Skip to main content

Chapter 1 · 16 hours

Traffic Engineering

IOE past exam questions

Past questions and answers

86 questions set from this chapter, 2 of them more than once; 3 are most repeated (set, or a close variant set, in 3 or more exams). Most repeated first.

  • Most repeated · 3 of 20 exams
  • Asked 3 times
  • 2079 Bhadra · 8 marks
  • 2078 Bhadra · 8 marks
  • 2076 Asoj · 8 marks

Describe the critical physical, mental and psychological characteristics of driver that affect his/her traffic performance.

Answer

Driver characteristics are the personal attributes that decide how a driver senses, decides and acts in traffic. The critical ones are physical, mental and psychological.

Physical characteristics

  • Vision: acuity (about 6/6 needed for a licence), the cone of clear vision (3-5 degrees), the field of vision (clear about 10 degrees, fairly clear about 12-14 degrees, peripheral up to about 120-180 degrees), colour perception (colour blindness for red/green is critical for signals), glare sensitivity, glare recovery and depth perception. Speed narrows the field of vision (at 100 km/h only about 40 degrees).
  • Hearing: horn and siren detection; deafness is partly compensated by vision, but affects awareness of emergency vehicles.
  • Reaction ability: muscle coordination, strength and speed of hand/foot response; fatigue, age and disability reduce it.
  • Age and health: reaction slows and vision/hearing fade in old age; illness, epilepsy and heart conditions are hazards.
  • Fatigue, alcohol and drugs: lengthen reaction time, impair judgement and cause drowsiness; Nepal's Motor Vehicles and Transport Management Act 2049 prohibits driving under the influence.

Mental characteristics

  • Intelligence and judgement: ability to judge speed, distance, gaps and the intentions of other users.
  • Knowledge and training: familiarity with traffic rules, signs and the route; unfamiliar drivers hesitate and make errors.
  • Attention and concentration: a driver can attend to only a limited amount of information; distractions (mobile phone, passengers) reduce attention.
  • Memory and learning: helps in recognising signs and routes and in forming habits.
  • Perception-reaction process (PIEV): perception, intellection, emotion and volition, which together determine the total reaction time.

Psychological characteristics

  • Emotional state and temperament: anger, stress, worry or elation lead to aggressive driving, overtaking in unsafe places and over-speeding.
  • Attitude and behaviour: attitude towards rules, other users and risk; over-confident or risk-taking drivers have more crashes.
  • Anxiety and fear: a nervous driver may brake suddenly or hesitate at intersections.
  • Social habits: lane discipline, courtesy, and tendency to follow the crowd.
  • Driving habits and experience: young drivers take more risks; experienced drivers anticipate hazards better.
  • Response to stimuli: drivers often react to expected events but are slow to react to unexpected ones (for example a stationary vehicle on a bend).

Design implication

Because drivers vary, design values are taken for an average or conservative driver: perception-reaction time of 2.5 s for sight distance (IRC:66, IRC:SP:23; Nepal Road Standard 2070), letter sizes of signs matched to acuity, and lighting and markings to help night vision.

  • Most repeated · 3 of 20 exams
  • 2082 Bhadra · 8 marks

Two vehicles A and B approaching at right angles, A from North and B from West collide with each other. After the collision, vehicle A skids in a direction 47° East of North and vehicle B skids 56° South of East. The initial skid distance of the vehicles A and B are 32 and 18 m respectively before collision. The skid distances after collision are 14 and 33 m respectively. If the weights of vehicles A and B are 4 and 6 tonnes respectively, calculate the original speeds of vehicles. The average skid resistance of the pavement is found to be 0.52.

Similar questions: Skid numerical: A from West, B from South (51, 61) (2078 Bhadra) · Skid numerical: A from West, B from South (45, 50) (2080 Bhadra)

Answer

A collision on a flat road is solved by (i) finding each vehicle's speed just after impact from its post-collision skid, (ii) applying conservation of linear momentum as a vector equation to get the speeds just before impact, and (iii) adding back the energy lost in the pre-collision skid.

Given: WA=4W_A = 4 t, WB=6W_B = 6 t, f=0.52f = 0.52, g=9.81 m/s2g = 9.81\ \text{m/s}^2. Pre-collision skids: dA=32d_A = 32 m, dB=18d_B = 18 m. Post-collision skids: dA′=14d_A' = 14 m, dB′=33d_B' = 33 m.

Vehicle A comes from the North (moving South). Vehicle B comes from the West (moving East). After impact A slides 47 degrees East of North and B slides 56 degrees South of East.

where θ\theta is the bearing from North, clockwise: θA=180∘\theta_A = 180^\circ, θB=90∘\theta_B = 90^\circ (travel directions) and θA′=47∘\theta_A' = 47^\circ, θB′=146∘\theta_B' = 146^\circ (skid directions after impact).

   before impact          after impact
   A: bearing 180 deg       A': bearing 47 deg
   B: bearing 90 deg       B': bearing 146 deg
   (bearing measured clockwise from North)

Step 1: Speeds just after collision

From work-energy, v′=2gfd′v' = \sqrt{2 g f d'}:

vA′=2(9.81)(0.52)(14)=11.95 m/svB′=2(9.81)(0.52)(33)=18.35 m/s\begin{aligned} v_A' &= \sqrt{2(9.81)(0.52)(14)} = 11.95\ \text{m/s}\\ v_B' &= \sqrt{2(9.81)(0.52)(33)} = 18.35\ \text{m/s} \end{aligned}

Step 2: Momentum balance (vector form)

Take xx = East and yy = North, and let uA,uBu_A, u_B be the speeds just before impact. Weights are proportional to masses, so they can be used directly.

WAuAsin⁡θA+WBuBsin⁡θB=WAvA′sin⁡θA′+WBvB′sin⁡θB′WAuAcos⁡θA+WBuBcos⁡θB=WAvA′cos⁡θA′+WBvB′cos⁡θB′\begin{aligned} W_A u_A \sin\theta_A + W_B u_B \sin\theta_B &= W_A v_A' \sin\theta_A' + W_B v_B' \sin\theta_B' \\ W_A u_A \cos\theta_A + W_B u_B \cos\theta_B &= W_A v_A' \cos\theta_A' + W_B v_B' \cos\theta_B' \end{aligned}

Substituting the numbers:

4 uA(0.0000)+6 uB(1.0000)=4(11.951)(0.7314)+6(18.349)(0.5592)=96.5264 uA(−1.0000)+6 uB(0.0000)=4(11.951)(0.6820)+6(18.349)(−0.8290)=−58.668\begin{aligned} 4\,u_A(0.0000) + 6\,u_B(1.0000) &= 4(11.951)(0.7314) + 6(18.349)(0.5592) = 96.526 \\ 4\,u_A(-1.0000) + 6\,u_B(0.0000) &= 4(11.951)(0.6820) + 6(18.349)(-0.8290) = -58.668 \end{aligned}

Solving: uA=14.67 m/s=52.8 km/hu_A = 14.67\ \text{m/s} = 52.8\ \text{km/h} and uB=16.09 m/s=57.9 km/hu_B = 16.09\ \text{m/s} = 57.9\ \text{km/h} at the instant of impact.

Step 3: Original speeds (before the pre-collision skid)

v0=u2+2gfdv_0 = \sqrt{u^2 + 2 g f d}:

vA=(14.67)2+2(9.81)(0.52)(32)=23.27 m/svB=(16.09)2+2(9.81)(0.52)(18)=21.03 m/s\begin{aligned} v_A &= \sqrt{(14.67)^2 + 2(9.81)(0.52)(32)} = 23.27\ \text{m/s}\\ v_B &= \sqrt{(16.09)^2 + 2(9.81)(0.52)(18)} = 21.03\ \text{m/s} \end{aligned}

Answer: original speed of vehicle AA = 83.8 km/h and of vehicle BB = 75.7 km/h (speeds at impact: 52.8 and 57.9 km/h).

  • Most repeated · 3 of 20 exams
  • 2070 Chaitra · 8 marks

An isolated signal with pedestrians indication is to be installed on a right angled intersection with road H of 12 m wide and road F of 9.6 m wide. The heaviest volume per hour for each lane of H and F are 475 and 325 respectively. The approach speeds are 60 and 45 kmph for road H and road F respectively. Design the timings of traffic and pedestrian signals. Assume amber times for road H and road F as 5 and 4 secs respectively.

