Skip to main content

Principal stresses at web-flange junction

Short answer

Bending stress 69.7 MPa (compression), shear stress 19.2 MPa. Mohr's circle gives principal stresses +4.9 MPa and -74.6 MPa, maximum shear 39.8 MPa. Extreme fibre bending stress 83.6 MPa exceeds the principal compression, so the junction does not govern.

An I-section has flanges 150 mm x 20 mm and a web 20 mm x 200 mm (overall depth 240 mm, I = 86.13 x 10^6 mm^4). At a section the bending moment is 60 kN m and the shear force is 100 kN. For a point in the web just below the top flange, find the bending stress, the shear stress, the principal stresses and the maximum shear stress, and compare the principal stress with the maximum bending stress at the extreme fibre.

The point is at a distance y=100y = 100 mm from the neutral axis (the junction of web and flange).

Bending stress

σ=MyI=60×106×10086.13×106=69.7 MPa (compression at the top, for a sagging moment)\sigma = \frac{My}{I} = \frac{60\times10^6\times100}{86.13\times10^6} = 69.7\ \text{MPa (compression at the top, for a sagging moment)}

Shear stress

QQ of the flange about the NA: 150×20×110=330 000 mm3150\times20\times110 = 330\,000\ \text{mm}^3. Width at this level (web) b=20b = 20 mm.

τ=VQIb=100×103×330 00086.13×106×20=19.2 MPa\tau = \frac{VQ}{Ib} = \frac{100\times10^3\times330\,000}{86.13\times10^6\times20} = 19.2\ \text{MPa}

Principal stresses

Take σx=−69.7\sigma_x = -69.7 MPa (axial direction of the beam), σy=0\sigma_y = 0, τxy=19.2\tau_{xy} = 19.2 MPa.

σx2=−34.8 MPa,R=34.82+19.22=39.75 MPa\frac{\sigma_x}{2} = -34.8\ \text{MPa}, \qquad R = \sqrt{34.8^2 + 19.2^2} = 39.75\ \text{MPa} σ1=−34.8+39.75=+4.9 MPa (tension)\sigma_1 = -34.8 + 39.75 = +4.9\ \text{MPa (tension)} σ2=−34.8−39.75=−74.6 MPa (compression)\sigma_2 = -34.8 - 39.75 = -74.6\ \text{MPa (compression)}

Maximum shear stress τmax=R=39.75 MPa\tau_{max} = R = 39.75\ \text{MPa}.

Direction: tan⁡2θ=2τ∣σx∣=0.551\tan2\theta = \dfrac{2\tau}{|\sigma_x|} = 0.551, so 2θ=28.8∘2\theta = 28.8^\circ and the compressive principal stress acts at θ=14.4∘\theta = 14.4^\circ to the beam axis.

Comparison with the extreme fibre

At the extreme fibre (y=120y = 120 mm) there is no shear stress and

σmax=60×106×12086.13×106=83.6 MPa\sigma_{max} = \frac{60\times10^6\times120}{86.13\times10^6} = 83.6\ \text{MPa}

The principal stress at the junction (74.674.6 MPa) is smaller than the extreme-fibre stress (83.683.6 MPa), so for this loading the extreme fibre governs. For deep plate girders, or where a large shear force and large moment act together, the junction can govern, so it must be checked.

Answer: σ=69.7\sigma = 69.7 MPa, τ=19.2\tau = 19.2 MPa; σ1=4.9\sigma_1 = 4.9 MPa, σ2=−74.6\sigma_2 = -74.6 MPa; τmax=39.8\tau_{max} = 39.8 MPa; σmax,fibre=83.6\sigma_{max,fibre} = 83.6 MPa.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Strength of Materials chapter 9 questions →