Skip to main content

Drag on a cylinder and shedding frequency

Short answer

Re = 5×10⁴. Drag force F_D =16.2 N, required power =243 W. Vortex shedding frequency f_s =60 Hz (St =0.2). Bluff bodies have large pressure drag from separated wakes; streamlined bodies have mainly skin friction. CFD predicts drag by integrating pressure and shear stress over the surface.

Air (ρ=1.2\rho = 1.2 kg/m³, μ=1.8×10−5\mu = 1.8\times10^{-5} Pa·s) flows at 15 m/s across a long circular cylinder of diameter 50 mm and length 2 m. (a) Find the Reynolds number. (b) Taking CD=1.2C_D = 1.2, find the drag force and power. (c) Estimate the vortex shedding frequency for St=0.2St = 0.2. (d) Explain why a bluff body has a larger drag than a streamlined body and how CFD predicts it.

(a) Reynolds number

Re=ρUDμ=1.2×15×0.051.8×10−5=5.0×104Re=\frac{\rho UD}{\mu}=\frac{1.2\times15\times0.05}{1.8\times10^{-5}}=5.0\times10^{4}

This is in the subcritical range (about 10310^3 to 2×1052\times10^5), where the laminar boundary layer separates near 80∘80^\circ and CD≈1.2C_D\approx1.2, so the given value is reasonable.

(b) Drag force and power

Reference area (projected) A=DL=0.05×2=0.10A=DL=0.05\times2=0.10 m².

FD=12ρU2CDA=0.5×1.2×152×1.2×0.10=16.2 NF_D=\tfrac12\rho U^2C_DA=0.5\times1.2\times15^2\times1.2\times0.10=16.2\ \text{N}

Power to overcome drag:

P=FDU=16.2×15=243 WP=F_DU=16.2\times15=243\ \text{W}

(c) Vortex shedding

fs=St UD=0.2×150.05=60 Hzf_s=\frac{St\,U}{D}=\frac{0.2\times15}{0.05}=60\ \text{Hz}

Alternating vortices (von Karman street) produce an oscillating lift force at this frequency, which can excite vibration and noise.

(d) Bluff versus streamlined bodies

 Bluff body                 Streamlined body
   ____                        ______
  /    \  large wake        ---/      \___  thin wake
 |  O   |:::::::::::::       ---\______/
  \____/  low pressure         attached flow
  • On a bluff body the boundary layer separates early because of the strong adverse pressure gradient. A broad low-pressure wake forms behind it, so pressure is much lower on the rear than the front: large pressure (form) drag dominates (friction drag is small).
  • On a streamlined body the flow stays attached up to the tail, the wake is thin, and drag is mainly skin friction, which is much smaller.

CFD prediction: a 2D/3D domain extending about 10D upstream and 20D downstream is meshed with prism layers; RANS (k-ω\omega SST) or unsteady URANS/LES is used; CDC_D is computed by integrating surface pressure and shear stress over the body. Wake resolution and separation prediction are the main sources of error, so validation with experimental CDC_D is needed.

Answer: Re=5×104Re=5\times10^4; FD=16.2F_D=16.2 N; P=243P=243 W; fs=60f_s=60 Hz.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Applied Computational Fluid Dynamics chapter 6 questions →