Skip to main content

Turbomachines versus positive displacement machines

Short answer

Turbomachines use dynamic blade action for continuous, steady flow, high speed, and large clearances; examples: centrifugal pump, gas turbine. Positive displacement machines trap fluid in a closed volume, produce pulsating flow, run at low speed with tight seals; examples: gear pump, reciprocating compressor.

Differentiate between turbomachines and positive displacement machines. Give two examples of each.

Both types transfer energy between a mechanical element and a fluid. They differ in the way the energy transfer takes place.

PointTurbomachinePositive displacement machine
PrincipleDynamic action of rotating blades changes the momentum of the fluid (Euler equation)Fluid is trapped in a closed volume that is changed by a piston, vane, gear or screw
FlowContinuous and steadyIntermittent or pulsating
Working element motionPure rotationReciprocating, or rotary with sealed chambers
ClearancesLarge running clearance, no sealing contactClose clearances or sliding seals needed
SpeedHigh (thousands of rpm)Low to moderate
Capacity and pressureLarge flow, moderate pressure ratio per stageSmall flow, high pressure possible
Size and weight per kWSmall, lightLarge and heavy
Vibration, balancingEasy to balance, smooth runningUnbalanced forces, more vibration
Efficiency curvePeaks at the design point, falls off-designAlmost constant over the range
Viscous fluidsPoorGood

Examples

  • Turbomachines: centrifugal pump, axial-flow gas turbine, steam turbine, centrifugal compressor.
  • Positive displacement machines: reciprocating compressor, gear pump, reciprocating IC engine, Roots blower.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Turbo Machines chapter 1 questions →