Skip to main content

Percentage error in notch discharge

Short answer

For a 1 mm head error, percentage discharge error is n dH/H. Rectangular notch: H=0.110 m, n=1.5, error 1.37%. Triangular notch: H=0.182 m, n=2.5, error 1.37%. Both are about 1.37%.

A sharp edged rectangular notch 30 cm long and a right-angled triangular notch are to be used alternatively for gauging a discharge estimated to be about 20 lit/s. Find in each cases the percentage error in computing the discharge that would be introduced by an error of 1 mm in observing the head over the notch.

Given: Q=20Q = 20 L/s =0.02= 0.02 m³/s; error in head dH=1dH = 1 mm =0.001= 0.001 m. The coefficients are not given, so take Cd=0.62C_d = 0.62 for the rectangular notch and Cd=0.60C_d = 0.60 for the right-angled triangular notch.

Percentage error formula: since Q∝HnQ \propto H^n,

dQQ=ndHH\frac{dQ}{Q} = n\frac{dH}{H}

Rectangular notch (L=0.30L = 0.30 m, n=3/2n = 3/2)

H=[Q23CdL2g]2/3=[0.0223(0.62)(0.3)(4.4294)]2/3=0.1099 mH = \left[\frac{Q}{\frac{2}{3}C_dL\sqrt{2g}}\right]^{2/3} = \left[\frac{0.02}{\frac{2}{3}(0.62)(0.3)(4.4294)}\right]^{2/3} = 0.1099\ \text{m} dQQ=1.5×0.0010.1099=0.01365=1.37 %\frac{dQ}{Q} = 1.5\times\frac{0.001}{0.1099} = 0.01365 = 1.37\ \%

Right-angled triangular notch (θ=90∘\theta = 90^\circ, tan⁡45∘=1\tan 45^\circ = 1, n=5/2n = 5/2)

H=[Q815Cd2g]2/5=[0.02815(0.6)(4.4294)]0.4=0.1819 mH = \left[\frac{Q}{\frac{8}{15}C_d\sqrt{2g}}\right]^{2/5} = \left[\frac{0.02}{\frac{8}{15}(0.6)(4.4294)}\right]^{0.4} = 0.1819\ \text{m} dQQ=2.5×0.0010.1819=0.01374=1.37 %\frac{dQ}{Q} = 2.5\times\frac{0.001}{0.1819} = 0.01374 = 1.37\ \%

Answer: the error in discharge is about 1.37 % for the rectangular notch and about 1.37 % for the triangular notch. Both give nearly the same error for 1 mm error in head; the result depends only slightly on the assumed CdC_d.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Fluid Mechanics chapter 6 questions →