Skip to main content

Valid RC admittance; Foster II and RC ladder

Short answer

Y(s) = (s+1)(s+3)/((s+2)(s+4)) is a valid RC admittance because its poles and zeros are simple, negative real, alternate with a zero nearest the origin. Foster‑II: shunt 8/3 Ω, series 4 Ω + 1/8 F, series 8/3 Ω + 3/32 F. RC ladder: series 1 Ω, shunt 0.5 F, series 4/3 Ω, shunt 1.5 F, series 1/3 Ω.

Which of the following function is valid RC admittance function? State with reason. Realize one of the RC admittance function in Foster II and RC ladder form. Y(s) = (s+1)(s+3)/((s+2)(s+4)); Y(s) = (s²+1)(s²+3)/(s(s²+2)(s²+4)); Y(s) = (s+2)(s+4)/((s+1)(s+3)); Y(s) = (s+1)(s+3)/(s(s+2)(s+4))

Testing the functions

An RC driving-point admittance YRC(s)Y_{RC}(s) (same form as ZRLZ_{RL}) must have:

  1. Simple poles and zeros on the negative real axis, alternating.
  2. The critical frequency nearest the origin is a zero (or Y(0)Y(0) is a finite constant); there is no pole at s=0s=0.
  3. The critical frequency farthest from the origin is a pole (it may be at s=∞s=\infty).
  4. YRC(∞)≥YRC(0)Y_{RC}(\infty) \ge Y_{RC}(0).
  5. Residues of YRC(s)/sY_{RC}(s)/s are real and positive.
FunctionCritical frequenciesResult
(s+1)(s+3)(s+2)(s+4)\dfrac{(s+1)(s+3)}{(s+2)(s+4)}z 1, p 2, z 3, p 4Lowest a zero, highest a pole, alternate; Y(0)=0.375<Y(∞)=1Y(0)=0.375 < Y(\infty)=1 → valid
(s2+1)(s2+3)s(s2+2)(s2+4)\dfrac{(s^2+1)(s^2+3)}{s(s^2+2)(s^2+4)}on jωj\omega axisLC type, not RC → invalid
(s+2)(s+4)(s+1)(s+3)\dfrac{(s+2)(s+4)}{(s+1)(s+3)}p 1, z 2, p 3, z 4Lowest is a pole; Y(0)>Y(∞)Y(0) > Y(\infty) → invalid (it is an RC impedance)
(s+1)(s+3)s(s+2)(s+4)\dfrac{(s+1)(s+3)}{s(s+2)(s+4)}p 0, z 1, p 2, z 3, p 4Pole at origin and Y(∞)=0<Y(0)Y(\infty)=0 < Y(0) → invalid

Realize Y(s)=(s+1)(s+3)(s+2)(s+4)=s2+4s+3s2+6s+8Y(s) = \dfrac{(s+1)(s+3)}{(s+2)(s+4)} = \dfrac{s^2+4s+3}{s^2+6s+8}.

Foster-II (parallel) form

Expand Y(s)/sY(s)/s in partial fractions and multiply back by ss:

k0=Y(0)=38k2=[(s+2)Y(s)s]s=−2=14k3=[(s+4)Y(s)s]s=−4=38\begin{aligned} k_0 &= Y(0) = \frac{3}{8} \\ k_{2} &= \left[\frac{(s+2)Y(s)}{s}\right]_{s=-2} = \frac{1}{4} \\ k_{3} &= \left[\frac{(s+4)Y(s)}{s}\right]_{s=-4} = \frac{3}{8} \end{aligned} Y(s)=38+s4(s+2)+3s8(s+4)Y(s) = \frac{3}{8} + \frac{s}{4 \left(s + 2\right)} + \frac{3 s}{8 \left(s + 4\right)}
TermRuleElement value
R1R_1 (shunt)1/k01/k_08/3 Ω (≈ 2.667 Ω)
R2R_2–C2C_2 in series (pole at −2-2)R=1/kR=1/k, C=k/σC=k/\sigmaR2R_2 = 4 Ω, C2C_2 = 1/8 F (≈ 0.125 F)
R3R_3–C3C_3 in series (pole at −4-4)R=1/kR=1/k, C=k/σC=k/\sigmaR3R_3 = 8/3 Ω (≈ 2.667 Ω), C3C_3 = 3/32 F (≈ 0.09375 F)
o--+-------+-------+
   |       |       |
  [R1]    [R2]    [R3]
   |      [C2]    [C3]
   |       |       |
o--+-------+-------+

Check: Y(∞)=38+14+38=1Y(\infty) = \tfrac{3}{8}+\tfrac{1}{4}+\tfrac{3}{8} = 1 ✓.

RC ladder (Cauer-I) form

Use Z(s)=1/Y(s)=(s+2)(s+4)(s+1)(s+3)Z(s) = 1/Y(s) = \dfrac{(s+2)(s+4)}{(s+1)(s+3)}; Z(∞)=1Z(\infty) = 1, so the ladder starts with a series resistor.

Divide with descending powers (continued fraction about s=∞s=\infty). For an RC impedance the quotients alternate between a constant (series RR) and ksks (shunt CC):

  1. Z1(s)=s2+6s+8s2+4s+3Z_1(s) = \frac{s^{2} + 6 s + 8}{s^{2} + 4 s + 3} → remove 11, giving series R1R_1 = 1 Ω; remainder 2s+5(s+1)(s+3)\frac{2 s + 5}{\left(s + 1\right) \left(s + 3\right)}.
  2. Y2(s)=s2+4s+32s+5Y_2(s) = \frac{s^{2} + 4 s + 3}{2 s + 5} → remove s2\frac{s}{2}, giving shunt C2C_2 = 1/2 F (≈ 0.5 F); remainder 3(s+2)2(2s+5)\frac{3 \left(s + 2\right)}{2 \left(2 s + 5\right)}.
  3. Z3(s)=4s+103s+6Z_3(s) = \frac{4 s + 10}{3 s + 6} → remove 43\frac{4}{3}, giving series R3R_3 = 4/3 Ω (≈ 1.333 Ω); remainder 23(s+2)\frac{2}{3 \left(s + 2\right)}.
  4. Y4(s)=3s+62Y_4(s) = \frac{3 s + 6}{2} → remove 3s2\frac{3 s}{2}, giving shunt C4C_4 = 3/2 F (≈ 1.5 F); remainder 33.
  5. Z5(s)=13Z_5(s) = \frac{1}{3} → remove 13\frac{1}{3}, giving series R5R_5 = 1/3 Ω (≈ 0.3333 Ω); remainder 00.
ElementPositionValue
R1R_1series1 Ω
C2C_2shunt1/2 F (≈ 0.5 F)
R3R_3series4/3 Ω (≈ 1.333 Ω)
C4C_4shunt3/2 F (≈ 1.5 F)
R5R_5series1/3 Ω (≈ 0.3333 Ω)
o--[R1]----+---[R3]----+---[R5]-+
           |           |        |
         [C2]        [C4]       |
           |           |        |
o----------+-----------+--------+

✓ Answer checked by Claude Sonnet 5.5

All Filter Design chapter 4 questions →