Skip to main content

Streaklines compared with streamlines

Short answer

Streamlines through (1,1): y=x (t=0), y=x^{2/3} (t=1 s), y=x^{1/2} (t=2 s). Streakline at t=3 s: from (1,1) to (190.6,20.1) m, equation x=y^{2.5}e^{-0.25(ln y)²}.

Consider the flow described by the velocity field V⃗=Bx(1+At)i^+Cyj^\vec V = Bx(1+At)\hat i + Cy\hat j, with A = 0.5 s⁻¹, and B = C = 1 s⁻¹. Coordinates are measured in meter. Plot the streak lines traced out by the particle that passes through the point (1, 1) during the interval from t = 0 to t = 3 s. Compare with streamlines plotted through the same point at the instants t = 0, 1 and 2 s. (no need of graph paper, plot in answer copy in precision as far as possible)

Velocity field: u=Bx(1+At)=x(1+0.5t)u = Bx(1+At) = x(1+0.5t), v=Cy=yv = Cy = y.

Streamlines through (1, 1) at fixed t

dydx=yx(1+At)  ⇒  ln⁡y=11+Atln⁡x  ⇒  y=x1/(1+0.5t)\frac{dy}{dx} = \frac{y}{x(1+At)}\;\Rightarrow\; \ln y = \frac{1}{1+At}\ln x\;\Rightarrow\; y = x^{1/(1+0.5t)}
TimeStreamline
t = 0y=xy = x
t = 1 sy=x2/3y = x^{2/3}
t = 2 sy=x1/2y = x^{1/2}

Points: for x=1,2,3,4x = 1, 2, 3, 4: t=0t=0: y=1,2,3,4y = 1, 2, 3, 4; t=1t=1: y=1,1.587,2.080,2.520y = 1, 1.587, 2.080, 2.520; t=2t=2: y=1,1.414,1.732,2.0y = 1, 1.414, 1.732, 2.0.

Streakline

Take the streakline observed at t=3t = 3 s, formed by all the particles that passed through (1, 1) at release times τ\tau from 0 to 3 s. Integrate the path of a particle released at τ\tau:

dydt=y⇒y=e(t−τ),dxdt=x(1+0.5t)⇒x=exp⁡[(t−τ)+0.25(t2−τ2)]\frac{dy}{dt} = y \Rightarrow y = e^{(t-\tau)},\qquad \frac{dx}{dt} = x(1+0.5t)\Rightarrow x = \exp\left[(t-\tau) + 0.25(t^2-\tau^2)\right]

At t=3t = 3:

τ\tau (s)00.511.522.53
x (m)190.57108.5854.6024.239.493.281.00
y (m)20.0912.187.394.482.721.651.00

Eliminating τ\tau (with s=ln⁡y=t−τs = \ln y = t-\tau): x=y1+0.5te−0.25(ln⁡y)2x = y^{1+0.5t}e^{-0.25(\ln y)^2}, and at t=3t=3, x=y2.5e−0.25(ln⁡y)2x = y^{2.5}e^{-0.25(\ln y)^2}.

 y (m)
 20 |                                        * (190.6, 20.1)  tau = 0
    |
 12 |                     * (108.6, 12.2)  tau = 0.5
    |
  7 |           * (54.6, 7.4)  tau = 1
  4 |     * (24.2, 4.5)  tau = 1.5
  1 |*(1,1) tau = 3    [(3.3, 1.65) and (9.5, 2.7) lie close to the start]
    +------------------------------------------------- x (m)
     0         50        100       150       200

Comparison: a streamline is the instantaneous curve tangent to the velocity. Through (1, 1) it is the straight line y=xy = x at t=0t = 0, and it becomes flatter with time (y=x1/(1+0.5t)y = x^{1/(1+0.5t)}). The streakline at t=3t = 3 s is much longer and lies well below the line y=xy = x (at y=20y = 20 m, xx is already 190 m), because particles released earlier have been carried far in the xx-direction by the growing uu. It does not lie on any one streamline. The flow is unsteady, so streaklines, pathlines and streamlines are different curves; they would coincide only in steady flow.

Answer: streamlines y=x, x2/3, x1/2y = x,\ x^{2/3},\ x^{1/2} at t=0,1,2t = 0, 1, 2 s; the streakline at t=3t = 3 s runs from (1,1)(1,1) to (190.6,20.1)(190.6, 20.1), as given by the table above.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Fluid Mechanics chapter 4 questions →