- 2066 Bhadra (old course) · 8 marks
P, I, D controllers and role of PI, PD
Short answer
P controller provides output proportional to error. I eliminates steady-state error but slows response. D adds damping. PI increases system type, making steady-state error zero but increasing overshoot. PD increases damping, reduces overshoot and settling time, improving transient performance.
Mention P, I and D controllers. Also explain the role of PI and PD controllers on transient and steady state performance specification.
P, I and D controllers
- Proportional (P): , . Output is proportional to the present error. Raising speeds up the response and reduces (but does not remove) steady-state error; too much gain gives overshoot and instability.
- Integral (I): , . Output depends on the accumulated past error. It adds a pole at the origin and removes steady-state offset, but adds 90° of phase lag and slows the response.
- Derivative (D): , . Output depends on the rate of change of error (future trend). It adds damping, but is never used alone because it gives no output for a constant error and amplifies noise.
Role of the PI controller
, a pole at the origin and a zero at .
| Specification | Effect of PI |
|---|---|
| System type | Increased by one |
| Steady-state error | Step error becomes zero (type-0 plant); ramp error falls |
| Rise time | Slightly reduced |
| Overshoot | Increases |
| Settling time | Increases (slower) |
| Stability | Relative stability decreases |
| Bandwidth | Decreases, so noise is filtered |
Role of the PD controller
, a zero at . For with PD, the characteristic equation becomes , so the effective damping ratio increases.
| Specification | Effect of PD |
|---|---|
| Damping | Increased |
| Peak overshoot | Reduced |
| Rise time and settling time | Reduced (faster) |
| Stability | Improved |
| Steady-state error | Type unchanged; error depends only on |
| Bandwidth | Increased; noise is amplified |
So PI is chosen to improve steady-state performance and PD to improve transient performance. A PID controller combines both.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Short note: PD and PI controller · Control Systems, chapter 7
- Short note: Characteristics of PI and PD control · Control Systems, chapter 7
- PD controller principle and working · Control Systems, chapter 7 · asked 2×
- Closed loop diagram; P, PI, PD, PID · Embedded System, chapter 7
- Control evaluation steps; PD and PI design · Embedded System, chapter 7
- Steady state vs transient stability; enhancement · Power System Analysis II, chapter 6 · asked 2×
- Steady state and transient behaviour with governor · Power Plant Equipment, chapter 2 · asked 2×