- 2076 Bhadra · 4+3 marks
Proper vs improper handoff; cellular concept N = 7
Short answer
An improper handoff drops the call because the signal falls below the minimum usable level before transfer. A proper handoff completes between the handoff threshold and minimum level. For N=7, cluster uses i=2, j=1, reuse ratio √21=4.58, giving S/I about 18.7 dB, meeting AMPS requirements.
Compare and contrast between improper handoff situation and proper handoff situation. Explain cellular concept for N = 7.
Improper vs proper handoff
A handoff starts when the signal from the serving base station falls to the handoff threshold Pr,handoff, which is kept above the minimum usable level Pr,min by a margin Δ.
Signal BS1 BS2
│ \ /
│ \ A: Pr,handoff reached /
│ \ ____/
│.......\ B: Pr,min ....../...........
│ (improper: call drops at B)
│ (proper: transferred to BS2 at C, before B)
└───────────────────────────────── distance
| Point | Improper handoff | Proper handoff |
|---|---|---|
| What happens | Signal falls below Pr,min before transfer | Transfer completes between Pr,handoff and Pr,min |
| Result | Call is dropped | Call continues smoothly |
| Typical causes | Δ too small, slow MSC processing, no free channel in new cell | Adequate Δ, fast processing, free channel available |
| User experience | Disconnection | No noticeable break |
Too large a Δ is also bad: it gives unnecessary handoffs and loads the MSC.
Cellular concept for N = 7
In the cellular concept, the service area is divided into small hexagonal cells, each served by a low-power base station. The total S channels are divided among N = 7 cells forming a cluster, so each cell gets S/7 channels. The cluster is repeated across the area (frequency reuse).
___
___/ 2 \___
/ 7 \___/ 3 \
\___/ 1 \___/
/ 6 \___/ 4 \
\___/ 5 \___/
\___/
- N = 7 is obtained with i = 2, j = 1 (N = i² + ij + j² = 4 + 2 + 1).
- Reuse ratio Q = √(3×7) = 4.58, so co-channel cells are 4.58R apart.
- With n = 4 and six interferers, S/I = 4.58⁴/6 ≈ 73.5 = 18.7 dB, which meets the 18 dB needed by AMPS. That is why N = 7 is the classic choice.
- Frequency reuse factor = 1/7.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Proper and improper handoff · Wireless Communication, chapter 2
- 2G vs 3G, prioritized handoff, cell dragging · Wireless Communication, chapter 1
- Numerical: cellular vs non-cellular voice channels · Wireless Communication, chapter 2
- Compare and contrast pollution in a city · Communication English, chapter 1