Skip to main content

K and T for roots left of s=−a

Short answer

Shift axis with s=z−a to obtain Tz^2+(1−2aT)z+(Ta^2−a+K)=0. Routh gives conditions: 0<T<1/(2a) and K>a(1−aT). This ensures all closed-loop roots lie to the left of s=−a.

For a unity feedback system having open loop transfer function G(s) = k/[s(1+Ts)], determine the values of K and T if it is desired that all the roots of closed loop system should lie in the region towards the left of s = −a.

To make all roots lie to the left of s=−as=-a, shift the imaginary axis to s=−as=-a by putting s=z−as = z - a. Then apply the Routh criterion to the new polynomial in zz (relative stability).

Characteristic equation

1+Ks(1+Ts)=0Ts2+s+K=0\begin{aligned} 1 + \frac{K}{s(1+Ts)} &= 0 \\ Ts^2 + s + K &= 0 \end{aligned}

Shift the axis: s=z−as = z - a

T(z−a)2+(z−a)+K=0Tz2+(1−2aT)z+(Ta2−a+K)=0\begin{aligned} T(z-a)^2 + (z-a) + K &= 0 \\ Tz^2 + (1-2aT)z + (Ta^2 - a + K) &= 0 \end{aligned}

Routh array in z

RowCol 1Col 2
z2z^2TTTa2−a+KTa^2-a+K
z1z^11−2aT1-2aT0
z0z^0Ta2−a+KTa^2-a+K

For no sign change (all roots left of z=0z=0, i.e. left of s=−as=-a):

  1. T>0T > 0
  2. 1−2aT>0⇒T<12a1-2aT > 0 \Rightarrow T < \dfrac{1}{2a}
  3. Ta2−a+K>0⇒K>a−a2T=a(1−aT)Ta^2 - a + K > 0 \Rightarrow K > a - a^2T = a(1-aT)
0<T<12a,K>a(1−aT)0 < T < \frac{1}{2a}, \qquad K > a(1-aT)

Physical meaning: the sum of the closed-loop roots is −1T-\frac{1}{T}, so both roots can be left of −a-a only if 1T>2a\frac{1}{T} > 2a. The gain must be large enough that the slower real root moves past −a-a.

Example: for a=1a=1 and T=0.25T=0.25: K>1(1−0.25)=0.75K > 1(1-0.25)=0.75. With K=1K=1, 0.25s2+s+1=00.25s^2+s+1=0 gives s=−2,−2s = -2, -2, both left of −1-1.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Control Systems chapter 4 questions →