- Asked 2/20
- 2073 Magh · 3+5 marks
Standing vs travelling wave; V antenna
Short answer
Standing wave antennas have open ends, reflections, and narrow bandwidth; travelling wave antennas are terminated, with forward wave only and wide bandwidth. V antenna consists of two long wires forming a V, fed at apex; terminated V is unidirectional and used for HF communication.
What is the main difference between standing wave antenna and travelling wave antenna? Explain with a neat sketch the construction, working principle and characteristic of V antenna.
Standing wave vs travelling wave antenna
A standing wave (resonant) antenna has its far end open, so the wave reflects and forms standing waves; a travelling wave (non-resonant) antenna is terminated in its characteristic impedance, so the wave travels only forward.
| Point | Standing wave (resonant) | Travelling wave (non-resonant) |
|---|---|---|
| End condition | Open circuit | Matched resistive load |
| Waves on wire | Incident + reflected → standing wave | Only forward travelling wave |
| Current | Sinusoidal, with nulls every λ/2 | Nearly uniform amplitude, progressive phase |
| Pattern | Bidirectional (symmetric lobes) | Unidirectional (towards load end) |
| Bandwidth | Narrow, resonant lengths only | Wide |
| Input impedance | Varies strongly with frequency | Nearly constant and resistive |
| Efficiency | Higher (no load loss) | Lower (power lost in load) |
| Examples | λ/2 dipole, resonant V | Beverage, terminated V, rhombic |
V antenna: construction
leg 1, length l (2λ-8λ)
/‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾ (R)
open- < apex angle 2θₘ ===> beam
wire \___________________________ (R)
feeder leg 2 (R only in non-resonant V)
- Two long horizontal wires forming a V, fed at the apex by a 600 Ω balanced line in antiphase.
- Apex angle = 2θₘ, θₘ = main-lobe angle of a long wire, cosθₘ ≈ 1 − 0.371λ/l (e.g. l = 4λ → θₘ ≈ 25°).
Working principle
Each leg is a long wire radiating its main lobe at θₘ to the wire. By placing the legs at ±θₘ to the bisector, one main lobe from each leg points along the bisector, where they add in phase; elsewhere they partly cancel. With open ends the V carries standing waves and is bidirectional; with terminated ends it carries travelling waves and is unidirectional.
Characteristics
- HF band, horizontal polarization, gain ≈ 3 dB more than a single long wire (≈ 10–15 dBi for long legs).
- Wide bandwidth; input impedance ≈ 500–800 Ω.
- Simple (three poles), but needs large area and has side lobes.
- Used for HF point-to-point communication.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Standing vs travelling wave; Rhombic antenna · Propagation and Antenna, chapter 3 · asked 2×
- Travelling wave antenna and V antenna · Propagation and Antenna, chapter 3 · asked 2×
- Rhombic antenna construction and working · Propagation and Antenna, chapter 3 · asked 5×
- V antenna construction and working · Propagation and Antenna, chapter 3 · asked 4×
- Single wire radiation and travelling wave long wire · Propagation and Antenna, chapter 1
- MOSFET construction and working principle · Basic Electronics Engineering, chapter 3 · asked 2×