Skip to main content

Advantages and disadvantages of DTMF set

Short answer

DTMF offers fast dialling (~100 ms/digit), end-to-end signalling for IVR, 16 signals, and reliable 2-of-8 error checking. Disadvantages include the need for DTMF receivers, susceptibility to talk-off (false digit detection from speech), level problems on long lines, and audible tones posing a security risk.

What are the advantage and disadvantage of DTMF telephone set? Explain.

DTMF (Dual Tone Multi-Frequency) telephone sets send each digit as the sum of two sine tones – one from a low group (697, 770, 852, 941 Hz) and one from a high group (1209, 1336, 1477, 1633 Hz).

            1209  1336  1477  1633 Hz
   697 Hz    1     2     3     A
   770 Hz    4     5     6     B
   852 Hz    7     8     9     C
   941 Hz    *     0     #     D

Example: key 8 = 852 Hz + 1336 Hz.

Advantages

  1. Fast dialling: each digit takes about 50 ms of tone plus 50 ms pause (~100 ms) against up to ~1 s per digit for a rotary dial. Call set-up time and register holding time in the exchange are reduced.
  2. End-to-end signalling: tones are in the voice band, so they pass through the connected call – used for IVR, telebanking, voicemail, remote control.
  3. More signals: 16 combinations including * and # (and A–D) for supplementary services.
  4. Reliability: electronic generation with crystal accuracy; no mechanical governor that wears out or drifts.
  5. Error checking: exactly one tone from each group must be present (2-of-8 code), so most faults are detected.
  6. Convenient: push buttons are easy, fewer misdialled numbers; suitable for redial and memory features.
  7. Suited to electronic/digital exchanges – no DC pulse counting relays.

Disadvantages

  1. Needs DTMF receivers at the exchange (digital filters/DSP), adding cost; old Strowger/crossbar exchanges cannot accept it without converters.
  2. Talk-off: speech, music or noise may imitate a DTMF pair and cause false digits, so receivers need guard circuits.
  3. Talk-down/level problems: on long lines the high-group tone is attenuated more (twist), and noise or echo can stop detection.
  4. Needs power and electronics in the set; more complex than a simple dial.
  5. Tones are audible and can be recorded or overheard (e.g. PINs) – a security issue.
  6. Compatibility: sets often need a pulse/tone switch in areas with old exchanges.

Overall, the advantages far outweigh the disadvantages, so DTMF has replaced pulse dialling in modern networks.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

Related questions

All Telecommunications chapter 1 questions →