Skip to main content

Sensitivity of ωo and Q in Tow-Thomas LPF

Short answer

For ωo: R1, R4, C1, C2 = -1/2; R2, R3, r = 0. For Q: R2 = 1, C1 = 1/2, R1 = R4 = C2 = -1/2; R3, r = 0. All sensitivities are at most unity and independent of Q, confirming low sensitivity.

Perform sensitivity analysis for center frequency (ωo) and quality factor (Q) of the Tow Thomas low pass filter with respect to all the resistors and capacitors present in the circuit.

Tow-Thomas low-pass biquad: OA1 is a lossy integrator (R2∥C1R_2 \parallel C_1 in feedback, inputs VinV_{in} through R3R_3 and V3V_3 through R1R_1), OA2 is an integrator (R4R_4, C2C_2), and OA3 is a unity-gain inverter (V3=−V2V_3 = -V_2) built with two equal resistors rr (the gain stays −1-1 when both change together).

        +------R2------+
        +------||------+
        |      C1      |        +--||--+
Vin-R3--+--|-\         |        |  C2  |
        |  |  >--------+--R4----+-|-\  |
        |  +|/  V1     (OA1)    | |  >-+-- V2 (LP)
        | GND                GND+|/    |
        |                     (OA2)    |
        +--R1-- V3 --[inverter -1]-----+
                         (OA3)

Node equations (ideal op-amps):

V1(1R2+sC1)=−VinR3−V3R1V2=−V1sR4C2,V3=−V2\begin{aligned} V_1\left(\frac{1}{R_2} + sC_1\right) &= -\frac{V_{in}}{R_3} - \frac{V_3}{R_1} \\ V_2 &= -\frac{V_1}{sR_4C_2}, \qquad V_3 = -V_2 \end{aligned}

Solving:

T(s)=V2Vin=1R3R4C1C2s2+sR2C1+1R1R4C1C2T(s) = \frac{V_2}{V_{in}} = \frac{\dfrac{1}{R_3R_4C_1C_2}}{s^2 + \dfrac{s}{R_2C_1} + \dfrac{1}{R_1R_4C_1C_2}}

So

ωo=1R1R4C1C2=R1−1/2R4−1/2C1−1/2C2−1/2,Q=ωoR2C1=R2C1R1R4C2\omega_o = \frac{1}{\sqrt{R_1R_4C_1C_2}} = R_1^{-1/2}R_4^{-1/2}C_1^{-1/2}C_2^{-1/2}, \qquad Q = \omega_o R_2C_1 = R_2\sqrt{\frac{C_1}{R_1R_4C_2}}

Sensitivity of ωo\omega_o: ωo=R1−1/2R4−1/2C1−1/2C2−1/2\omega_o = R_1^{-1/2}R_4^{-1/2}C_1^{-1/2}C_2^{-1/2}, so using Sxxn=nS^{x^n}_x = n:

SR1ωo=SR4ωo=SC1ωo=SC2ωo=−12,SR2ωo=SR3ωo=Srωo=0S^{\omega_o}_{R_1} = S^{\omega_o}_{R_4} = S^{\omega_o}_{C_1} = S^{\omega_o}_{C_2} = -\frac12, \qquad S^{\omega_o}_{R_2} = S^{\omega_o}_{R_3} = S^{\omega_o}_{r} = 0

Example of one step: SR1ωo=R1ωo∂ωo∂R1=R1ωo(−12ωoR1)=−12S^{\omega_o}_{R_1} = \dfrac{R_1}{\omega_o}\dfrac{\partial\omega_o}{\partial R_1} = \dfrac{R_1}{\omega_o}\left(-\dfrac{1}{2}\dfrac{\omega_o}{R_1}\right) = -\dfrac12.

Check: sum over resistors =−1= -1, sum over capacitors =−1= -1, as expected for a frequency.

Sensitivity of QQ: Q=R2 C11/2 R1−1/2R4−1/2C2−1/2Q = R_2\,C_1^{1/2}\,R_1^{-1/2}R_4^{-1/2}C_2^{-1/2}, so

SR2Q=1,SC1Q=12,SR1Q=SR4Q=SC2Q=−12,SR3Q=SrQ=0S^{Q}_{R_2} = 1, \quad S^{Q}_{C_1} = \frac12, \quad S^{Q}_{R_1} = S^{Q}_{R_4} = S^{Q}_{C_2} = -\frac12, \quad S^Q_{R_3} = S^Q_r = 0

For example, SR2Q=R2Q⋅∂Q∂R2=R2Q⋅QR2=1S^Q_{R_2} = \dfrac{R_2}{Q}\cdot\dfrac{\partial Q}{\partial R_2} = \dfrac{R_2}{Q}\cdot\dfrac{Q}{R_2} = 1.

Check: sum over resistors =1−12−12=0= 1 - \frac12 - \frac12 = 0, sum over capacitors =12−12=0= \frac12 - \frac12 = 0, as expected for a dimensionless quantity.

Summary

ElementSωoS^{\omega_o}SQS^{Q}
R1R_1−1/2−1/2
R2R_201
R3R_300
R4R_4−1/2−1/2
C1C_1−1/21/2
C2C_2−1/2−1/2
Inverter rr00

All sensitivities are at most 1 in magnitude and do not depend on QQ, so the Tow-Thomas biquad is a low-sensitivity circuit; R2R_2 tunes QQ alone, and R3R_3 sets the gain alone.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Sonnet 5.5

All Filter Design chapter 7 questions →