Skip to main content

Magnetic vs electric circuits, work law and Ohm's law

Short answer

MMF (NI) corresponds to EMF, flux to current, and reluctance (l/μA) to resistance. Ampère’s work law gives ∮ H·dl = NI; magnetic Ohm’s law is φ = F/S, where S = l/(μA).

List out the similarities between magnetic circuit and electric circuit. Deduce work law and Ohm's law for magnetic circuit.

A magnetic circuit is the closed path followed by magnetic flux, e.g. the iron core of a transformer with its air gaps. It behaves much like an electric circuit, with mmf driving flux against reluctance.

Similarities

Magnetic circuitElectric circuit
MMF, F=NIF = NI (AT)EMF, EE (V)
Flux, ϕ\phi (Wb)Current, II (A)
Reluctance, S=l/μAS = l/\mu A (AT/Wb)Resistance, R=ρl/AR = \rho l/A (Ω)
Permeance, 1/S1/SConductance, 1/R1/R
Permeability, μ\muConductivity, σ=1/ρ\sigma = 1/\rho
Flux density, B=ϕ/AB = \phi/ACurrent density, J=I/AJ = I/A
Field intensity, HH (AT/m)Electric field, EE (V/m)
ϕ=F/S\phi = F/SI=E/RI = E/R
Series: S=S1+S2+…S = S_1 + S_2 + \dotsSeries: R=R1+R2+…R = R_1 + R_2 + \dots

Differences (in brief): flux does not actually flow and needs no energy to keep it up, while current does; μ\mu changes with B (saturation), while R is nearly constant.

Work law (Ampere's circuital law)

The work done in moving a unit magnetic pole once round a closed path equals the ampere-turns enclosed:

∮H⃗⋅dl⃗=NI\oint \vec H \cdot d\vec l = NI

For a path made of sections in which H is constant,

H1l1+H2l2+⋯=NI=FH_1 l_1 + H_2 l_2 + \dots = NI = F

So the total mmf equals the sum of the "magnetic drops" HlHl round the circuit, just as KVL says the emf equals the sum of IR drops.

Ohm's law for a magnetic circuit

Take a ring of mean length ll, area AA, permeability μ=μ0μr\mu = \mu_0\mu_r, with NN turns carrying II. From the work law H=NI/lH = NI/l. Then

B=μH=μNIlϕ=BA=μANIl=NIl/(μA)\begin{aligned} B &= \mu H = \frac{\mu NI}{l} \\ \phi &= BA = \frac{\mu A NI}{l} = \frac{NI}{l/(\mu A)} \end{aligned} ϕ=FS,S=lμ0μrA\phi = \frac{F}{S}, \quad S = \frac{l}{\mu_0 \mu_r A}

i.e. flux = mmf / reluctance, the magnetic form of I=V/RI = V/R.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Electrical Machines I chapter 1 questions →