Skip to main content

Resultant force on bifurcating bend

Short answer

Assume d1=20 cm, compute V1=12.2 m/s, p1=125.6 kPa via Bernoulli. Momentum equations yield force components on bend: Rx=2526 N, Ry=-2721 N. Resultant force is 3.71 kN, directed 47.1° below the inlet axis.

Ignoring friction losses, calculate the magnitude and direction of resultant force, exerted on the bend when water discharges at the atmosphere as shown in figure below. Both nozzles discharge water with a velocity of 20 m/sec. Consider the axes of the pipe and the nozzles lie in a horizontal plane. [Figure: pipe with inlet velocity V1V_1 branching into a straight outlet d2d_2 = 12 cm (V2V_2) and a branch d3d_3 = 10 cm (V3V_3) at 60° to the axis]

The resultant force is found by applying the Bernoulli equation to get the inlet pressure and then the momentum equation in the xx and yy directions. The result is about 3.71 kN, acting at about 47∘47^\circ to the inlet axis.

Assumptions

The figure does not give the inlet diameter, so I take d1=20d_1 = 20 cm. The inlet pipe lies along the xx-axis, nozzle 2 (d2=12d_2 = 12 cm) continues straight, and nozzle 3 (d3=10d_3 = 10 cm) leaves at 60∘60^\circ to the axis. The plane is horizontal, so weight does not matter. Both nozzles discharge to the atmosphere, so p2=p3=0p_2 = p_3 = 0 (gauge). ρ=1000 kg/m3\rho = 1000\ \text{kg/m}^3.

                    / --> V3 (d3, 60 deg)
   V1, p1  ------->(
                    \ --> V2 (d2, straight)

Discharges and inlet velocity

A1=0.03142 m2,  A2=0.011310 m2,  A3=0.007854 m2Q2=A2V2=0.2262 m3/s,Q3=A3V3=0.1571 m3/sQ1=Q2+Q3=0.3833 m3/s,V1=Q1/A1=12.20 m/s\begin{aligned} A_1 &= 0.03142\ \text{m}^2,\; A_2 = 0.011310\ \text{m}^2,\; A_3 = 0.007854\ \text{m}^2 \\ Q_2 &= A_2V_2 = 0.2262\ \text{m}^3/\text{s},\quad Q_3 = A_3V_3 = 0.1571\ \text{m}^3/\text{s} \\ Q_1 &= Q_2 + Q_3 = 0.3833\ \text{m}^3/\text{s},\quad V_1 = Q_1/A_1 = 12.20\ \text{m/s} \end{aligned}

Inlet pressure (Bernoulli, no losses)

p1=12ρ (V22−V12)=12(1000)(202−12.22)=125 580 Pa=125.6 kPap_1 = \tfrac12\rho\,(V_2^2 - V_1^2) = \tfrac12(1000)(20^2 - 12.2^2) = 125\,580\ \text{Pa} = 125.6\ \text{kPa}

Momentum equation (force of bend on fluid, FxF_x, FyF_y)

Fx+p1A1=ρ (Q2V2+Q3V3cos⁡60∘−Q1V1)Fx=1000 (4.524+1.571−4.676)−3945=−2526 NFy=ρQ3V3sin⁡60∘=1000(0.1571)(20)(0.866)=2721 N\begin{aligned} F_x + p_1A_1 &= \rho\,(Q_2V_2 + Q_3V_3\cos 60^\circ - Q_1V_1) \\ F_x &= 1000\,(4.524 + 1.571 - 4.676) - 3945 = -2526\ \text{N} \\ F_y &= \rho Q_3V_3\sin 60^\circ = 1000(0.1571)(20)(0.866) = 2721\ \text{N} \end{aligned}

The force exerted on the bend by the water is equal and opposite:

Rx=2526 N,Ry=−2721 NR_x = 2526\ \text{N},\quad R_y = -2721\ \text{N} R=25262+27212=3713 N,θ=tan⁡−127212526=47.1∘R = \sqrt{2526^2 + 2721^2} = 3713\ \text{N},\qquad \theta = \tan^{-1}\frac{2721}{2526} = 47.1^\circ

Answer: R≈3.71R \approx 3.71 kN, directed 47.1∘47.1^\circ below the inlet axis (away from the branch side), pushing the bend along the flow direction.

All Fluid Mechanics chapter 7 questions →