Skip to main content

R-H root distribution of s⁶+3s⁵+4s⁴+6s³+5s²+3s+2

Short answer

The Routh array produces a row of zeros. The auxiliary equation 2(s²+1)²=0 gives repeated roots ±j1. No sign changes occur, so there are no RHP poles, but the repeated imaginary poles yield unstable response. Roots: 2 in LHP (−1, −2), 4 on the jω axis ( ±j1 twice).

Construct Routh array and determine the stability of the system whose characteristic equation is s⁶ + 3s⁵ + 4s⁴ + 6s³ + 5s² + 3s + 2. Comment on the location of the roots of characteristic equation.

Result: the system is unstable. It has 2 roots in the LHP, a repeated pair on the jωj\omega axis at ±j1\pm j1, and no roots in the RHP.

The Routh–Hurwitz criterion states that the number of roots in the right half of the s-plane equals the number of sign changes in the first column of the Routh array. A row of all zeros means there are roots placed symmetrically about the origin; these are found from the auxiliary equation.

q(s)=s6+3s5+4s4+6s3+5s2+3s+2=0q(s) = s^6+3s^5+4s^4+6s^3+5s^2+3s+2 = 0

All coefficients are present and positive, so the necessary condition is satisfied.

Routh array

RowCol 1Col 2Col 3Col 4
s6s^61452
s5s^53630
s4s^43(4)−1(6)3=2\frac{3(4)-1(6)}{3}=23(5)−1(3)3=4\frac{3(5)-1(3)}{3}=42
s3s^300

The s3s^3 row is all zeros. Auxiliary equation from the s4s^4 row:

A(s)=2s4+4s2+2,dAds=8s3+8sA(s) = 2s^4+4s^2+2, \qquad \frac{dA}{ds} = 8s^3 + 8s

Replace the s3s^3 row by 8, 88,\ 8 and continue:

RowCol 1Col 2Col 3
s3s^388
s2s^28(4)−2(8)8=2\frac{8(4)-2(8)}{8}=28(2)−2(0)8=2\frac{8(2)-2(0)}{8}=2
s1s^10

The s1s^1 row is zero again. New auxiliary equation A1(s)=2s2+2A_1(s) = 2s^2+2, dA1ds=4s\frac{dA_1}{ds} = 4s:

RowCol 1
s1s^14
s0s^02

First column: 1, 3, 2, 8, 2, 4, 21,\ 3,\ 2,\ 8,\ 2,\ 4,\ 2. No sign change, so no root is in the right half plane.

Roots of the auxiliary equation

2s4+4s2+2=2(s2+1)2=0  ⇒  s=±j1, ±j12s^4+4s^2+2 = 2(s^2+1)^2 = 0 \;\Rightarrow\; s = \pm j1,\ \pm j1

So ±j1\pm j1 is a repeated pair on the imaginary axis. Dividing q(s)q(s) by (s2+1)2(s^2+1)^2 leaves s2+3s+2=(s+1)(s+2)s^2+3s+2 = (s+1)(s+2).

Location of roots

RegionNumberRoots
Right half plane0none
On jωj\omega axis4±j1\pm j1 (each twice)
Left half plane2−1, −2-1,\ -2

Comment on stability

There is no RHP root, but the imaginary-axis roots are repeated. Repeated poles on the jωj\omega axis give terms like tsin⁡tt\sin t in the response, which grow without limit. Therefore the system is unstable. If the jωj\omega roots were non-repeated, it would only be marginally stable.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Control Systems chapter 4 questions →