Similar questions: Signal timing: roads A 18 m and B 12 m (2081 Baisakh) · Signal timing: roads A 15 m and B 12 m (2071 Chaitra)

Answer

Isolated two-phase signal with pedestrian indications for road H (12 m) and road F (9.6 m). The ambers are given (5 s and 4 s), so the approach speeds are not needed for them.

Design basis (IRC:93-1985, Guidelines on Design and Installation of Road Traffic Signals, with Webster's method): two-phase signal, Phase 1 = road H moves, Phase 2 = road F moves. Pedestrians cross a road while the traffic on the cross road has green. Assumed (not given): saturation flow 1800 PCU/h per lane, start-up lost time 2 s per phase, pedestrian walking speed 1.2 m/s and initial walk (pedestrian start-up) time 5 s.

Step 1: Amber (change) time

Amber times are given: road H = 5 s, road F = 4 s.

Step 2: Pedestrian crossing time

Time to cross = initial walk + width / walking speed:

tp,H=5+121.2=15.0 stp,F=5+9.61.2=13.0 s\begin{aligned} t_{p,H} &= 5 + \frac{12}{1.2} = 15.0\ \text{s}\\ t_{p,F} &= 5 + \frac{9.6}{1.2} = 13.0\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Pedestrians crossing road H walk during Phase 2, so Phase 2 green must be at least 15.0 s. Pedestrians crossing road F walk during Phase 1, so Phase 1 green must be at least 13.0 s.

Step 3: Webster cycle time from traffic

yH=4751800=0.264,yF=3251800=0.181,Y=0.444L=(2+5)+(2+4)=13 sC0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(13)+51−0.444=44.1 s\begin{aligned} y_H &= \frac{475}{1800} = 0.264, \quad y_F = \frac{325}{1800} = 0.181, \quad Y = 0.444\\ L &= (2+5) + (2+4) = 13\ \text{s}\\ C_0 &= \frac{1.5L+5}{1-Y} = \frac{1.5(13)+5}{1-0.444} = 44.1\ \text{s} \end{aligned} gH=0.2640.444(31.1)=18.5 s,GH=gH+2=20.5 sgF=0.1810.444(31.1)=12.6 s,GF=gF+2=14.6 s\begin{aligned} g_H &= \frac{0.264}{0.444}(31.1) = 18.5\ \text{s}, \quad G_H = g_H + 2 = 20.5\ \text{s}\\ g_F &= \frac{0.181}{0.444}(31.1) = 12.6\ \text{s}, \quad G_F = g_F + 2 = 14.6\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 4: Check against pedestrian needs

PhaseGreen from traffic (s)Pedestrian minimum (s)Adopted green (s)
1 (road H)20.513.021
2 (road F)14.615.015

Adopted cycle length C=21+5+15+4=45C = 21 + 5 + 15 + 4 = 45 s.

Final timings

SignalPhase 1: road HPhase 2: road F
Vehicle green21 s15 s
Vehicle amber5 s4 s
Vehicle red19 s26 s

Pedestrian signals: pedestrians crossing road F get WALK for 5 s then flashing (clearance) for 8 s during Phase 1 (total 13 s of 21 s green); pedestrians crossing road H get WALK for 5 s then flashing for 10 s during Phase 2 (total 15 s of 15 s green). All pedestrian indications show DON'T WALK (red man) while their cross traffic moves.

Phase diagram

Cycle = 45 s
Road H: [GREEN 21][A 5][  RED 19  ]
Road F: [ RED 26 ][GREEN 15][A 4]
Ped crossing F: [WALK+FLASH 21][DON'T WALK 24]
Ped crossing H: [DON'T WALK 26][WALK+FLASH 15][DW]
  • Asked 2 times
  • 2082 Baisakh · 8 marks
  • 2070 Chaitra (old course) · 8 marks

What are general requirements of traffic control devices? Explain the different types of traffic sign.

Answer

General requirements of traffic control devices

  1. Fulfil a need: each device must be justified by a real need based on a traffic study.
  2. Command attention: be conspicuous (size, colour, shape, retro-reflectivity).
  3. Convey a clear and simple meaning that can be understood at a glance.
  4. Command respect: be used only where needed, not over-used, so that drivers obey.
  5. Give adequate time for response: placed in advance of the hazard, with enough time to read and act.
  6. Be uniform: the same type of device, shape and colour everywhere in the country.
  7. Be legible and visible at night (reflectorised or illuminated).
  8. Be maintained: clean, repainted, repaired.
  9. Be properly located and enforced by traffic police.

Types of traffic signs

TypePurposeShape and colour
Regulatory (mandatory)Tell the driver what to do or not do (stop, give way, no entry, speed limit, no parking)Circular, red border, white background; STOP is an octagon, GIVE WAY an inverted triangle
Cautionary (warning)Warn of a hazard ahead (curve, steep descent, junction, school, narrow bridge)Equilateral triangle, red border, white background, black symbol
Informatory (guide)Give directions, place names, distances, facilities (hospital, parking, fuel)Rectangular; blue (facilities) or green (direction on highways) background, white letters

Subdivisions: informatory signs include direction signs, place identification, route markers, facility information and parking signs.

Placement: within the cone of clear vision, 3 m lateral clearance from the edge, with a mounting height of 2.0-2.5 m above the ground; legends in a size that can be read at the speed of the road.

 Regulatory      Warning        Informatory
  .-----.        /\            +---------+
 /  STOP \      /  \           | HOSPITAL|
 \  (red) /     / !  \          +---------+
  `-----'      /______\        blue/green
 circle/octagon  triangle       rectangle
  • 2081 Bhadra · 8 marks

Assuming the linear speed-density relationship, the mean free speed is observed to be 80 kmph near zero density and the corresponding jam density is 120 veh/hr.
a) Write down the speed-density and flow density equation. b) Draw v-k, v-q and q-v diagram indicating the critical values. c) Compute speed and density corresponding to flow of 800 veh/hr. d) Compute the avg headways, spacing when the flow is maximum.

Similar questions: Linear speed-density: free speed 90, jam 150 (2079 Bhadra)

Answer

(Jam density is a number of vehicles per kilometre, so "veh/hr" in the question is read as veh/km.)

(a) Speed-density and flow-density equations

For a linear (Greenshields) relation, speed falls from the free-flow speed vfv_f at zero density to zero at jam density kjk_j:

v=vf(1−kkj)=80(1−k120)=80−0.6667 kv = v_f\left(1-\frac{k}{k_j}\right) = 80\left(1-\frac{k}{120}\right) = 80 - 0.6667\,k

Since q=v kq = v\,k:

q=vf k(1−kkj)=80 k−0.6667 k2q = v_f\,k\left(1-\frac{k}{k_j}\right) = 80\,k - 0.6667\,k^2

(b) Diagrams and critical values

Setting dq/dk=0dq/dk = 0 gives km=kj/2k_m = k_j/2, vm=vf/2v_m = v_f/2 and qmax=vfkj/4q_{max} = v_f k_j/4:

km=120/2=60 veh/kmvm=80/2=40 km/hqmax=80×1204=2400 veh/h\begin{aligned} k_m &= 120/2 = 60\ \text{veh/km}\\ v_m &= 80/2 = 40\ \text{km/h}\\ q_{max} &= \frac{80 \times 120}{4} = 2400\ \text{veh/h} \end{aligned}
v-k diagram (straight line)
 v (km/h)
   80 |*
      |   *
   40 |- - - *   <- at q max
      |         *
      +-----------*--- k (veh/km)
      0    60     120

q-k diagram (parabola)
 q (veh/h)
 2400 |        _ * _   <- q max
      |     *         *
      |   *             *
      +--*-------|-------*-- k
      0        60       120

v-q diagram (half parabola)
 v (km/h)
   80 |*
      |  *
   40 |- - - *  <- q max (nose)
      |     *
      |   *   (congested branch)
      +--------|--------- q (veh/h)
      0       2400

(c) Speed and density for a flow of 800 veh/h

Substitute in q=vfk−(vf/kj)k2q = v_f k - (v_f/k_j)k^2:

0.6667k2−80k+800=0⇒k=80±802−4(0.6667)(800)2(0.6667)0.6667k^2 - 80k + 800 = 0 \quad\Rightarrow\quad k = \frac{80 \pm \sqrt{80^2 - 4(0.6667)(800)}}{2(0.6667)} k1=11.01 veh/km,k2=108.99 veh/kmk_1 = 11.01\ \text{veh/km},\quad k_2 = 108.99\ \text{veh/km}
  • Uncongested (stable) state: k=11.0k = 11.0 veh/km and v=80(1−11.01/120)=72.7v = 80(1-11.01/120) = 72.7 km/h.
  • Congested (forced) state: k=109.0k = 109.0 veh/km and v=7.3v = 7.3 km/h.

