- Practice · 5 marks
Turbomachines versus positive displacement machines
Short answer
Turbomachines use dynamic blade action for continuous, steady flow, high speed, and large clearances; examples: centrifugal pump, gas turbine. Positive displacement machines trap fluid in a closed volume, produce pulsating flow, run at low speed with tight seals; examples: gear pump, reciprocating compressor.
Differentiate between turbomachines and positive displacement machines. Give two examples of each.
Both types transfer energy between a mechanical element and a fluid. They differ in the way the energy transfer takes place.
| Point | Turbomachine | Positive displacement machine |
|---|---|---|
| Principle | Dynamic action of rotating blades changes the momentum of the fluid (Euler equation) | Fluid is trapped in a closed volume that is changed by a piston, vane, gear or screw |
| Flow | Continuous and steady | Intermittent or pulsating |
| Working element motion | Pure rotation | Reciprocating, or rotary with sealed chambers |
| Clearances | Large running clearance, no sealing contact | Close clearances or sliding seals needed |
| Speed | High (thousands of rpm) | Low to moderate |
| Capacity and pressure | Large flow, moderate pressure ratio per stage | Small flow, high pressure possible |
| Size and weight per kW | Small, light | Large and heavy |
| Vibration, balancing | Easy to balance, smooth running | Unbalanced forces, more vibration |
| Efficiency curve | Peaks at the design point, falls off-design | Almost constant over the range |
| Viscous fluids | Poor | Good |
Examples
- Turbomachines: centrifugal pump, axial-flow gas turbine, steam turbine, centrifugal compressor.
- Positive displacement machines: reciprocating compressor, gear pump, reciprocating IC engine, Roots blower.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Thermodynamic laws and efficiencies of turbomachines · Turbo Machines, chapter 1
- Euler work equation for turbomachines · Turbo Machines, chapter 2
- Turbomachine: definition, parts and classification · Turbo Machines, chapter 1
- Dimensionless parameters and their significance · Turbo Machines, chapter 1
- Turbomachines versus positive displacement machines · Fluid Machines, chapter 1