Skip to main content

Moving observer: car counts on 800 m road

Short answer

Average counts give Ns=82.25, No=17, Np=32.25, y=-15.25. Flow q = (82.25-15.25)/(0.08) = 837.5 veh/h; journey time 0.0582 h, so journey speed = 0.8/0.0582 = 13.7 km/h.

A car driver was driving along 800 m road. She counted the number of cars that she meets while driving southwards (Ns), the number of cars that overtake her while driving northward (No), and the numbers of cars that she overtakes while driving northward (Np) is shown in table below. Find the average traffic flow and journey speed. Given that she travels at a constant speed of 20 kmph.

Vehicle met while driving southwardVehicle overtaking while driving northVehicle overtaken while driving north
1071074
1132541
30155
79189

The moving observer method gives the flow qq and mean stream speed from counts made by a test car running with and against the stream.

Reading of the table: the vehicles she meets while driving southward are the northbound stream she is measuring (NsN_s); while driving northward, NoN_o = cars that overtake her and NpN_p = cars she overtakes. Section length 800 m, test speed 20 km/h on both runs.

Average counts (4 runs)

Nˉs=107+113+30+794=82.25Nˉo=10+25+15+184=17.00,Nˉp=74+41+5+94=32.25y=Nˉo−Nˉp=−15.25\begin{aligned} \bar N_s &= \frac{107+113+30+79}{4} = 82.25\\ \bar N_o &= \frac{10+25+15+18}{4} = 17.00, \quad \bar N_p = \frac{74+41+5+9}{4} = 32.25\\ y &= \bar N_o - \bar N_p = -15.25 \end{aligned}

Travel times

tw=ta=0.820=0.04 h=2.4 mint_w = t_a = \frac{0.8}{20} = 0.04\ \text{h} = 2.4\ \text{min}

Traffic flow

q=Ns+ytw+ta=82.25+(−15.25)0.04+0.04=837.5 veh/hq = \frac{N_s + y}{t_w + t_a} = \frac{82.25 + (-15.25)}{0.04 + 0.04} = 837.5\ \text{veh/h}

Journey time and speed of the stream

tˉ=tw−yq=0.04−(−15.25)837.5=0.0582 h=3.49 min\bar t = t_w - \frac{y}{q} = 0.04 - \frac{(-15.25)}{837.5} = 0.0582\ \text{h} = 3.49\ \text{min} Vj=Ltˉ=0.80.0582=13.74 km/hV_j = \frac{L}{\bar t} = \frac{0.8}{0.0582} = 13.74\ \text{km/h}

Answer: average flow = 837.5 veh/h; journey speed = 13.7 km/h (journey time 3.49 min). The stream is slower than the test car because more vehicles were overtaken by her than overtook her.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Transportation Engineering II chapter 1 questions →