Answer: for 800 veh/h, speed = 72.7 km/h at density = 11.0 veh/km (stable flow); the congested alternative is 7.3 km/h at 109.0 veh/km.

(d) Headway, spacing at maximum flow

At qmax=2400q_{max} = 2400 veh/h, km=60k_m = 60 veh/km, vm=40v_m = 40 km/h:

Average headway h=3600qmax=36002400=1.50 sAverage spacing s=1000km=100060=16.67 m\begin{aligned} \text{Average headway}\ h &= \frac{3600}{q_{max}} = \frac{3600}{2400} = 1.50\ \text{s}\\ \text{Average spacing}\ s &= \frac{1000}{k_m} = \frac{1000}{60} = 16.67\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Answer: headway = 1.50 s, spacing = 16.67 m.

  • 2081 Baisakh · 8 marks

An isolated signal with pedestrian indication is to be installed on a right angled intersection with road A, 18m wide and road B, 12m wide. The heaviest volume per hour for each lane of road A and B are 300 and 250, respectively. The approach speeds are 55 and 40 kmph for road A and B respectively. Design the timing of traffic and pedestrian signals.

Similar questions: Signal timing: roads H 12 m and F 9.6 m (2070 Chaitra)

Answer

Isolated two-phase signal with pedestrian indications for road A (18 m) and road B (12 m).

Design basis (IRC:93-1985, Guidelines on Design and Installation of Road Traffic Signals, with Webster's method): two-phase signal, Phase 1 = road A moves, Phase 2 = road B moves. Pedestrians cross a road while the traffic on the cross road has green. Assumed (not given): saturation flow 1800 PCU/h per lane, start-up lost time 2 s per phase, pedestrian walking speed 1.2 m/s and initial walk (pedestrian start-up) time 5 s.

Step 1: Amber (change) time

Amber I=tr+v2aI = t_r + \dfrac{v}{2a} with reaction time tr=1t_r = 1 s and comfortable deceleration a=3 m/s2a = 3\ \text{m/s}^2, kept within the IRC:93 range of 2-4 s:

IA=1+55/3.62(3)=3.55→4 sIB=1+40/3.62(3)=2.85→3 s\begin{aligned} I_A &= 1 + \frac{55/3.6}{2(3)} = 3.55 \to 4\ \text{s}\\ I_B &= 1 + \frac{40/3.6}{2(3)} = 2.85 \to 3\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 2: Pedestrian crossing time

Time to cross = initial walk + width / walking speed:

tp,A=5+181.2=20.0 stp,B=5+121.2=15.0 s\begin{aligned} t_{p,A} &= 5 + \frac{18}{1.2} = 20.0\ \text{s}\\ t_{p,B} &= 5 + \frac{12}{1.2} = 15.0\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Pedestrians crossing road A walk during Phase 2, so Phase 2 green must be at least 20.0 s. Pedestrians crossing road B walk during Phase 1, so Phase 1 green must be at least 15.0 s.

Step 3: Webster cycle time from traffic

yA=3001800=0.167,yB=2501800=0.139,Y=0.306L=(2+4)+(2+3)=11 sC0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(11)+51−0.306=31.0 s\begin{aligned} y_A &= \frac{300}{1800} = 0.167, \quad y_B = \frac{250}{1800} = 0.139, \quad Y = 0.306\\ L &= (2+4) + (2+3) = 11\ \text{s}\\ C_0 &= \frac{1.5L+5}{1-Y} = \frac{1.5(11)+5}{1-0.306} = 31.0\ \text{s} \end{aligned} gA=0.1670.306(20.0)=10.9 s,GA=gA+2=12.9 sgB=0.1390.306(20.0)=9.1 s,GB=gB+2=11.1 s\begin{aligned} g_A &= \frac{0.167}{0.306}(20.0) = 10.9\ \text{s}, \quad G_A = g_A + 2 = 12.9\ \text{s}\\ g_B &= \frac{0.139}{0.306}(20.0) = 9.1\ \text{s}, \quad G_B = g_B + 2 = 11.1\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 4: Check against pedestrian needs

PhaseGreen from traffic (s)Pedestrian minimum (s)Adopted green (s)
1 (road A)12.915.015
2 (road B)11.120.020

Adopted cycle length C=15+4+20+3=42C = 15 + 4 + 20 + 3 = 42 s.

Final timings

SignalPhase 1: road APhase 2: road B
Vehicle green15 s20 s
Vehicle amber4 s3 s
Vehicle red23 s19 s

Pedestrian signals: pedestrians crossing road B get WALK for 5 s then flashing (clearance) for 10 s during Phase 1 (total 15 s of 15 s green); pedestrians crossing road A get WALK for 5 s then flashing for 15 s during Phase 2 (total 20 s of 20 s green). All pedestrian indications show DON'T WALK (red man) while their cross traffic moves.

Phase diagram

Cycle = 42 s
Road A: [GREEN 15][A 4][  RED 23  ]
Road B: [ RED 19 ][GREEN 20][A 3]
Ped crossing B: [WALK+FLASH 15][DON'T WALK 27]
Ped crossing A: [DON'T WALK 19][WALK+FLASH 20][DW]
  • 2080 Bhadra · 6 marks

Two vehicles A and B approaching at right angle, A from west and B from south, collide with each other. After the collision, vehicle A skids in a direction 45 deg. north of the west and vehicle B, 50 deg. east of north. The initial skid distance of vehicles A and B are 35 and 25m respectively before collision. The skid distance after collision are 30m and 10m respectively. If the weight of vehicles A and B are 3.5 and 6 tonnes respectively, calculate the original speed of vehicles. The avg. skid resistance of the pavement is found to be 0.55.

Similar questions: Skid numerical: A from North, B from West (2082 Bhadra)

Answer

A collision on a flat road is solved by (i) finding each vehicle's speed just after impact from its post-collision skid, (ii) applying conservation of linear momentum as a vector equation to get the speeds just before impact, and (iii) adding back the energy lost in the pre-collision skid.

Given: WA=3.5W_A = 3.5 t, WB=6W_B = 6 t, f=0.55f = 0.55, g=9.81 m/s2g = 9.81\ \text{m/s}^2. Pre-collision skids: dA=35d_A = 35 m, dB=25d_B = 25 m. Post-collision skids: dA′=30d_A' = 30 m, dB′=10d_B' = 10 m.

Vehicle A comes from the West (moving East). Vehicle B comes from the South (moving North). After impact A slides 45 degrees North of West and B slides 50 degrees East of North.

where θ\theta is the bearing from North, clockwise: θA=90∘\theta_A = 90^\circ, θB=0∘\theta_B = 0^\circ (travel directions) and θA′=315∘\theta_A' = 315^\circ, θB′=50∘\theta_B' = 50^\circ (skid directions after impact).

   before impact          after impact
   A: bearing 90 deg       A': bearing 315 deg
   B: bearing 0 deg       B': bearing 50 deg
   (bearing measured clockwise from North)

Step 1: Speeds just after collision

From work-energy, v′=2gfd′v' = \sqrt{2 g f d'}:

vA′=2(9.81)(0.55)(30)=17.99 m/svB′=2(9.81)(0.55)(10)=10.39 m/s\begin{aligned} v_A' &= \sqrt{2(9.81)(0.55)(30)} = 17.99\ \text{m/s}\\ v_B' &= \sqrt{2(9.81)(0.55)(10)} = 10.39\ \text{m/s} \end{aligned}

Step 2: Momentum balance (vector form)

Take xx = East and yy = North, and let uA,uBu_A, u_B be the speeds just before impact. Weights are proportional to masses, so they can be used directly.

