- Practice · 4+3 marks
Solar concentrators and concentration ratio
Short answer
Concentrating collectors focus beam radiation onto a small receiver, achieving high temperatures (100-1500°C) with low heat loss; they require tracking and use only beam radiation. The geometric concentration ratio of the parabolic trough is C = W/(πD) = 3.0/(π×0.05) = 19.1, suitable for medium temperatures (150-300°C).
(a) Why are concentrating collectors used? Classify solar concentrators and compare them with flat plate collectors. (b) A parabolic trough has an aperture width of 3.0 m and a tubular receiver of outer diameter 5 cm. Find the geometric concentration ratio, taking the receiver as a cylinder, and comment on it.
(a) Why and types
A concentrator uses mirrors or lenses to focus beam radiation from a large aperture onto a small absorber (receiver). The small receiver area gives low heat loss, so high temperatures (100–1500 °C) and good efficiency at high temperature are obtained, and less expensive absorber material is needed per unit of heat. Concentrators are used for process heat, industrial steam and solar thermal power plants.
Classification
- By focus: line focus (parabolic trough, linear Fresnel) and point focus (parabolic dish, central receiver/heliostat field).
- By optics: reflecting (mirrors) or refracting (Fresnel lens).
- By tracking: single axis (trough) or two axis (dish, tower).
| Point | Flat plate | Concentrator |
|---|---|---|
| Radiation used | Beam + diffuse | Beam only |
| Tracking | Not needed | Needed |
| Concentration ratio | 1 | 10 to above 1000 |
| Temperature | up to 100 °C | 100 to 1500 °C |
| Cost and maintenance | Low | High |
| Working in cloud | Works | Poor |
(b) Concentration ratio
If the aperture area is taken as the net opening (excluding the area shaded by the receiver), . So, ideally, the receiver surface gets about 19 times the intensity falling on the aperture. This is a moderate value, suitable for medium-temperature work (about 150–300 °C); the ideal limit for a line-focus (2-D) concentrator is (about 212 for a half acceptance angle of 0.27°).
Answer: .
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Flat plate collector and solar water heater · Energy Resources, chapter 2
- Flat plate collector useful heat and outlet temperature · Energy Resources, chapter 2
- Wind turbine power, tip speed ratio and energy · Energy Resources, chapter 4
- Hypergeometric: solar collectors selection · Probability and Statistics, chapter 2
- Aperture antenna and parabolic feeding · Propagation and Antenna, chapter 3
- Audible noise of 765 kV line (18 kV/cm outer) · High Voltage Engineering, chapter 5 · asked 4×
- Audible noise of 765 kV line (18.4 kV/cm outer) · High Voltage Engineering, chapter 5 · asked 4×