Skip to main content

Critical position of UDL shorter than span

Short answer

Place the UDL so that the section divides the load in the same ratio as it divides the span: c/l = a/L, where c is load length left of the section, l is total load length, a is distance from left support. Equating end ordinates of the ILD under the load yields this critical condition.

Using influence line diagram, determine the most critical position of a stretch of uniformly distributed load shorter than the span to give maximum bending moment at a given section of a simply supported beam. (Prove that the bending moment is maximum when the section divides the span and the load in the same ratio.)

A UDL shorter than the span gives maximum bending moment at a section when the load is placed so that the section divides the span and the load in the same ratio.

ILD for bending moment at section C

Simply supported beam ABAB, span LL; section CC at aa from AA, b=L−ab = L-a. The ILD for MCM_C is a triangle with peak yC=ab/Ly_C = ab/L under CC.

        A      c    C   (l-c)    B
        o------+----+-------+----o
  ILD:         y1  ab/L     y2

Ordinate left of CC at distance xx from AA: y=xbLy = \dfrac{xb}{L}. Right of CC at distance xx from BB: y=xaLy = \dfrac{xa}{L}.

Proof

Let a UDL of intensity ww and length ll (< LL) have a length cc on the left of CC and (l−c)(l-c) on the right. Ordinates under its ends are

y1=(a−c) bL,y2={b−(l−c)} aLy_1 = \frac{(a-c)\,b}{L}, \qquad y_2 = \frac{\{b-(l-c)\}\,a}{L}

MC=w×(area under ILD below the load)M_C = w\times(\text{area under ILD below the load}). Shift the load by a small distance dxdx to the right. The left end loses a strip of height y1y_1 and the right end gains a strip of height y2y_2, so

dMCdx=w (y2−y1)\frac{dM_C}{dx} = w\,(y_2 - y_1)

MCM_C is maximum when dMC/dx=0dM_C/dx = 0, i.e. y1=y2y_1 = y_2:

(a−c) b=(b−l+c) aab−cb=ab−la+cac(a+b)=la⇒cl=aL\begin{aligned} (a-c)\,b &= (b-l+c)\,a \\ ab - cb &= ab - la + ca \\ c(a+b) &= la \Rightarrow \frac{c}{l} = \frac{a}{L} \end{aligned}

Hence the part of the load on the left of CC is to the whole load as the left part of the span is to the whole span:

cl=aL\frac{c}{l} = \frac{a}{L}

Maximum moment

With c=la/Lc = la/L the end ordinates are equal: y1=y2=abL(1−lL)y_1 = y_2 = \dfrac{ab}{L}\left(1-\dfrac{l}{L}\right). The area under the load is two trapezoids:

Mmax=w l2(abL+y1)=w l abL(1−l2L)M_{max} = w\,\frac{l}{2}\left(\frac{ab}{L} + y_1\right) = w\,l\,\frac{ab}{L}\left(1 - \frac{l}{2L}\right)

Result: place the UDL so that the section divides the load in the ratio a:ba : b, the same as it divides the span.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Theory of Structures I chapter 5 questions →