WAuAsin⁡θA+WBuBsin⁡θB=WAvA′sin⁡θA′+WBvB′sin⁡θB′WAuAcos⁡θA+WBuBcos⁡θB=WAvA′cos⁡θA′+WBvB′cos⁡θB′\begin{aligned} W_A u_A \sin\theta_A + W_B u_B \sin\theta_B &= W_A v_A' \sin\theta_A' + W_B v_B' \sin\theta_B' \\ W_A u_A \cos\theta_A + W_B u_B \cos\theta_B &= W_A v_A' \cos\theta_A' + W_B v_B' \cos\theta_B' \end{aligned}

Substituting the numbers:

3.5 uA(1.0000)+6 uB(0.0000)=3.5(17.992)(−0.7071)+6(10.388)(0.7660)=3.2173.5 uA(0.0000)+6 uB(1.0000)=3.5(17.992)(0.7071)+6(10.388)(0.6428)=84.593\begin{aligned} 3.5\,u_A(1.0000) + 6\,u_B(0.0000) &= 3.5(17.992)(-0.7071) + 6(10.388)(0.7660) = 3.217 \\ 3.5\,u_A(0.0000) + 6\,u_B(1.0000) &= 3.5(17.992)(0.7071) + 6(10.388)(0.6428) = 84.593 \end{aligned}

Solving: uA=0.92 m/s=3.3 km/hu_A = 0.92\ \text{m/s} = 3.3\ \text{km/h} and uB=14.10 m/s=50.8 km/hu_B = 14.10\ \text{m/s} = 50.8\ \text{km/h} at the instant of impact.

Step 3: Original speeds (before the pre-collision skid)

v0=u2+2gfdv_0 = \sqrt{u^2 + 2 g f d}:

vA=(0.92)2+2(9.81)(0.55)(35)=19.46 m/svB=(14.10)2+2(9.81)(0.55)(25)=21.65 m/s\begin{aligned} v_A &= \sqrt{(0.92)^2 + 2(9.81)(0.55)(35)} = 19.46\ \text{m/s}\\ v_B &= \sqrt{(14.10)^2 + 2(9.81)(0.55)(25)} = 21.65\ \text{m/s} \end{aligned}

Answer: original speed of vehicle AA = 70.0 km/h and of vehicle BB = 77.9 km/h (speeds at impact: 3.3 and 50.8 km/h).

  • 2079 Bhadra · 8 marks

Assuming the linear speed-density relationship, the mean free speed is observed to be 90 kmph near zero density and the corresponding jam density is 150 veh/hr. Average length of vehicle is 6.1 m.
a) Write down the speed-density and flow density equation. b) Draw v-k, v-q and q-v diagram indicating the critical values. c) Compute speed and density corresponding to flow of 800 veh/hr. d) Compute the avg headways, spacing, clearance and gap when the flow is maximum.

Similar questions: Linear speed-density: free speed 80, jam 120 (2081 Bhadra)

Answer

(Jam density is a number of vehicles per kilometre, so "veh/hr" in the question is read as veh/km.)

(a) Speed-density and flow-density equations

For a linear (Greenshields) relation, speed falls from the free-flow speed vfv_f at zero density to zero at jam density kjk_j:

v=vf(1−kkj)=90(1−k150)=90−0.6 kv = v_f\left(1-\frac{k}{k_j}\right) = 90\left(1-\frac{k}{150}\right) = 90 - 0.6\,k

Since q=v kq = v\,k:

q=vf k(1−kkj)=90 k−0.6 k2q = v_f\,k\left(1-\frac{k}{k_j}\right) = 90\,k - 0.6\,k^2

(b) Diagrams and critical values

Setting dq/dk=0dq/dk = 0 gives km=kj/2k_m = k_j/2, vm=vf/2v_m = v_f/2 and qmax=vfkj/4q_{max} = v_f k_j/4:

km=150/2=75 veh/kmvm=90/2=45 km/hqmax=90×1504=3375 veh/h\begin{aligned} k_m &= 150/2 = 75\ \text{veh/km}\\ v_m &= 90/2 = 45\ \text{km/h}\\ q_{max} &= \frac{90 \times 150}{4} = 3375\ \text{veh/h} \end{aligned}
v-k diagram (straight line)
 v (km/h)
   90 |*
      |   *
   45 |- - - *   <- at q max
      |         *
      +-----------*--- k (veh/km)
      0    75     150

q-k diagram (parabola)
 q (veh/h)
 3375 |        _ * _   <- q max
      |     *         *
      |   *             *
      +--*-------|-------*-- k
      0        75       150

v-q diagram (half parabola)
 v (km/h)
   90 |*
      |  *
   45 |- - - *  <- q max (nose)
      |     *
      |   *   (congested branch)
      +--------|--------- q (veh/h)
      0       3375

(c) Speed and density for a flow of 800 veh/h

Substitute in q=vfk−(vf/kj)k2q = v_f k - (v_f/k_j)k^2:

0.6k2−90k+800=0⇒k=90±902−4(0.6)(800)2(0.6)0.6k^2 - 90k + 800 = 0 \quad\Rightarrow\quad k = \frac{90 \pm \sqrt{90^2 - 4(0.6)(800)}}{2(0.6)} k1=9.49 veh/km,k2=140.51 veh/kmk_1 = 9.49\ \text{veh/km},\quad k_2 = 140.51\ \text{veh/km}
  • Uncongested (stable) state: k=9.5k = 9.5 veh/km and v=90(1−9.49/150)=84.3v = 90(1-9.49/150) = 84.3 km/h.
  • Congested (forced) state: k=140.5k = 140.5 veh/km and v=5.7v = 5.7 km/h.

Answer: for 800 veh/h, speed = 84.3 km/h at density = 9.5 veh/km (stable flow); the congested alternative is 5.7 km/h at 140.5 veh/km.

(d) Headway, spacing, clearance and gap at maximum flow

At qmax=3375q_{max} = 3375 veh/h, km=75k_m = 75 veh/km, vm=45v_m = 45 km/h:

Average headway h=3600qmax=36003375=1.07 sAverage spacing s=1000km=100075=13.33 mClearance =s−L=13.33−6.1=7.23 mGap (time) =h−Lvm=1.07−6.112.500=0.58 s\begin{aligned} \text{Average headway}\ h &= \frac{3600}{q_{max}} = \frac{3600}{3375} = 1.07\ \text{s}\\ \text{Average spacing}\ s &= \frac{1000}{k_m} = \frac{1000}{75} = 13.33\ \text{m}\\ \text{Clearance}\ &= s - L = 13.33 - 6.1 = 7.23\ \text{m}\\ \text{Gap (time)}\ &= h - \frac{L}{v_m} = 1.07 - \frac{6.1}{12.500} = 0.58\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Answer: headway = 1.07 s, spacing = 13.33 m, clearance = 7.23 m, gap = 0.58 s.

  • 2078 Bhadra · 8 marks

Two vehicles approaching at right angles, A from West and B from South, collide with each other. After the collision, vehicle A skids in a direction 51° North of West and vehicle B, 61° East of North. The initial skid distances of the vehicles A and B are 39m and 21m respectively before collision. The skid distances after collision are 15m and 36m respectively. If the weights of vehicles B and A are 6 and 4.4 tonnes respectively, calculate the original speeds of the vehicles. Take average skid resistance as 0.55.

Similar questions: Skid numerical: A from North, B from West (2082 Bhadra)

Answer

A collision on a flat road is solved by (i) finding each vehicle's speed just after impact from its post-collision skid, (ii) applying conservation of linear momentum as a vector equation to get the speeds just before impact, and (iii) adding back the energy lost in the pre-collision skid.

Given: WA=4.4W_A = 4.4 t, WB=6W_B = 6 t, f=0.55f = 0.55, g=9.81 m/s2g = 9.81\ \text{m/s}^2. Pre-collision skids: dA=39d_A = 39 m, dB=21d_B = 21 m. Post-collision skids: dA′=15d_A' = 15 m, dB′=36d_B' = 36 m.

