Skip to main content

Comparison of masonry units

Short answer

Burnt clay bricks: 3.5–20+ N/mm², heavy, high energy. Stone: 20–100+ N/mm², durable but heavy. Solid concrete blocks: 4–10 N/mm². Hollow blocks: 3–8 N/mm², light, can be reinforced. Compressed earth blocks (CEB): 2–6 N/mm², low energy, needs water protection.

Differentiate between brick, stone, concrete block, hollow block and compressed earth block as masonry units, giving their characteristics and typical uses.

PropertyBurnt clay brickStoneSolid concrete blockHollow blockCompressed earth block (CEB)
MaterialClay moulded and burntNatural rock (granite, sandstone, limestone)Cement, sand, aggregateSame as concrete, with coresSoil with 5–10% cement/lime, pressed
Compressive strength3.5–20+ N/mm²20–100+ N/mm²4–10 N/mm²3–8 N/mm² (net-area basis)2–6 N/mm²
Density1700–1900 kg/m³2300–2800 kg/m³2000–2300 kg/m³1400–1800 kg/m³1800–2000 kg/m³
Water absorptionup to 20%Low (1–5%)5–10%5–10%Higher, needs protection
Weight and easeHandy, lightHeavy, hard to dressHeavyLight, large unit, quickMedium
EnergyHigh (burning)Quarrying and dressingCement energyLowerVery low (no burning)
Typical useLoad-bearing and partition wallsFoundations, retaining walls, hill housesLoad-bearing wallsPartitions, framed buildingsLow-cost housing

Notes

  • Brick quality is judged by compressive strength, water absorption (not above 20 percent), efflorescence and a ringing sound when struck.
  • Stone is durable and strong in compression, but heavy and weak in tension; it needs mortar and good bonding with through stones.
  • Hollow blocks have cores (voids more than 25 percent of the gross area); they are light, reduce dead load and can be reinforced and grouted for seismic resistance.
  • CEB is environment friendly, needs no firing and has good thermal behaviour, but it must be protected from water and erosion by plaster and projecting eaves.
  • All masonry units are strong in compression but weak in tension and shear, so masonry is mainly used for gravity load-bearing walls.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Sonnet 5.5

All Design of Timber and Masonry Structures chapter 4 questions →