Skip to main content

Rotational system θ1/T and electrical analogies

Short answer

Reduce series B1−K2 to B1K2s/(B1s+K2), parallel with K3 gives coupling Zc. θ1(s)/T(s) = (b+Zc)/[ab+Zc(a+b)] with a=J1s^2+K1, b=J2s^2+B2s; denominator is 5th order. T-V analogy: T→e, J→L, B→R, K→1/C; B1−K2 series maps to parallel R||C shared by loops, K3 adds series C.

Find the transfer function θ1(s)/T(s) for the given rotational mechanical system. Also draw analogous electrical networks. [Figure: fixed wall – torsional spring K1 – inertia J1 (torque T(t) applied, angle θ1); J1 connected to inertia J2 (angle θ2) by damper B1 in series with spring K2, in parallel with spring K3; J2 – damper B2 – fixed wall]

Angles: θ1\theta_1 (J1J_1, torque TT), θ2\theta_2 (J2J_2) and θ3\theta_3 = junction of B1B_1 (on the J1J_1 side) and K2K_2 (on the J2J_2 side). K3K_3 couples J1J_1 and J2J_2 directly; K1K_1 and B2B_2 go to the frame.

Differential equations (Laplace form)

J1s2θ1+K1θ1+B1s(θ1−θ3)+K3(θ1−θ2)=TB1s(θ3−θ1)+K2(θ3−θ2)=0J2s2θ2+B2sθ2+K2(θ2−θ3)+K3(θ2−θ1)=0\begin{aligned} J_1s^2\theta_1 + K_1\theta_1 + B_1s(\theta_1 - \theta_3) + K_3(\theta_1 - \theta_2) &= T \\ B_1s(\theta_3 - \theta_1) + K_2(\theta_3 - \theta_2) &= 0 \\ J_2s^2\theta_2 + B_2s\theta_2 + K_2(\theta_2 - \theta_3) + K_3(\theta_2 - \theta_1) &= 0 \end{aligned}

Reducing the series branch

B1B_1 in series with K2K_2 is equivalent to B1sK2B1s+K2\dfrac{B_1sK_2}{B_1s + K_2}; with K3K_3 in parallel the total coupling is

Zc=K3+B1K2sB1s+K2=QB1s+K2,Q=K3(B1s+K2)+B1K2sZ_c = K_3 + \frac{B_1K_2s}{B_1s + K_2} = \frac{Q}{B_1s + K_2}, \quad Q = K_3(B_1s + K_2) + B_1K_2s

With a=J1s2+K1a = J_1s^2 + K_1 and b=J2s2+B2sb = J_2s^2 + B_2s:

(a+Zc)θ1−Zcθ2=T−Zcθ1+(b+Zc)θ2=0⇒θ1T=b+Zcab+Zc(a+b)\begin{aligned} (a + Z_c)\theta_1 - Z_c\theta_2 &= T \\ -Z_c\theta_1 + (b + Z_c)\theta_2 &= 0 \end{aligned} \qquad\Rightarrow\qquad \frac{\theta_1}{T} = \frac{b + Z_c}{ab + Z_c(a + b)}

Transfer function

Multiplying by (B1s+K2)(B_1s + K_2):

θ1(s)T(s)=(B1s+K2)(J2s2+B2s)+Q(B1s+K2)(J1s2+K1)(J2s2+B2s)+Q[(J1+J2)s2+B2s+K1]\frac{\theta_1(s)}{T(s)} = \frac{(B_1s + K_2)(J_2s^2 + B_2s) + Q}{(B_1s + K_2)(J_1s^2 + K_1)(J_2s^2 + B_2s) + Q\left[(J_1 + J_2)s^2 + B_2s + K_1\right]}

Expanded:

θ1T=B1J2s3+(B1B2+J2K2)s2+(B1K2+B1K3+B2K2)s+K2K3Δ\frac{\theta_1}{T} = \frac{B_1J_2s^3 + (B_1B_2 + J_2K_2)s^2 + (B_1K_2 + B_1K_3 + B_2K_2)s + K_2K_3}{\Delta} Δ=  B1J1J2s5+(B1B2J1+J1J2K2)s4+[B1J1(K2+K3)+B1J2(K1+K2+K3)+B2J1K2]s3+[B1B2(K1+K2+K3)+J1K2K3+J2K2(K1+K3)]s2+[B1K1(K2+K3)+B2K2(K1+K3)]s+K1K2K3\begin{aligned} \Delta =\; & B_1J_1J_2s^5 + (B_1B_2J_1 + J_1J_2K_2)s^4 \\ & + \left[B_1J_1(K_2 + K_3) + B_1J_2(K_1 + K_2 + K_3) + B_2J_1K_2\right]s^3 \\ & + \left[B_1B_2(K_1 + K_2 + K_3) + J_1K_2K_3 + J_2K_2(K_1 + K_3)\right]s^2 \\ & + \left[B_1K_1(K_2 + K_3) + B_2K_2(K_1 + K_3)\right]s + K_1K_2K_3 \end{aligned}

Analogous electrical networks

MechanicalT-V (mesh)T-I (node)
TTeeii
JJLLCC
BBRR1/R1/R
KK1/C1/C1/L1/L
ω\omegaiivv

T-I network (nodes v1,v3,v2v_1, v_3, v_2):

 v1                RB1    v3  L2   v2
 +----+----+----+--/\/\/--+--LLLL--+----+----+
 |    |    |    |                  |    |    |
 |    |    |    +-------LLLL-------+    |    |
 |    |    |             L3             |    |
(i)   C1   L1                           C2   R2
 |    |    |                            |    |
 +----+----+----------------------------+----+ gnd

(C1=J1C_1 = J_1, L1=1/K1L_1 = 1/K_1, RB1=1/B1R_{B1} = 1/B_1, L2=1/K2L_2 = 1/K_2, L3=1/K3L_3 = 1/K_3, C2=J2C_2 = J_2, R2=1/B2R_2 = 1/B_2.) T-V network (mesh currents i1,i2i_1, i_2 and inner loop i3i_3):

   L1=J1  C1=1/K1          L2=J2  R2=B2
 +-LLLL----||----+---------LLLL---/\/\-+
 |               |                     |
(~) e         C3=1/K3                  |
 |    i1         |          i2         |
 |           +---+---+                 |
 |         R1=B1  C2=1/K2              |
 |           | i3    |                 |
 |           +---+---+                 |
 |               |                     |
 +---------------+---------------------+

K3K_3 (parallel coupling) becomes a series element C3C_3 in the shared branch, and the series pair B1B_1–K2K_2 becomes the parallel pair R1∥C2R_1 \parallel C_2. The mesh equations are exactly the three equations above with θ→q\theta \to q.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Control Systems chapter 2 questions →