Vehicle A comes from the West (moving East); its weight is 4.4 t. Vehicle B comes from the South (moving North); its weight is 6 t. After impact A slides 51 degrees North of West and B slides 61 degrees East of North.

where θ\theta is the bearing from North, clockwise: θA=90∘\theta_A = 90^\circ, θB=0∘\theta_B = 0^\circ (travel directions) and θA′=321∘\theta_A' = 321^\circ, θB′=61∘\theta_B' = 61^\circ (skid directions after impact).

   before impact          after impact
   A: bearing 90 deg       A': bearing 321 deg
   B: bearing 0 deg       B': bearing 61 deg
   (bearing measured clockwise from North)

Step 1: Speeds just after collision

From work-energy, v′=2gfd′v' = \sqrt{2 g f d'}:

vA′=2(9.81)(0.55)(15)=12.72 m/svB′=2(9.81)(0.55)(36)=19.71 m/s\begin{aligned} v_A' &= \sqrt{2(9.81)(0.55)(15)} = 12.72\ \text{m/s}\\ v_B' &= \sqrt{2(9.81)(0.55)(36)} = 19.71\ \text{m/s} \end{aligned}

Step 2: Momentum balance (vector form)

Take xx = East and yy = North, and let uA,uBu_A, u_B be the speeds just before impact. Weights are proportional to masses, so they can be used directly.

WAuAsin⁡θA+WBuBsin⁡θB=WAvA′sin⁡θA′+WBvB′sin⁡θB′WAuAcos⁡θA+WBuBcos⁡θB=WAvA′cos⁡θA′+WBvB′cos⁡θB′\begin{aligned} W_A u_A \sin\theta_A + W_B u_B \sin\theta_B &= W_A v_A' \sin\theta_A' + W_B v_B' \sin\theta_B' \\ W_A u_A \cos\theta_A + W_B u_B \cos\theta_B &= W_A v_A' \cos\theta_A' + W_B v_B' \cos\theta_B' \end{aligned}

Substituting the numbers:

4.4 uA(1.0000)+6 uB(0.0000)=4.4(12.723)(−0.6293)+6(19.710)(0.8746)=68.2024.4 uA(0.0000)+6 uB(1.0000)=4.4(12.723)(0.7771)+6(19.710)(0.4848)=100.837\begin{aligned} 4.4\,u_A(1.0000) + 6\,u_B(0.0000) &= 4.4(12.723)(-0.6293) + 6(19.710)(0.8746) = 68.202 \\ 4.4\,u_A(0.0000) + 6\,u_B(1.0000) &= 4.4(12.723)(0.7771) + 6(19.710)(0.4848) = 100.837 \end{aligned}

Solving: uA=15.50 m/s=55.8 km/hu_A = 15.50\ \text{m/s} = 55.8\ \text{km/h} and uB=16.81 m/s=60.5 km/hu_B = 16.81\ \text{m/s} = 60.5\ \text{km/h} at the instant of impact.

Step 3: Original speeds (before the pre-collision skid)

v0=u2+2gfdv_0 = \sqrt{u^2 + 2 g f d}:

vA=(15.50)2+2(9.81)(0.55)(39)=25.71 m/svB=(16.81)2+2(9.81)(0.55)(21)=22.56 m/s\begin{aligned} v_A &= \sqrt{(15.50)^2 + 2(9.81)(0.55)(39)} = 25.71\ \text{m/s}\\ v_B &= \sqrt{(16.81)^2 + 2(9.81)(0.55)(21)} = 22.56\ \text{m/s} \end{aligned}

Answer: original speed of vehicle AA = 92.6 km/h and of vehicle BB = 81.2 km/h (speeds at impact: 55.8 and 60.5 km/h).

  • 2073 Shrawan · 8 marks

The average normal flow of traffic on cross roads H and F during design period are 400 and 250 PCU per hour, the saturated headway on these roads are estimated as 3 secs and 4 secs respectively. The all red time required for pedestrian crossing is 15 secs. Design two phase traffic signal by Webster's method.

Similar questions: Intersection control methods; Webster signal 400/300 PCU (2066 Bhadra)

Answer

Saturation flow from the saturation headway: road H s=3600/3=1200s = 3600/3 = 1200 PCU/h; road F s=3600/4=900s = 3600/4 = 900 PCU/h.

Step 1: Flow ratios

Flow ratio y=q/sy = q/s for each approach; the larger value in a phase is the critical one.

PhaseApproachqsy = q/s
Phase 1Road H40012000.333
Phase 2Road F2509000.278
Y=0.333+0.278=0.611Y = 0.333 + 0.278 = 0.611

Step 2: Lost time

Lost time is not given; it is taken as 2 s per phase (including the 2 s amber), plus the all-red period for pedestrians RR = 15 s per cycle.

L=(0.0+2.0)+(0.0+2.0)+15=19.0 sL = (0.0+2.0) + (0.0+2.0) + 15 = 19.0\ \text{s}

Step 3: Optimum cycle time (Webster)

C0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(19.0)+51−0.611=86.1 sC_0 = \frac{1.5L + 5}{1 - Y} = \frac{1.5(19.0) + 5}{1 - 0.611} = 86.1\ \text{s}

Adopt C = 90 s.

Step 4: Green times

Total effective green =C−L=90−19.0=71.0= C - L = 90 - 19.0 = 71.0 s, divided in proportion to yy:

g1=yY(C−L)=0.3330.611(71.0)=38.7 sg_{1} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.333}{0.611}(71.0) = 38.7\ \text{s} g2=yY(C−L)=0.2780.611(71.0)=32.3 sg_{2} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.278}{0.611}(71.0) = 32.3\ \text{s}

Displayed green G=g+G = g + start-up loss (so that ∑G+∑I+R=C\sum G + \sum I + R = C):

PhaseEffective g (s)Start-up loss (s)Green G (s)Amber (s)
Phase 138.70.0392
Phase 232.30.0322

Check: 39 + 2 + 32 + 2 + 15 = 90 s.

Phase diagram

|     P1 green 39      | A2|   P2 green 32    | A2|  R 15  |
  • 2071 Chaitra · 8 marks

An isolated signal with pedestrians indication is to be installed on a right angled intersection with road A 15 m wide and road B 12 m wide. The heaviest volume per hour for each lane of road A and road B are 300 and 250 respectively. The amber times for roads A and B are 3 and 2 seconds respectively. Design the timings of traffic and pedestrian signal.

Similar questions: Signal timing: roads H 12 m and F 9.6 m (2070 Chaitra)

Answer

Isolated two-phase signal with pedestrian indications for road A (15 m) and road B (12 m). Approach speeds are not needed because the ambers are given (3 s and 2 s).

Design basis (IRC:93-1985, Guidelines on Design and Installation of Road Traffic Signals, with Webster's method): two-phase signal, Phase 1 = road A moves, Phase 2 = road B moves. Pedestrians cross a road while the traffic on the cross road has green. Assumed (not given): saturation flow 1800 PCU/h per lane, start-up lost time 2 s per phase, pedestrian walking speed 1.2 m/s and initial walk (pedestrian start-up) time 5 s.

Step 1: Amber (change) time

Amber times are given: road A = 3 s, road B = 2 s.

Step 2: Pedestrian crossing time

Time to cross = initial walk + width / walking speed:

tp,A=5+151.2=17.5 stp,B=5+121.2=15.0 s\begin{aligned} t_{p,A} &= 5 + \frac{15}{1.2} = 17.5\ \text{s}\\ t_{p,B} &= 5 + \frac{12}{1.2} = 15.0\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Pedestrians crossing road A walk during Phase 2, so Phase 2 green must be at least 17.5 s. Pedestrians crossing road B walk during Phase 1, so Phase 1 green must be at least 15.0 s.

Step 3: Webster cycle time from traffic

yA=3001800=0.167,yB=2501800=0.139,Y=0.306L=(2+3)+(2+2)=9 sC0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(9)+51−0.306=26.6 s\begin{aligned} y_A &= \frac{300}{1800} = 0.167, \quad y_B = \frac{250}{1800} = 0.139, \quad Y = 0.306\\ L &= (2+3) + (2+2) = 9\ \text{s}\\ C_0 &= \frac{1.5L+5}{1-Y} = \frac{1.5(9)+5}{1-0.306} = 26.6\ \text{s} \end{aligned} gA=0.1670.306(17.6)=9.6 s,GA=gA+2=11.6 sgB=0.1390.306(17.6)=8.0 s,GB=gB+2=10.0 s\begin{aligned} g_A &= \frac{0.167}{0.306}(17.6) = 9.6\ \text{s}, \quad G_A = g_A + 2 = 11.6\ \text{s}\\ g_B &= \frac{0.139}{0.306}(17.6) = 8.0\ \text{s}, \quad G_B = g_B + 2 = 10.0\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 4: Check against pedestrian needs

PhaseGreen from traffic (s)Pedestrian minimum (s)Adopted green (s)
1 (road A)11.615.015
2 (road B)10.017.518

Adopted cycle length C=15+3+18+2=38C = 15 + 3 + 18 + 2 = 38 s.

