- Practice · 6 marks
Horizontal and vertical axis wind turbines
Short answer
HAWT shafts are horizontal, need yaw, high efficiency; VAWT shafts are vertical, accept wind from any direction, generator at ground. VAWT types: Savonius (drag, high starting torque, λ≈1, Cp≈0.15–0.2) and Darrieus (lift, not self-starting, λ≈4–6, Cp≈0.35–0.40). Cp–λ curve: each rotor has one optimum λ; multi-blade rotors peak at low λ, three-blade HAWT peaks at λ≈6–8.
Differentiate between horizontal axis and vertical axis wind turbines. Name the types of VAWT and explain the power coefficient versus tip speed ratio characteristics of different rotors.
Tip speed ratio is , where is the blade tip speed. The curve of against shows how a rotor type behaves.
HAWT versus VAWT
| Point | HAWT | VAWT |
|---|---|---|
| Shaft | Horizontal, parallel to wind | Vertical, normal to wind |
| Wind direction | Needs yaw mechanism | Accepts wind from any direction |
| Generator and gearbox | On tower top, heavy | At ground level, easy service |
| Efficiency () | High, 0.40–0.50 | Lower, 0.15–0.40 |
| Self-starting | Yes | Darrieus is not self-starting |
| Tower and wind speed | Tall tower, uses higher wind | Short tower, lower wind speed |
| Blade loading | Gravity load varies with rotation | Pulsating torque, fatigue |
| Use | Utility-scale (kW to MW) | Small, urban, low-wind sites |
Types of VAWT
- Savonius: two or three half-cylinder cups; a drag device; high starting torque, low speed, , –0.2; used for water pumping and ventilation.
- Darrieus: curved or straight blades (H-rotor) with aerofoil section; lift device; –6, –0.40; needs starting help.
- characteristics
Cp
0.5| ___ 3-blade HAWT
| / \
0.4| / _.-Darrieus
| / / \
0.2| Savonius \
| _/_.-'''-.
+---------------------- lambda
1 2 4 6 8
- Multi-bladed American windmill: peak at , high torque, low (about 0.3) and good for pumping.
- Three-blade HAWT: peak at –8, high speed, suitable for electricity.
- Each rotor has one optimum ; away from it drops, so variable-speed operation keeps near the optimum.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Wind turbine power, tip speed ratio and energy · Energy Resources, chapter 4
- Wind sources, turbines, parks, power control · Energy Environment and Society, chapter 3
- Solar generation and wind power characteristics · Power Plant Design, chapter 1
- Tidal versus wind power plant · Power Plant Design, chapter 1
- Vertical curve with horizontal curve, 45 degrees · Transportation Engineering I, chapter 3