Skip to main content

Arch 40 m: ILDs for thrust, BM at 8 m, shear

Short answer

For a three-hinged parabolic arch, the ILD for horizontal thrust is triangular with peak 1.0 at the crown. The ILD for bending moment at a section 8 m from left support reaches +3.84 m at the section, zero at 15.38 m, and -2.4 m at the crown. ILDs for radial shear and normal thrust show jumps at the section due to load crossing.

A three hinged symmetrical parabolic arch has a span of 40 m and rise of 10 m. Draw ILD for: (i) horizontal thrust, (ii) BM at section 8 m from left support, (iii) ILD for normal thrust and radial shear at the same section.

Data: symmetrical three-hinged parabolic arch, L=40L = 40 m, f=10f = 10 m, y=4×10 x (40−x)402=x(40−x)40y = \dfrac{4\times 10\,x\,(40-x)}{40^2} = \dfrac{x(40-x)}{40}. Section DD at x=8x = 8 m: yD=6.4y_D = 6.4 m, tan⁡θ=40−1640=0.6\tan\theta = \dfrac{40-16}{40} = 0.6, θ=30.96∘\theta = 30.96^\circ, sin⁡θ=0.5145\sin\theta = 0.5145, cos⁡θ=0.8575\cos\theta = 0.8575.

(i) ILD of horizontal thrust

For a unit load at x′x', the simple-beam moment at the crown is x′2\dfrac{x'}{2} (left half) or 40−x′2\dfrac{40-x'}{2} (right half), so

H=MCf=x′20 (x′≤20),40−x′20 (x′≥20)H = \frac{M_C}{f} = \frac{x'}{20}\ (x'\le 20), \qquad \frac{40-x'}{20}\ (x'\ge 20)

This is a triangle with a peak of 1.01.0 at the crown and zero at AA and BB.

(ii) ILD of bending moment at D

MD=Mb−H yDM_D = M_b - H\,y_D, with Mb=x′(40−8)40=0.8x′M_b = \dfrac{x'(40-8)}{40} = 0.8x' for x′≤8x'\le 8 and 8(40−x′)40=0.2 (40−x′)\dfrac{8(40-x')}{40} = 0.2\,(40-x') for x′≥8x'\ge 8.

  • Load left of DD: MD=0.8x′−x′20(6.4)=0.48 x′M_D = 0.8x' - \dfrac{x'}{20}(6.4) = 0.48\,x' (so +3.84+3.84 m at DD)
  • Load between DD and CC: MD=0.2 (40−x′)−0.32 x′=8−0.52 x′M_D = 0.2\,(40-x') - 0.32\,x' = 8 - 0.52\,x' (so −2.4-2.4 m at the crown)
  • Load right of CC: MD=0.2 (40−x′)−0.05 (40−x′)(6.4)=−0.12 (40−x′)M_D = 0.2\,(40-x') - 0.05\,(40-x')(6.4) = -0.12\,(40-x')

The neutral point is at s0=L23L−2a=1600120−16=15.38s_0 = \dfrac{L^2}{3L-2a} = \dfrac{1600}{120-16} = 15.38 m.

(iii) ILDs of radial shear and normal thrust at D

V=Vbcos⁡θ−Hsin⁡θ,N=Vbsin⁡θ+Hcos⁡θV = V_b\cos\theta - H\sin\theta, \qquad N = V_b\sin\theta + H\cos\theta

with Vb=−x′40V_b = -\dfrac{x'}{40} for a load left of DD and 40−x′40\dfrac{40-x'}{40} for a load right of DD.

Ordinates

Load at x' (m)HM (m)V (radial)N
00000
40.21.92-0.18860.12
8-0.43.84-0.37730.2401
8+0.43.840.48020.7546
120.61.760.29150.8746
160.8-0.320.10290.9947
201-2.4-0.08571.1147
240.8-1.92-0.06860.8918
280.6-1.44-0.05140.6688
320.4-0.96-0.03430.4459
360.2-0.48-0.01710.2229
400000

(The two rows at 8 m show the jumps in VV (=cos⁡θ=0.8575=\cos\theta = 0.8575) and in NN (=sin⁡θ=0.5145=\sin\theta = 0.5145) as the unit load crosses the section.)

Shapes

  • H: triangle, 0 at AA, 1.0 at the crown, 0 at BB.
  • M at D: 0 at AA, rises to +3.84+3.84 m at DD, falls to zero at the neutral point (15.3815.38 m) and to −2.4-2.4 m at the crown, and returns to 0 at BB.
  • V at D: negative from AA to just left of DD (−0.3773-0.3773), jumps up by cos⁡θ=0.8575\cos\theta = 0.8575 to +0.4802+0.4802 just right of DD, then decreases linearly to zero at x′=18.18x' = 18.18 m; it is negative from there to BB (−0.0857-0.0857 at the crown, then rising linearly to 0 at BB).
  • N at D: positive (compressive) throughout; it rises to 0.24010.2401 just left of DD, jumps by sin⁡θ=0.5145\sin\theta = 0.5145 to 0.75460.7546, rises to 1.11471.1147 at the crown and falls linearly to 0 at BB.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Theory of Structures I chapter 6 questions →