Final timings

SignalPhase 1: road APhase 2: road B
Vehicle green15 s18 s
Vehicle amber3 s2 s
Vehicle red20 s18 s

Pedestrian signals: pedestrians crossing road B get WALK for 5 s then flashing (clearance) for 10 s during Phase 1 (total 15 s of 15 s green); pedestrians crossing road A get WALK for 5 s then flashing for 12 s during Phase 2 (total 18 s of 18 s green). All pedestrian indications show DON'T WALK (red man) while their cross traffic moves.

Phase diagram

Cycle = 38 s
Road A: [GREEN 15][A 3][  RED 20  ]
Road B: [ RED 18 ][GREEN 18][A 2]
Ped crossing B: [WALK+FLASH 15][DON'T WALK 23]
Ped crossing A: [DON'T WALK 18][WALK+FLASH 18][DW]
  • 2066 Bhadra · 2+6 marks

What are different methods of traffic control at an intersection? The average normal flow of traffic on cross roads A and B during design period are 400 and 300 PCU per hour; the saturation flow values on these roads are estimated as 1450 and 1150 PCU per hour respectively. The all-red time required for pedestrian crossing is 12 sec. Design two phase traffic signal by Webster's method.

Similar questions: Webster signal: roads H and F, 3 s and 4 s headways (2073 Shrawan)

Answer

Methods of traffic control at an intersection

  1. Uncontrolled (priority by rules): drivers give way to the vehicle on the right or on the main road; suitable for very low volume.
  2. Traffic signs and markings: STOP and GIVE WAY signs, with stop lines; minor road gives way to major road (IRC:67, IRC:35).
  3. Channelisation: islands and markings guide the movements (IRC:SP:41).
  4. Rotary (roundabout): one-way circulation, no signals (IRC:65).
  5. Traffic signals: fixed-time, vehicle-actuated or area-coordinated (IRC:93).
  6. Police control by hand signals at peak times or special events.
  7. Grade separation: flyover, underpass or interchange for very high volume.

Design of a two-phase signal by Webster's method

Data: roads A and B carry 400 and 300 PCU/h; saturation flows 1450 and 1150 PCU/h; all-red time for pedestrians RR = 12 s per cycle.

Step 1: Flow ratios

Flow ratio y=q/sy = q/s for each approach; the larger value in a phase is the critical one.

PhaseApproachqsy = q/s
Phase 1Road A40014500.276
Phase 2Road B30011500.261
Y=0.276+0.261=0.537Y = 0.276 + 0.261 = 0.537

Step 2: Lost time

Lost time per phase is taken as 2 s (including the amber of 2 s), plus the all-red time RR = 12 s.

L=(0.0+2.0)+(0.0+2.0)+12=16.0 sL = (0.0+2.0) + (0.0+2.0) + 12 = 16.0\ \text{s}

Step 3: Optimum cycle time (Webster)

C0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(16.0)+51−0.537=62.6 sC_0 = \frac{1.5L + 5}{1 - Y} = \frac{1.5(16.0) + 5}{1 - 0.537} = 62.6\ \text{s}

Adopt C = 65 s.

Step 4: Green times

Total effective green =C−L=65−16.0=49.0= C - L = 65 - 16.0 = 49.0 s, divided in proportion to yy:

g1=yY(C−L)=0.2760.537(49.0)=25.2 sg_{1} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.276}{0.537}(49.0) = 25.2\ \text{s} g2=yY(C−L)=0.2610.537(49.0)=23.8 sg_{2} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.261}{0.537}(49.0) = 23.8\ \text{s}

Displayed green G=g+G = g + start-up loss (so that ∑G+∑I+R=C\sum G + \sum I + R = C):

PhaseEffective g (s)Start-up loss (s)Green G (s)Amber (s)
Phase 125.20.0252
Phase 223.80.0242

Check: 25 + 2 + 24 + 2 + 12 = 65 s.

Phase diagram

|    P1 green 25    | A2|   P2 green 24    | A2|   R 12  |
  • 2082 Bhadra · 4+4 marks

Describe the critical road user characteristics to be considered in traffic engineering design. Discuss, how static characteristic of vehicle affect road design?

Answer

Critical road user characteristics

  1. Physical: vision (acuity, field of vision, colour vision, glare), hearing, strength and agility. They fix sign sizes, letter heights, lighting, sight distances and footpath gradients.
  2. Mental and psychological: attention, judgement, emotional stability and attitude. They influence overtaking decisions, gap acceptance and compliance with signals.
  3. Reaction time (PIEV): about 2.5 s is used for stopping sight distance, headlight sight distance and intersection sight distance (IRC:SP:23, IRC:66, Nepal Road Standard 2070).
  4. Pedestrian characteristics: walking speed about 1.2 m/s (IRC:103 and IRC:93 use 1.2 m/s; slower, about 0.9 m/s, for children and the elderly); space needed about 0.5-0.75 m² per person; they need footpaths, crossings, refuge islands and signal time.
  5. Cyclists: speed 10-25 km/h, need separate lanes and safe turning at intersections.
  6. Age and gender, fatigue, intoxication and disability: these add to variation, so design uses the 85th-percentile or a conservative value (for example the 15th-percentile pedestrian speed for crossing time).
  7. Behaviour and compliance: lane discipline, helmet and seat-belt use, jaywalking and parking habits vary by country and must be reflected in the design and enforcement plan (in Nepal mixed traffic is common).
  8. Mixed traffic: in Nepal slow and fast vehicles share the carriageway, so wider shoulders and segregation are required.

How static characteristics of a vehicle affect road design

CharacteristicTypical valueEffect on road design
Width2.5 m (trucks, buses)Lane width (3.5 m rural, 3.0-3.25 m urban), parking bay width
Heightup to 4.75 m (IRC)Vertical clearance under bridges and tunnels (5.5 m minimum, IRC:5)
Length11-12 m rigid, up to 18 m semi-trailerParking bays, curve widening, kerb radius, passing and storage lanes
Wheel base and overhang6-7 m (truck)Extra widening on curves, minimum turning radius, tail swing
Ground clearance0.2-0.3 mHump, drain and vertical-curve design
Turning radius12-14 m (truck)Minimum intersection radius, island and median-opening design
Weight and axle load10.2 t legal single axle; 8.16 t standard axle in IRC:37Pavement thickness, bridge loading (IRC:6), width of bridge
Eye and object heightdriver eye 1.2 m, object 0.15 m (IRC:SP:23)Sight distance at crests

Examples: the 2.5 m width and 11 m length of a bus fix the minimum bay size; the 4.75 m height fixes bridge clearance; the large turning radius of trucks fixes the radius of intersection corners; the axle load fixes pavement thickness.

  • 2082 Bhadra · 3+3+2 marks

What are the basic requirements of intersection at grade? Mention the factors affecting night visibility at road. How much is the recommended lateral offset of the lighting poles at the road? Explain with reasoning.

Answer

Basic requirements of an intersection at grade

  1. Safety: few and simple conflict points, good sight triangles (IRC:66, IRC:SP:41), and low approach speeds.
  2. Capacity: enough lanes and green time or rotary width for the design hour volume.
  3. Clear, simple layout: roads meet at about 90 degrees (not less than 60 degrees); avoid more than four arms; flat approach gradient.
  4. Channelisation and control: islands, markings, signs, signals or a rotary where needed; provision for pedestrians and cyclists.
  5. Drainage, lighting and economy.

Factors affecting night visibility

  • Headlight intensity, beam type (dipped or high) and alignment.
  • Glare from opposing headlights, and the driver's glare recovery time.
  • Street lighting level and uniformity.
  • Contrast between object and background; colour and reflectance of the pavement (a wet or dark surface reflects little).
  • Speed of the vehicle (less time to see and react) and driver age and eyesight.
  • Weather (rain, fog, dust), cleanliness of windscreen, and retro-reflective signs and markings.

Lateral offset of lighting poles

Poles are placed at least 0.6 m (minimum 0.3 m on very restricted kerbed streets) behind the kerb face on urban roads, and about 1.5 m or more from the carriageway edge (outside the shoulder) on high-speed roads without kerbs, as in IS 1944 / IRC practice.

