- Asked 4/17
- 2075 Chaitra · 6 marks
- 2071 Shrawan · 2+3 marks
Negative binomial: definition and difference
Short answer
Negative binomial gives probability that rth success occurs on xth trial. It differs from binomial because number of trials is random, not fixed.
Define Negative Binomial distribution and explain characteristics. How does it differ from binomial distribution?
Definition
Consider repeated independent Bernoulli trials, each with probability of success p and failure q = 1 − p. The negative binomial distribution gives the probability that the r-th success occurs on the x-th trial.
P(X = x) = C(x − 1, r − 1) pʳ qˣ⁻ʳ , x = r, r + 1, r + 2, ...
The last (x-th) trial must be a success, and the previous x − 1 trials contain exactly r − 1 successes. Here r is a fixed positive integer and p is the parameter. It is written NB(r, p).
Characteristics
- The trials are independent and have only two outcomes, with constant p.
- The number of successes r is fixed; the number of trials X is random.
- The range of X is r, r + 1, r + 2, … (infinite and discrete).
- Mean: E(X) = r/p.
- Variance: Var(X) = rq/p², which is greater than the mean when q > p.
- For r = 1 it reduces to the geometric distribution: P(X = x) = q ˣ⁻¹ p.
- The sum of r independent geometric variables is negative binomial.
- If the number of failures Y = X − r is counted, P(Y = y) = C(y + r − 1, y) pʳ qʸ, with mean rq/p and variance rq/p².
Example: a player shoots until he scores 3 goals, with p = 0.4 per shot. The probability that the 3rd goal comes on the 5th shot is C(4, 2) (0.4)³ (0.6)² = 6 × 0.064 × 0.36 = 0.138.
Difference from the binomial distribution
| Basis | Binomial | Negative binomial |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed | Number of trials n | Number of successes r |
| Random variable | Number of successes | Number of trials needed |
| Possible values | 0, 1, …, n | r, r + 1, … |
| pmf | C(n, x) pˣ qⁿ⁻ˣ | C(x − 1, r − 1) pʳ qˣ⁻ʳ |
| Mean, variance | np, npq | r/p, rq/p² |
| Variance vs mean | Variance < mean | Variance > mean when q > p |
✓ Answer checked by Claude Sonnet 5.5
Related questions
- Binomial characteristics vs negative binomial · Probability and Statistics, chapter 2 · asked 4×
- Binomial characteristics vs hypergeometric · Probability and Statistics, chapter 2 · asked 4×
- Negative binomial definition and characteristics · Probability and Statistics, chapter 2 · asked 2×
- Binomial vs negative binomial differences · Probability and Statistics, chapter 2 · asked 4×
- Negative binomial: 5th hit on 10th throw · Probability and Statistics, chapter 2
- Discrete distribution; compare NB and binomial · Probability and Statistics, chapter 2
- Poisson definition; approximation to binomial · Probability and Statistics, chapter 2 · asked 2×
- Binomial definition and conditions · Probability and Statistics, chapter 2