- 2071 Magh · 4 marks
Advantages of TDMA over FDMA
Short answer
TDMA allows multiple users per carrier, reducing base station transceivers, and eliminates duplexers by separating transmit/receive in time. Mobile-assisted handoff becomes possible during idle slots, battery life improves via burst transmission, and flexible bit rates are supported by allocating multiple slots. Digital TDMA also provides encryption, error control, and higher spectral efficiency than analog FDMA with fewer guard bands.
What are the advantages of TDMA cellular system over FDMA cellular system?
A TDMA cellular system shares one carrier among several users in time slots, while FDMA gives each user its own carrier. TDMA has these advantages over FDMA:
- Fewer transceivers – one radio at the base station serves several users (8 in GSM), reducing cost and size.
- No duplexer needed – transmit and receive happen in different time slots, so the handset is simpler.
- Battery saving – the mobile transmits only in its slot (discontinuous transmission) and can switch off its transmitter between bursts.
- Mobile-assisted handoff (MAHO) – during idle slots the mobile measures signal strength of neighbouring base stations, giving faster and more reliable handoff.
- Flexible bit rate – a user can be given several slots for higher data rates (e.g. GPRS, HSCSD).
- Higher capacity / spectral efficiency – digital coding, speech compression and better reuse give more users per MHz than analog FDMA.
- Fewer guard bands and simpler filtering – wide carriers mean fewer channel edges; less adjacent-channel interference from intermodulation.
- Digital features – easy encryption, error control coding and data services.
| Point | FDMA | TDMA |
|---|---|---|
| Users per carrier | 1 | Several |
| Duplexer | Needed | Not needed |
| Handoff | Network controlled | Mobile assisted |
| Battery use | Continuous Tx | Burst Tx |
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- TDMA versus FDMA · Wireless Communication, chapter 7
- FDMA vs TDMA; operation of FHMA · Wireless Communication, chapter 7
- Advantages and disadvantages of FDMA, TDMA, CDMA · Wireless Communication, chapter 7
- Numerical: cellular vs non-cellular voice channels · Wireless Communication, chapter 2
- Evolution from 1G to 2.5G (TDMA) · Wireless Communication, chapter 1
- CDMA vs TDMA; FHSS multiple access · Wireless Communication, chapter 7
- FDMA vs TDMA; T1 and E1 hierarchy · Communication Systems, chapter 5
- OFC system; pros and cons over metal wire · Propagation and Antenna, chapter 6