Reasoning: (1) a pole set too close is hit by vehicles whose wheels or mirrors overhang; (2) a larger offset gives the driver recovery space and reduces the severity of impact (frangible or breakaway poles are used where offset is small); (3) it keeps the footpath and sight lines clear; (4) too large an offset reduces the light falling on the carriageway and increases the bracket length, so the offset is a balance between safety and lighting efficiency.

  • 2082 Bhadra · 8 marks

Design an isolated traffic signal at an intersection of road X (15 m width), and road Y (10.5 m width). The highest observed traffic volume per lane is 250 vehicles per hour on road X and 200 vehicles per hour on road Y. The approach speeds are 50 km/h for road X and 35 km/h for road Y. Design the traffic and pedestrian signal timings for this intersection. Also, prepare a phase diagram showing both vehicular and pedestrian signal timing.

Answer

Design the vehicular and pedestrian timings of an isolated two-phase signal for roads X (15 m) and Y (10.5 m).

Design basis (IRC:93-1985, Guidelines on Design and Installation of Road Traffic Signals, with Webster's method): two-phase signal, Phase 1 = road X moves, Phase 2 = road Y moves. Pedestrians cross a road while the traffic on the cross road has green. Assumed (not given): saturation flow 1800 PCU/h per lane, start-up lost time 2 s per phase, pedestrian walking speed 1.2 m/s and initial walk (pedestrian start-up) time 5 s.

Step 1: Amber (change) time

Amber I=tr+v2aI = t_r + \dfrac{v}{2a} with reaction time tr=1t_r = 1 s and comfortable deceleration a=3 m/s2a = 3\ \text{m/s}^2, kept within the IRC:93 range of 2-4 s:

IX=1+50/3.62(3)=3.31→4 sIY=1+35/3.62(3)=2.62→3 s\begin{aligned} I_X &= 1 + \frac{50/3.6}{2(3)} = 3.31 \to 4\ \text{s}\\ I_Y &= 1 + \frac{35/3.6}{2(3)} = 2.62 \to 3\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 2: Pedestrian crossing time

Time to cross = initial walk + width / walking speed:

tp,X=5+151.2=17.5 stp,Y=5+10.51.2=13.8 s\begin{aligned} t_{p,X} &= 5 + \frac{15}{1.2} = 17.5\ \text{s}\\ t_{p,Y} &= 5 + \frac{10.5}{1.2} = 13.8\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Pedestrians crossing road X walk during Phase 2, so Phase 2 green must be at least 17.5 s. Pedestrians crossing road Y walk during Phase 1, so Phase 1 green must be at least 13.8 s.

Step 3: Webster cycle time from traffic

yX=2501800=0.139,yY=2001800=0.111,Y=0.250L=(2+4)+(2+3)=11 sC0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(11)+51−0.250=28.7 s\begin{aligned} y_X &= \frac{250}{1800} = 0.139, \quad y_Y = \frac{200}{1800} = 0.111, \quad Y = 0.250\\ L &= (2+4) + (2+3) = 11\ \text{s}\\ C_0 &= \frac{1.5L+5}{1-Y} = \frac{1.5(11)+5}{1-0.250} = 28.7\ \text{s} \end{aligned} gX=0.1390.250(17.7)=9.8 s,GX=gX+2=11.8 sgY=0.1110.250(17.7)=7.9 s,GY=gY+2=9.9 s\begin{aligned} g_X &= \frac{0.139}{0.250}(17.7) = 9.8\ \text{s}, \quad G_X = g_X + 2 = 11.8\ \text{s}\\ g_Y &= \frac{0.111}{0.250}(17.7) = 7.9\ \text{s}, \quad G_Y = g_Y + 2 = 9.9\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 4: Check against pedestrian needs

PhaseGreen from traffic (s)Pedestrian minimum (s)Adopted green (s)
1 (road X)11.813.814
2 (road Y)9.917.518

Adopted cycle length C=14+4+18+3=39C = 14 + 4 + 18 + 3 = 39 s.

Final timings

SignalPhase 1: road XPhase 2: road Y
Vehicle green14 s18 s
Vehicle amber4 s3 s
Vehicle red21 s18 s

Pedestrian signals: pedestrians crossing road Y get WALK for 5 s then flashing (clearance) for 9 s during Phase 1 (total 14 s of 14 s green); pedestrians crossing road X get WALK for 5 s then flashing for 12 s during Phase 2 (total 18 s of 18 s green). All pedestrian indications show DON'T WALK (red man) while their cross traffic moves.

Phase diagram

Cycle = 39 s
Road X: [GREEN 14][A 4][  RED 21  ]
Road Y: [ RED 18 ][GREEN 18][A 3]
Ped crossing Y: [WALK+FLASH 14][DON'T WALK 25]
Ped crossing X: [DON'T WALK 18][WALK+FLASH 18][DW]
  • 2082 Baisakh · 8 marks

Explain the method to determine the spacing of street light. Explain about different types of parking.

Answer

Spacing of street lights

The spacing is found from the luminous flux that must reach the road surface (lumen method):

S=F×Uf×ME×WS = \frac{F \times U_f \times M}{E \times W}

where SS = spacing between lamps (m), FF = luminous flux of the lamp (lumen), UfU_f = utilisation factor (fraction of lamp flux that reaches the road; from the luminaire curves for the given mounting height, width and arrangement), MM = maintenance factor (0.7-0.8, allows for dust and lamp ageing), EE = required average illuminance (lux) and WW = width of the road to be lit (m).

Steps:

  1. Fix the required illuminance EE for the road class from IS 1944/CIE/Nepal standards.
  2. Select the mounting height HH, the arrangement (single side, staggered, opposite or central) and the luminaire type.
  3. Choose the lamp (wattage and lumen output FF).
  4. Read the utilisation factor UfU_f from the manufacturer's curve for W/HW/H and the overhang.
  5. Take the maintenance factor MM.
  6. Compute SS from the formula; for staggered or opposite arrangement use the full width WW and divide FF appropriately (for opposite arrangement use half width per row).
  7. Check that S/HS/H lies within 3 to 5 (cut-off luminaires: 3, semi-cut-off: 4-5), and that the uniformity ratio (min/avg) is at least 0.3. Adjust the lamp or height if necessary.

Example: F=15000F = 15000 lm, Uf=0.4U_f = 0.4, M=0.75M = 0.75, E=20E = 20 lux, W=10W = 10 m: S=15000×0.4×0.7520×10=22.5S = \dfrac{15000 \times 0.4 \times 0.75}{20 \times 10} = 22.5 m. For a mounting height of 7.5 m, S/H=3S/H = 3, which is acceptable.

Types of parking

Parking is classified as on-street (on the carriageway edge) and off-street (away from the carriageway).

A. On-street parking (vehicles park along the kerb):

TypeArrangementRemarks
ParallelVehicles parked along the kerb, bay about 5.0-5.5 m x 2.0-2.5 mLeast road width needed, safest, but fewest cars per length
30 degree angleFront end towards the kerbModerate capacity, easy entry
45 degree angleFront in or back inGood capacity, easy to park
60 degree angleFront inHigh capacity, needs wider bay
90 degree (right angle)Perpendicular to the kerbMost vehicles per length, most road width, high risk to through traffic
 Parallel            45 degree           90 degree
 ______________     \ \ \ \ \          | | | | | |
 [car] [car] [car]   \_\_\_\_\_         |_|_|_|_|_|
 ========= kerb      ===== kerb          ===== kerb

B. Off-street parking:

  • Surface parking lots: open areas near markets or terminals; low cost, require land.
  • Multi-storey (multi-level) parking: several floors; best use of costly land, high construction cost; ramp or mechanical access.
  • Underground parking: below buildings or public squares; keeps surface free, expensive.
  • Mechanical or automated parking: lifts and stackers, used where land is very scarce.
  • Park-and-ride facilities: at city edges, linked to public transport.

Nepal practice: on-street parking is regulated by the Metropolitan/Municipal offices and Traffic Police (parallel parking on one side, paid parking zones), and off-street parking is required in new buildings by the Nepal National Building Code (NBC 206 / municipal building bye-laws).

