Skip to main content

Rotational system θ2/T with T-V and T-I analogies

Short answer

θ2(s)/T(s) = DK / [s{ (Ds+K)(J1s+D1)(J2s+D2) + DK((J1+J2)s + D1+D2) }]. In torque-voltage analogy, torque maps to voltage, inertias to inductors, dampers to resistors, springs to capacitors; in torque-current analogy, torque maps to current, inertias to capacitors, dampers to resistors, springs to inductors.

Find the transfer function θ2(s)/T(s) for the mechanical rotational system of figure below. Also draw the T-V and T-I analogy circuit of the system. [Figure: fixed wall – viscous damper D1 – inertia J1 (torque T(t) applied, angle θ1); J1 – damper D – torsional spring K – inertia J2 (angle θ2); J2 – damper D2 – fixed wall]

Assumptions: zero initial conditions; θ3\theta_3 is the angle of the junction between damper DD and spring KK (D on the J1J_1 side). The series DD–KK coupling is massless.

Equations (Laplace form)

Inertia J1J_1:

T(s)=(J1s2+D1s)θ1+Ds(θ1−θ3)T(s) = (J_1s^2 + D_1s)\theta_1 + Ds(\theta_1 - \theta_3)

Junction:   Ds(θ3−θ1)+K(θ3−θ2)=0\;Ds(\theta_3 - \theta_1) + K(\theta_3 - \theta_2) = 0

Inertia J2J_2:   (J2s2+D2s)θ2+K(θ2−θ3)=0\;(J_2s^2 + D_2s)\theta_2 + K(\theta_2 - \theta_3) = 0

Solving

Damper and spring in series transmit the same torque, so they act as one element with "stiffness"

Ke(s)=DsKDs+KK_e(s) = \frac{DsK}{Ds + K}

Then (J1s2+D1s+Ke)θ1−Keθ2=T(J_1s^2+D_1s+K_e)\theta_1 - K_e\theta_2 = T and −Keθ1+(J2s2+D2s+Ke)θ2=0-K_e\theta_1 + (J_2s^2+D_2s+K_e)\theta_2 = 0, giving

θ2T=Ke(J1s2+D1s)(J2s2+D2s)+Ke[(J1+J2)s2+(D1+D2)s]\frac{\theta_2}{T} = \frac{K_e}{(J_1s^2+D_1s)(J_2s^2+D_2s) + K_e\left[(J_1+J_2)s^2 + (D_1+D_2)s\right]}

Multiply top and bottom by (Ds+K)(Ds+K) and cancel the common ss:

θ2(s)T(s)=DKs[(Ds+K)(J1s+D1)(J2s+D2)+DK{(J1+J2)s+D1+D2}]\frac{\theta_2(s)}{T(s)} = \frac{DK}{s\left[(Ds+K)(J_1s+D_1)(J_2s+D_2) + DK\{(J_1+J_2)s + D_1 + D_2\}\right]}

Expanded:

θ2(s)T(s)=DKs[a3s3+a2s2+a1s+a0]\frac{\theta_2(s)}{T(s)} = \frac{DK}{s\left[a_3s^3 + a_2s^2 + a_1s + a_0\right]} a3=DJ1J2,a2=D(D1J2+D2J1)+KJ1J2a1=DD1D2+K[D(J1+J2)+D1J2+D2J1]a0=K[D(D1+D2)+D1D2]\begin{aligned} a_3 &= DJ_1J_2, \quad a_2 = D(D_1J_2 + D_2J_1) + KJ_1J_2 \\ a_1 &= DD_1D_2 + K\left[D(J_1+J_2) + D_1J_2 + D_2J_1\right] \\ a_0 &= K\left[D(D_1+D_2) + D_1D_2\right] \end{aligned}

Torque–voltage (T-V) analogy

Torque → voltage, JJ → LL, DD → RR, KK → C=1/KC = 1/K, angular velocity → loop current. The series DD–KK pair becomes R∥CR \parallel C shared by the two loops.

  +--[L1]--[R1]--+-----+--[L2]--[R2]--+
  |              |     |              |
 (T)  i1 ->      R     C     <- i2    |
  |              |     |              |
  +--------------+-----+--------------+
 L1=J1, R1=D1, R=D, C=1/K, L2=J2, R2=D2

Torque–current (T-I) analogy

Torque → current source, JJ → CC, DD → conductance (R=1/DR = 1/D), KK → L=1/KL = 1/K, angular velocity → node voltage.

      ω1          ω3           ω2
  +----o----+--[R]--o--[L]--+----o
  |    |    |               |    |
 (T)   C1   R1              C2   R2
  |    |    |               |    |
  +----+----+---------------+----+
              ground
 C1=J1, R1=1/D1, R=1/D, L=1/K, C2=J2, R2=1/D2

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Control Systems chapter 2 questions →