Skip to main content

Testing lossless functions; Foster I and Cauer II

Short answer

A valid LC function has an odd/even ratio, simple jω poles/zeros alternating, and residues positive. The valid function is Z(s)=(s²+1)(s²+3)/[s(s²+2)(s²+4)] (p0,z1,p1.414,z1.732,p2,z∞, even/odd). Foster I: series C₁=8/3 F, parallel tanks L₂=1/8 H,C₂=4 F and L₃=3/32 H,C₃=8/3 F. Cauer II: series C₁=8/3 F, shunt L₂=7/32 H, series C₃=88/49 F, shunt L₄=21/968 H, series C₅=44/3 F.

How can you determine whether the given function is a valid lossless function or not? Explain. Which of the following functions are the valid LC impedance function? State with reason. Pick one valid LC impedance function and realize it in Foster I and Cauer II form. Z(s) = (s²+2)(s²+4)/(s(s²+1)(s²+3)), Z(s) = (s²+1)(s²+3)/((s²+2)(s²+4)), Z(s) = (s²+1)(s²+3)/(s(s²+2)(s²+4))

Testing a lossless function

A given Z(s)Z(s) is checked as follows:

  1. Factor numerator and denominator. Each must be a product of factors ss and (s2+ωi2)(s^2+\omega_i^2) only, so that one is even and the other odd.
  2. Write the critical frequencies in increasing order of ω\omega and check that poles and zeros alternate.
  3. Check that there is a pole or zero at s=0s=0 and at s=∞s=\infty (degrees differ by exactly 1).
  4. Check that all residues of the partial-fraction expansion are positive (this follows when steps 1–3 hold).

Which functions are valid

FunctionCritical frequenciesResult
(s2+2)(s2+4)s(s2+1)(s2+3)\dfrac{(s^2+2)(s^2+4)}{s(s^2+1)(s^2+3)}p 0, p 1, z 1.414, p 1.732, z 2Poles 0 and 1 adjacent → invalid
(s2+1)(s2+3)(s2+2)(s2+4)\dfrac{(s^2+1)(s^2+3)}{(s^2+2)(s^2+4)}z 1, p 1.414, z 1.732, p 2Even/even, equal degrees: no pole or zero at 00, ∞\infty → invalid
(s2+1)(s2+3)s(s2+2)(s2+4)\dfrac{(s^2+1)(s^2+3)}{s(s^2+2)(s^2+4)}p 0, z 1, p 1.414, z 1.732, p 2, z ∞Even/odd, alternate → valid

Realize Z(s)=s4+4s2+3s5+6s3+8sZ(s) = \dfrac{s^4+4s^2+3}{s^5+6s^3+8s}.

Foster-I form

Expand Z(s)Z(s) in partial fractions (each term is an impedance; the elements are in series):

k0=[s Z(s)]s=0=382k2=[(s2+2) Z(s)s]s2=−2=142k3=[(s2+4) Z(s)s]s2=−4=38\begin{aligned} k_0 &= \left[s\,Z(s)\right]_{s=0} = \frac{3}{8} \\ 2k_{2} &= \left[\frac{(s^2+2)\,Z(s)}{s}\right]_{s^2=-2} = \frac{1}{4} \\ 2k_{3} &= \left[\frac{(s^2+4)\,Z(s)}{s}\right]_{s^2=-4} = \frac{3}{8} \end{aligned} Z(s)=38s+s4(s2+2)+3s8(s2+4)Z(s) = \frac{3}{8 s} + \frac{s}{4 \left(s^{2} + 2\right)} + \frac{3 s}{8 \left(s^{2} + 4\right)}
TermRuleElement value
C1C_1 (series, pole at 0)1/k01/k_08/3 F (≈ 2.667 F)
L2∥C2L_2 \parallel C_2 (tank, ω2=2\omega^2=2)C=1/2kC=1/2k, L=2k/ω2L=2k/\omega^2C2C_2 = 4 F, L2L_2 = 1/8 H (≈ 0.125 H)
L3∥C3L_3 \parallel C_3 (tank, ω2=4\omega^2=4)C=1/2kC=1/2k, L=2k/ω2L=2k/\omega^2C3C_3 = 8/3 F (≈ 2.667 F), L3L_3 = 3/32 H (≈ 0.09375 H)
o--[C1]--[L2||C2]--[L3||C3]--o

Cauer-II form

Z(s)Z(s) has a pole at s=0s=0, so the first element is a series capacitor. Arrange numerator and denominator in ascending powers of ss and divide repeatedly (continued fraction about s=0s=0); each quotient is k/sk/s:

  1. Z1(s)=3+4s2+s48s+6s3+s5Z_1(s) = \frac{3 + 4 s^{2} + s^{4}}{8 s + 6 s^{3} + s^{5}} → quotient 38s\frac{3}{8 s} gives series C1C_1 = 8/3 F (≈ 2.667 F); remainder s(5s2+14)8(s2+2)(s2+4)\frac{s \left(5 s^{2} + 14\right)}{8 \left(s^{2} + 2\right) \left(s^{2} + 4\right)}.
  2. Y2(s)=64+48s2+8s414s+5s3Y_2(s) = \frac{64 + 48 s^{2} + 8 s^{4}}{14 s + 5 s^{3}} → quotient 327s\frac{32}{7 s} gives shunt L2L_2 = 7/32 H (≈ 0.2188 H); remainder 8s(7s2+22)7(5s2+14)\frac{8 s \left(7 s^{2} + 22\right)}{7 \left(5 s^{2} + 14\right)}.
  3. Z3(s)=98+35s2176s+56s3Z_3(s) = \frac{98 + 35 s^{2}}{176 s + 56 s^{3}} → quotient 4988s\frac{49}{88 s} gives series C3C_3 = 88/49 F (≈ 1.796 F); remainder 21s44(7s2+22)\frac{21 s}{44 \left(7 s^{2} + 22\right)}.
  4. Y4(s)=968+308s221sY_4(s) = \frac{968 + 308 s^{2}}{21 s} → quotient 96821s\frac{968}{21 s} gives shunt L4L_4 = 21/968 H (≈ 0.02169 H); remainder 44s3\frac{44 s}{3}.
  5. Z5(s)=344sZ_5(s) = \frac{3}{44 s} → quotient 344s\frac{3}{44 s} gives series C5C_5 = 44/3 F (≈ 14.67 F); remainder 00.
ElementPositionValue
C1C_1series8/3 F (≈ 2.667 F)
L2L_2shunt7/32 H (≈ 0.2188 H)
C3C_3series88/49 F (≈ 1.796 F)
L4L_4shunt21/968 H (≈ 0.02169 H)
C5C_5series44/3 F (≈ 14.67 F)
o--[C1]----+---[C3]----+---[C5]-+
           |           |        |
         [L2]        [L4]       |
           |           |        |
o----------+-----------+--------+

✓ Answer checked by Claude Sonnet 5.5

All Filter Design chapter 4 questions →