Skip to main content

Band pass (1 krad/s, 100 rad/s) from 4th order ladder

Short answer

Frequency transformation converts a normalized LP prototype (s→(s²+ω₀²)/(Bs) for BP) so all filter types derive from one set of tables, preserving response characteristics. For 4th-order Butterworth, ω₀=1000 rad/s, B=100 rad/s: series arms 7.654 mH+130.7 µF and 18.48 mH+54.11 µF; shunt arms 54.11 µH∥18.48 mF and 130.7 µH∥7.654 mF; terminations 1 Ω.

What is frequency transformation? What are the importance? Obtain a band pass filter having band center (ω0) at 1K rad/sec and bandwidth of 100 rad/sec from fourth order Butterworth lowpass ladder circuit. [Refer Table 2]

Frequency transformation is the change of the complex-frequency variable ss in a normalized low-pass prototype (cut-off ω=1\omega = 1 rad/s) so that the same circuit or transfer function gives a high-pass, band-pass or band-stop response, or a low-pass response at another frequency. Typical substitutions are s→s/ωps \to s/\omega_p (LP→LP), s→ωp/ss \to \omega_p/s (LP→HP) and s→s2+ω02Bss \to \dfrac{s^2+\omega_0^2}{Bs} (LP→BP).

Importance

  • Only one set of design tables (Butterworth, Chebyshev, Bessel low-pass prototypes) is needed; every other filter type is derived from it.
  • The approximation is done once, on the simple low-pass problem; the transformed filter keeps the same ripple and selectivity. Note that a band-pass or band-stop filter has twice the order of the prototype (here a 4th-order low-pass gives an 8th-order band-pass).
  • Element values can be converted directly in the circuit (each LL and CC is replaced by a simple combination), so no new synthesis is needed.
  • Normalized values (ω=1\omega = 1, 1 Ω1\ \Omega) are easy to handle and are later scaled to practical values.

Band-pass design

Prototype (Table 2, 4th-order Butterworth, Rs=RL=1 ΩR_s = R_L = 1\ \Omega, ωc=1\omega_c = 1 rad/s): g1=0.7654g_1 = 0.7654, g2=1.848g_2 = 1.848, g3=1.848g_3 = 1.848, g4=0.7654g_4 = 0.7654. Taking the ladder that starts with a series inductor: L1=0.7654L_1 = 0.7654 H (series), C2=1.848C_2 = 1.848 F (shunt), L3=1.848L_3 = 1.848 H (series), C4=0.7654C_4 = 0.7654 F (shunt).

Given ω0=1000\omega_0 = 1000 rad/s and B=100B = 100 rad/s, so ω02=106\omega_0^2 = 10^6.

LP → BP rules (substitute s→s2+ω02Bss \to \dfrac{s^2+\omega_0^2}{Bs}):

Prototype elementBecomesValues
Series LLseries L′L'–C′C' (series resonant)L′=L/BL' = L/B, C′=B/(Lω02)C' = B/(L\omega_0^2)
Shunt CCshunt L′′∥C′′L'' \parallel C'' (parallel resonant)C′′=C/BC'' = C/B, L′′=B/(Cω02)L'' = B/(C\omega_0^2)
ResistorunchangedRR

Each new pair resonates at ω0\omega_0 since L′C′=L′′C′′=1/ω02L'C' = L''C'' = 1/\omega_0^2.

Calculations

L1′=0.7654100=7.654 mH,C1′=1000.7654×106=130.65 μFC2′′=1.848100=18.48 mF,L2′′=1001.848×106=54.11 μHL3′=1.848100=18.48 mH,C3′=1001.848×106=54.11 μFC4′′=0.7654100=7.654 mF,L4′′=1000.7654×106=130.65 μH\begin{aligned} L_1' &= \frac{0.7654}{100} = 7.654\ \text{mH}, & C_1' &= \frac{100}{0.7654\times10^6} = 130.65\ \mu\text{F} \\ C_2'' &= \frac{1.848}{100} = 18.48\ \text{mF}, & L_2'' &= \frac{100}{1.848\times10^6} = 54.11\ \mu\text{H} \\ L_3' &= \frac{1.848}{100} = 18.48\ \text{mH}, & C_3' &= \frac{100}{1.848\times10^6} = 54.11\ \mu\text{F} \\ C_4'' &= \frac{0.7654}{100} = 7.654\ \text{mF}, & L_4'' &= \frac{100}{0.7654\times10^6} = 130.65\ \mu\text{H} \end{aligned}
ArmTypeLLCC
1series L–C7.654 mH130.65 µF
2shunt L ∥ C54.11 µH18.48 mF
3series L–C18.48 mH54.11 µF
4shunt L ∥ C130.65 µH7.654 mF

Terminations stay Rs=RL=1 ΩR_s = R_L = 1\ \Omega.

o-[Rs]-[L1 C1]-+-[L3 C3]-+-----+
               |         |     |
          [L2||C2]  [L4||C4]  [RL]
               |         |     |
o--------------+---------+-----+

Check: L1′C1′=7.654×10−3×130.65×10−6=10−6=1/ω02L_1'C_1' = 7.654\times10^{-3}\times130.65\times10^{-6} = 10^{-6} = 1/\omega_0^2. The resulting filter is 8th order, centred at 1000 rad/s with a 3 dB bandwidth of 100 rad/s. For practical values, the circuit may finally be impedance scaled (e.g. to 1 kΩ: multiply each LL by 1000, divide each CC by 1000).

Answer: series arms 7.654 mH + 130.65 µF and 18.48 mH + 54.11 µF; shunt arms 54.11 µH ∥ 18.48 mF and 130.65 µH ∥ 7.654 mF, with 1 Ω terminations.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Sonnet 5.5

All Filter Design chapter 3 questions →