Skip to main content

R-H root distribution of s⁵+4s⁴+2s³+8s²+s+4

Short answer

A zero row appears in the Routh array; the auxiliary polynomial yields repeated roots at s = ±j1 twice. The first column has no sign changes, so 0 RHP roots, 1 LHP root at s = −4, and 4 on the jω axis. Repeated imaginary-axis poles make the system unstable.

Using R-H criteria, tell how many roots of polynomial are in right half s-plane, in left half s-plane and on jω axis. Comment on stability. s⁵ + 4s⁴ + 2s³ + 8s² + s + 4 = 0

Result: RHP = 0, LHP = 1 (at s=−4s=-4), jωj\omega axis = 4 (±j1\pm j1, each twice). The system is unstable.

The number of sign changes in the first column gives the RHP roots. A zero row gives the roots that are symmetric about the origin; these are found from the auxiliary polynomial.

s5+4s4+2s3+8s2+s+4=0s^5+4s^4+2s^3+8s^2+s+4=0

Routh array

RowCol 1Col 2Col 3
s5s^5121
s4s^4484
s3s^34(2)−1(8)4=0\frac{4(2)-1(8)}{4}=04(1)−1(4)4=0\frac{4(1)-1(4)}{4}=0

The s3s^3 row is all zeros. Auxiliary polynomial from the s4s^4 row:

A(s)=4s4+8s2+4,dAds=16s3+16sA(s) = 4s^4+8s^2+4, \qquad \frac{dA}{ds} = 16s^3+16s
RowCol 1Col 2
s3s^31616
s2s^216(8)−4(16)16=4\frac{16(8)-4(16)}{16}=416(4)−016=4\frac{16(4)-0}{16}=4
s1s^10 (zero row again)

New auxiliary polynomial A1(s)=4s2+4A_1(s)=4s^2+4, dA1ds=8s\frac{dA_1}{ds}=8s:

RowCol 1
s1s^18
s0s^04

First column: 1, 4, 16, 4, 8, 41,\ 4,\ 16,\ 4,\ 8,\ 4. No sign change, so there is no root in the RHP.

Roots from the auxiliary polynomial

4s4+8s2+4=4(s2+1)2=0⇒s=±j1, ±j14s^4+8s^2+4 = 4(s^2+1)^2 = 0 \Rightarrow s=\pm j1,\ \pm j1

These 4 roots lie on the jωj\omega axis (repeated pair). The remaining root: s5+4s4+2s3+8s2+s+4(s2+1)2=s+4\frac{s^5+4s^4+2s^3+8s^2+s+4}{(s^2+1)^2} = s+4, so s=−4s=-4.

RegionNumber of roots
Right half s-plane0
Left half s-plane1 (s=−4s=-4)
On jωj\omega axis4 (±j1\pm j1 repeated)

Stability

No root is in the RHP, but the roots on the jωj\omega axis are repeated. They produce a response term like tsin⁡tt\sin t, which grows with time. So the system is unstable.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Control Systems chapter 4 questions →