Skip to main content

Standing vs travelling wave; V antenna

Short answer

Standing wave antennas have open ends, reflections, and narrow bandwidth; travelling wave antennas are terminated, with forward wave only and wide bandwidth. V antenna consists of two long wires forming a V, fed at apex; terminated V is unidirectional and used for HF communication.

What is the main difference between standing wave antenna and travelling wave antenna? Explain with a neat sketch the construction, working principle and characteristic of V antenna.

Standing wave vs travelling wave antenna

A standing wave (resonant) antenna has its far end open, so the wave reflects and forms standing waves; a travelling wave (non-resonant) antenna is terminated in its characteristic impedance, so the wave travels only forward.

PointStanding wave (resonant)Travelling wave (non-resonant)
End conditionOpen circuitMatched resistive load
Waves on wireIncident + reflected → standing waveOnly forward travelling wave
CurrentSinusoidal, with nulls every λ/2Nearly uniform amplitude, progressive phase
PatternBidirectional (symmetric lobes)Unidirectional (towards load end)
BandwidthNarrow, resonant lengths onlyWide
Input impedanceVaries strongly with frequencyNearly constant and resistive
EfficiencyHigher (no load loss)Lower (power lost in load)
Examplesλ/2 dipole, resonant VBeverage, terminated V, rhombic

V antenna: construction

                 leg 1, length l (2λ-8λ)
           /‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾ (R)
  open-  <   apex angle 2θₘ      ===> beam
  wire     \___________________________ (R)
  feeder         leg 2      (R only in non-resonant V)
  • Two long horizontal wires forming a V, fed at the apex by a 600 Ω balanced line in antiphase.
  • Apex angle = 2θₘ, θₘ = main-lobe angle of a long wire, cosθₘ ≈ 1 − 0.371λ/l (e.g. l = 4λ → θₘ ≈ 25°).

Working principle

Each leg is a long wire radiating its main lobe at θₘ to the wire. By placing the legs at ±θₘ to the bisector, one main lobe from each leg points along the bisector, where they add in phase; elsewhere they partly cancel. With open ends the V carries standing waves and is bidirectional; with terminated ends it carries travelling waves and is unidirectional.

Characteristics

  • HF band, horizontal polarization, gain ≈ 3 dB more than a single long wire (≈ 10–15 dBi for long legs).
  • Wide bandwidth; input impedance ≈ 500–800 Ω.
  • Simple (three poles), but needs large area and has side lobes.
  • Used for HF point-to-point communication.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Propagation and Antenna chapter 3 questions →