Skip to main content

Depth for maximum discharge, triangular channel

Short answer

For a closed equilateral triangle with apex up, maximize Q=KA^(5/3)P^(-2/3) to get 8u²-u-5=0, where u=h/H. Solving yields u≈0.856. Thus maximum discharge occurs at depth h ≈ 0.856H ≈ 0.741a, with a the side length.

In a partially full channel having a triangular section as shown in figure, the rate of discharge Q=KAR2/3Q = KAR^{2/3}, in which K = a constant; A = flow area and R = hydraulic radius. Determine the depth at which the discharge is maximum. [Figure: triangular channel with both sides at 60° to the horizontal (equilateral section) and flow depth h]

Reading of the figure: the section is a closed equilateral triangle conduit (both sides at 60∘60^\circ to the horizontal) with the base horizontal at the bottom and apex at the top, partly filled to depth hh. (For an open V-shaped section the discharge would increase continuously with depth, so a maximum exists only for the closed apex-up section.) Let the side of the triangle be aa and its height H=32aH=\dfrac{\sqrt3}{2}a.

        /\
       /  \         apex up
      / ~~ \  h     water of depth h
     /______\
        a

Geometry for depth hh

Width of water surface at height hh: T=a(1−hH)T=a\left(1-\dfrac hH\right).

A=ah−a2Hh2=a(h−h22H)A=ah-\frac{a}{2H}h^2=a\left(h-\frac{h^2}{2H}\right)

Wetted perimeter: base + the two sloping sides below the surface (h/sin⁡60∘=2h/3h/\sin60^\circ=2h/\sqrt3 each):

P=a+4h3P=a+\frac{4h}{\sqrt3}

Let u=h/Hu=h/H. Then 4h3=4Hu3=2au\dfrac{4h}{\sqrt3}=\dfrac{4Hu}{\sqrt3}=2au:

A=aH(u−u22),P=a(1+2u)A=aH\left(u-\frac{u^2}{2}\right),\qquad P=a(1+2u)

Maximum discharge

Q=KAR2/3=KA5/3P−2/3Q=KAR^{2/3}=KA^{5/3}P^{-2/3}. For maximum QQ: dQdh=0\dfrac{dQ}{dh}=0:

5PdAdh=2AdPdh5P\frac{dA}{dh}=2A\frac{dP}{dh} dAdh=a(1−u),dPdh=2aH\frac{dA}{dh}=a(1-u),\qquad \frac{dP}{dh}=\frac{2a}{H} 5 a(1+2u) a(1−u)=2 aH(u−u22)2aH5\,a(1+2u)\,a(1-u)=2\,aH\left(u-\frac{u^2}{2}\right)\frac{2a}{H} 5(1+u−2u2)=4u−2u2  ⇒  8u2−u−5=05(1+u-2u^2)=4u-2u^2\;\Rightarrow\;8u^2-u-5=0 u=1+1+16016=1+12.68916=0.8555u=\frac{1+\sqrt{1+160}}{16}=\frac{1+12.689}{16}=0.8555 h=uH=0.8555 H=0.7409 ah=uH=0.8555\,H=0.7409\,a

Answer: the discharge is maximum when the depth is about 0.856 of the height of the triangle (h≈0.856H≈0.741ah\approx0.856H\approx0.741a, where aa is the side).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Hydraulics chapter 6 questions →