32-16}{32} = 0.5, θ=26.57∘\theta = 26.57^\circ.

ILDs for the section at x = 8 m

Thrust ILD: H=x′2fH = \dfrac{x'}{2f} (load left of the crown) or L−x′2f\dfrac{L-x'}{2f} (right of the crown), peak L4f=1\dfrac{L}{4f} = 1 at the crown. Moment ILD: M=Mb−H yM = M_b - H\,y.

x (m)PointILD of HILD of M at section
0A00
8section D0.53
12.8neutral point0.80
16crown C1-2
32B00

The ILD of MM is zero at the neutral point, 12.8 m from AA; it is positive on one side and negative on the other.

Maximum positive bending moment

The critical position is: 80 kN at 8 m, 40 kN at 11 m (measured from AA).

Load (kN)Position (m)Ordinate of M-ILD (m)P x y (kN m)Ordinate of H-ILD
80832400.5
40111.125450.688
M=∑P y=285 kN m,H=∑P yH=67.5 kNM = \sum P\,y = 285\ \text{kN m}, \qquad H = \sum P\,y_H = 67.5\ \text{kN}

With y=6y = 6 m, θ=26.57∘\theta = 26.57^\circ and the simple-beam shear Vb=86.25V_b = 86.25 kN at the section:

V=Vbcos⁡θ−Hsin⁡θ=46.96 kNN=Vbsin⁡θ+Hcos⁡θ=98.95 kN\begin{aligned} V &= V_b\cos\theta - H\sin\theta = 46.96\ \text{kN}\\ N &= V_b\sin\theta + H\cos\theta = 98.95\ \text{kN} \end{aligned}

Maximum negative bending moment

The critical position is: 80 kN at 16 m, 40 kN at 19 m (measured from AA).

Load (kN)Position (m)Ordinate of M-ILD (m)P x y (kN m)Ordinate of H-ILD
8016-2-1601
4019-1.625-650.812
M=∑P y=−225 kN m,H=∑P yH=112.5 kNM = \sum P\,y = -225\ \text{kN m}, \qquad H = \sum P\,y_H = 112.5\ \text{kN}

With y=6y = 6 m, θ=26.57∘\theta = 26.57^\circ and the simple-beam shear Vb=56.25V_b = 56.25 kN at the section:

V=Vbcos⁡θ−Hsin⁡θ=0 kNN=Vbsin⁡θ+Hcos⁡θ=125.78 kN\begin{aligned} V &= V_b\cos\theta - H\sin\theta = 0\ \text{kN}\\ N &= V_b\sin\theta + H\cos\theta = 125.78\ \text{kN} \end{aligned}

Answer: maximum positive moment =+285= +285 kN m (80 kN at the section, 40 kN 3 m to its right); maximum negative moment =−225= -225 kN m (80 kN at 16 m, i.e. at the crown, and 40 kN at 19 m).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Theory of Structures I chapter 6 questions →