Skip to main content

Strut loads in braced cut

Short answer

Using Peck's soft-to-medium clay diagram, apparent pressure pa = 60 kN/m². Hinge method gives reactions per metre: A=97, B=143, C=138, D=147 kN/m. With 2 m spacing, strut loads are A=194 kN, B=286 kN, C=276 kN, D=294 kN.

Determine the forces in the struts for the bracing system shown in figure below. Assume hinges at the levels B and C. Take the spacing of the struts in each strut level as 2.0 m. [Figure: braced cut 10.0 m deep with four strut levels A, B, C, D numbered (1) to (4) at depths 1.5 m, 4.0 m, 6.5 m and 9.0 m (spacings 1.5 m, 2.5 m, 2.5 m, 2.5 m, 1.0 m); soil γt=18 kN/m3\gamma_t = 18\ \text{kN/m}^3, c=30 kN/m2c = 30\ \text{kN/m}^2.]

Data: cut depth H=10H = 10 m, γ=18\gamma = 18 kN/m3^3, c=30c = 30 kN/m2^2 (clay), struts at A, B, C and D at 1.5, 4.0, 6.5 and 9.0 m, horizontal spacing 2.0 m, hinges at B and C.

1. Apparent pressure (Peck, clay)

γHc=18×1030=6>4 ⇒ soft to medium clay\frac{\gamma H}{c} = \frac{18\times10}{30} = 6 > 4\ \Rightarrow\ \text{soft to medium clay} pa=γH(1−4cγH)=180(1−120180)=60.0 kN/m2 (>0.3γH=54)p_a = \gamma H\left(1 - \frac{4c}{\gamma H}\right) = 180\left(1 - \frac{120}{180}\right) = 60.0\ \text{kN/m}^2\ (> 0.3\gamma H = 54)

The diagram rises from 0 at the top to 60 kN/m2^2 at 0.25H=2.50.25H = 2.5 m, then stays at 60 kN/m2^2 to the base (total load =525= 525 kN/m).

 0   |
     |\
 2.5 | 60
 A 1.5
 B 4.0  ---- 60 constant
 C 6.5
 D 9.0
10   |_____ 60

2. Reactions per metre run (hinge method)

  • Top part (0 to 4.0 m): load =165.0= 165.0 kN/m. Moments about A give the hinge reaction at B: RB1=68.0R_{B1} = 68.0 kN/m, so RA=165.0−68.0=97.0R_A = 165.0 - 68.0 = 97.0 kN/m.
  • Middle part (B to C, 2.5 m), simply supported with uniform pressure 60: RB2=RC1=60×2.5/2=75.0R_{B2} = R_{C1} = 60\times2.5/2 = 75.0 kN/m.
  • Bottom part (6.5 to 10 m): load =210= 210 kN/m. Moments about D give RC2=63.0R_{C2} = 63.0 kN/m, so RD=210−63.0=147.0R_D = 210 - 63.0 = 147.0 kN/m.
LevelReaction (kN/m)Strut load =R×2.0= R\times2.0 (kN)
A97.0194
B68.0 + 75.0 = 143.0286
C75.0 + 63.0 = 138.0276
D147.0294

Check: ∑R=97+143+138+147=525\sum R = 97 + 143 + 138 + 147 = 525 kN/m, which equals the total load of 525 kN/m.

Answer: strut loads A = 194 kN, B = 286 kN, C = 276 kN, D = 294 kN.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Sonnet 5.5

All Foundation Engineering chapter 4 questions →