- 2081 Bhadra (CS II) · 3+4 marks
PAM vs PPM; generation of PWM
Short answer
PAM varies pulse amplitude; PPM varies pulse position. PAM has poor noise immunity while PPM is robust. PWM is generated by comparing the message with a sawtooth: a comparator outputs a high pulse while the ramp is below the message, making pulse width proportional to the sample value.
Differentiate between pulse amplitude and pulse position modulation. Explain the generation of pulse width modulation.
PAM vs PPM
| Point | PAM | PPM |
|---|---|---|
| Parameter varied | Amplitude of pulses | Position (time) of pulses |
| Pulse width and amplitude | Width fixed, amplitude varies | Both fixed |
| Noise immunity | Poor (noise adds to amplitude) | Good (amplitude noise can be clipped) |
| Transmitter power | Varies with signal | Constant |
| Bandwidth | Depends on pulse width; lowest | Large (needs sharp, narrow pulses) |
| Synchronisation | Not critical | Needs accurate timing reference |
| Generation | Sample-and-hold | Derived from PWM (differentiate trailing edges) |
| Detection | LPF / hold | Convert to PWM, then LPF |
Generation of PWM
Pulse width modulation (PWM) keeps amplitude and position of the leading edge fixed and varies the width of each pulse in proportion to the message sample.
+-----------+
m(t) ------->| (+) | +------------+
| sum |------>| Comparator |--> PWM
saw-tooth -->| | | (vs. Vref) |
(fs) +-----------+ +------------+
saw /| /| /| m(t) + saw compared with Vref
/ | / | / |
/ |/ |/ |
PWM ___ _____ __
| | | | | | width ~ m(nTs)
___| |__| |__| |__
Working (comparator method):
- A sawtooth (ramp) generator runs at the sampling frequency .
- The message is added to the ramp (or compared directly with the ramp).
- A comparator outputs HIGH while the ramp is below the message (or the sum exceeds the reference) and LOW otherwise.
- The time at which the crossing occurs depends on the message value, so the trailing edge moves and the pulse width is proportional to .
Alternative: a monostable multivibrator triggered at whose timing is controlled by the message voltage (e.g. 555 timer with the message on the control pin).
PPM from PWM: differentiate the PWM and use the trailing-edge spikes to trigger a fixed-width monostable; pulse positions then follow the message.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Short note: PAM, PWM and PPM · Communication Systems, chapter 4
- PAM, PWM, PPM; PCM of 4.8 MHz TV signal with 512 levels · Communication Systems, chapter 4
- ISB modulation; AM vs FM · Communication Systems, chapter 2
- DPCM vs delta modulation; E1 hierarchy · Communication Systems, chapter 4
- Single-pulse PWM: modulation index and Fourier series · Power Electronics, chapter 5
- What is sinusoidal pulse-width modulation · Power Electronics, chapter 5
- PAM versus PWM · Data Communication, chapter 5
- PWM half-bridge inverter switching instants · Power Electronics, chapter 5