  • 2082 Baisakh · 8 marks

An impatient car driver stuck behind a truck travelling at 35 kmph decides to overtake the truck. The acceleration characteristics of car is given by, dV/dt = 2.01 − 0.05V where V is speed in m/s and time is in sec.
i) What is acceleration after 20 and 40 sec? ii) What is maximum speed attainable by car? iii) How far will car travel in 260 sec?

Answer

The acceleration falls linearly with speed, so dVdt=2.01−0.05V\dfrac{dV}{dt} = 2.01 - 0.05V is solved by separating variables. Assumption: the car starts at the truck's speed, V0=35V_0 = 35 km/h =9.722= 9.722 m/s at t=0t = 0.

Speed as a function of time

∫dV2.01−0.05V=∫dt  ⇒  −20ln⁡(2.01−0.05V)=t+C\int \frac{dV}{2.01-0.05V} = \int dt \;\Rightarrow\; -20\ln(2.01-0.05V) = t + C

At t=0t=0, V=V0V=V_0. This gives

V(t)=40.2−(40.2−9.722) e−0.05t=40.2−30.478 e−0.05t m/sV(t) = 40.2 - (40.2 - 9.722)\,e^{-0.05t} = 40.2 - 30.478\,e^{-0.05t}\ \text{m/s}

and the acceleration is a=2.01−0.05V=0.05(40.2−V0)e−0.05t=1.5239 e−0.05ta = 2.01 - 0.05V = 0.05(40.2 - V_0)e^{-0.05t} = 1.5239\,e^{-0.05t}.

(i) Acceleration after 20 s and 40 s

V(20)=40.2−30.478e−1=28.988 m/s,a(20)=2.01−0.05(28.988)=0.561 m/s2V(40)=40.2−30.478e−2=36.075 m/s,a(40)=2.01−0.05(36.075)=0.206 m/s2\begin{aligned} V(20) &= 40.2 - 30.478e^{-1} = 28.988\ \text{m/s}, & a(20) &= 2.01 - 0.05(28.988) = 0.561\ \text{m/s}^2\\ V(40) &= 40.2 - 30.478e^{-2} = 36.075\ \text{m/s}, & a(40) &= 2.01 - 0.05(36.075) = 0.206\ \text{m/s}^2 \end{aligned}

(ii) Maximum speed attainable

Speed is maximum when dV/dt=0dV/dt = 0:

Vmax=2.010.05=40.2 m/s=144.7 km/hV_{max} = \frac{2.01}{0.05} = 40.2\ \text{m/s} = 144.7\ \text{km/h}

(This is approached asymptotically; a real car would be limited by the speed limit and road.)

(iii) Distance travelled in 260 s

x=∫0260V dt=40.2t−30.4780.05(1−e−0.05t)=40.2(260)−609.56(1−e−13)=9842.4 m\begin{aligned} x &= \int_0^{260} V\,dt = 40.2t - \frac{30.478}{0.05}\left(1 - e^{-0.05t}\right)\\ &= 40.2(260) - 609.56\left(1 - e^{-13}\right) = 9842.4\ \text{m} \end{aligned}

Answer: (i) a20=0.561a_{20} = 0.561 m/s2^2, a40=0.206a_{40} = 0.206 m/s2^2; (ii) Vmax=40.2V_{max} = 40.2 m/s (144.7 km/h); (iii) distance ≈\approx 9842 m (9.84 km).

  • 2082 Baisakh · 8 marks

A car driver was driving along 800 m road. She counted the number of cars that she meets while driving southwards (Ns), the number of cars that overtake her while driving northward (No), and the numbers of cars that she overtakes while driving northward (Np) is shown in table below. Find the average traffic flow and journey speed. Given that she travels at a constant speed of 20 kmph.
Vehicle met while driving southwardVehicle overtaking while driving northVehicle overtaken while driving north
1071074
1132541
30155
79189

Answer

The moving observer method gives the flow qq and mean stream speed from counts made by a test car running with and against the stream.

Reading of the table: the vehicles she meets while driving southward are the northbound stream she is measuring (NsN_s); while driving northward, NoN_o = cars that overtake her and NpN_p = cars she overtakes. Section length 800 m, test speed 20 km/h on both runs.

Average counts (4 runs)

Nˉs=107+113+30+794=82.25Nˉo=10+25+15+184=17.00,Nˉp=74+41+5+94=32.25y=Nˉo−Nˉp=−15.25\begin{aligned} \bar N_s &= \frac{107+113+30+79}{4} = 82.25\\ \bar N_o &= \frac{10+25+15+18}{4} = 17.00, \quad \bar N_p = \frac{74+41+5+9}{4} = 32.25\\ y &= \bar N_o - \bar N_p = -15.25 \end{aligned}

Travel times

tw=ta=0.820=0.04 h=2.4 mint_w = t_a = \frac{0.8}{20} = 0.04\ \text{h} = 2.4\ \text{min}

Traffic flow

q=Ns+ytw+ta=82.25+(−15.25)0.04+0.04=837.5 veh/hq = \frac{N_s + y}{t_w + t_a} = \frac{82.25 + (-15.25)}{0.04 + 0.04} = 837.5\ \text{veh/h}

Journey time and speed of the stream

tˉ=tw−yq=0.04−(−15.25)837.5=0.0582 h=3.49 min\bar t = t_w - \frac{y}{q} = 0.04 - \frac{(-15.25)}{837.5} = 0.0582\ \text{h} = 3.49\ \text{min} Vj=Ltˉ=0.80.0582=13.74 km/hV_j = \frac{L}{\bar t} = \frac{0.8}{0.0582} = 13.74\ \text{km/h}

Answer: average flow = 837.5 veh/h; journey speed = 13.7 km/h (journey time 3.49 min). The stream is slower than the test car because more vehicles were overtaken by her than overtook her.

  • 2081 Bhadra · 8 marks

Discuss critical characteristics of driver related to vision that affect traffic performance.

Answer

Vision supplies about 90 percent of the information a driver uses, so its characteristics control how a road must be designed.

  • Visual acuity: the ability to see detail. Static acuity is needed to read signs; dynamic acuity (seeing moving objects) is poorer and falls as speed rises. A sign letter height is chosen so that a driver of normal acuity can read it in the time available.
  • Cone of vision: clear vision is within about 3 degrees; fairly clear vision within about 10 degrees; useful peripheral vision up to about 120 degrees (about 160-180 degrees for movement). Signs must be placed within the clear cone.
  • Peripheral vision: detects vehicles and pedestrians at the sides; it narrows with speed (about 100 degrees at 30 km/h to about 40 degrees at 100 km/h) and with age and alcohol.
  • Colour vision: red, green and amber must be recognised. About 8 percent of males are colour blind; signals therefore also use fixed positions (red on top) and shapes.
  • Glare vision and recovery: headlight glare at night reduces vision for several seconds. Recovery time is about 3-6 s from dark to bright, longer in old age. Hence anti-glare screens, median planting and low-mounted headlights are used.
  • Depth perception: judging distance and relative speed is vital in overtaking and gap acceptance; it is poor at night and in fog.
  • Night vision and adaptation: the eye takes time to adapt to darkness; street lighting at tunnel exits and underpasses must provide a gradual transition.

The design consequences are: sign size and placement, retro-reflective markings, lighting levels, sight-distance lengths, and signal lens colours and positions.

  • 2081 Bhadra · 8 marks

Define spot speed and explain the methods of conducting spot speed study. Write down the advantages and limitations of rotary intersection.

Answer

Spot speed

Spot speed is the instantaneous speed of a vehicle at a specified point (spot) of the road. It is used for speed limits, design speed, sight distance, signal timing, crash analysis and checking road geometry (85th-percentile speed is the usual regulatory speed).

Methods of spot speed study

  1. Stopwatch (enoscope-based) method: a short base length (about 30 m for speeds below 40 km/h, 50-100 m for higher speeds) is marked; the time a vehicle takes to cross it is measured with a stopwatch, and v=d/tv = d/t. Simple and cheap but less accurate; the enoscope (mirror box) reduces parallax error.
  2. Pavement contact devices: pneumatic road tubes or piezo/induction loops across the lane record the passing of axles and give speed from the time between two sensors; automatic and accurate, good for long counts.
  3. Radar (Doppler) speed meter / lidar gun: a hand-held or tripod unit measures speed directly using the Doppler effect; quick and accurate, but drivers may notice and slow.
  4. Video and image processing: vehicles are recorded and speeds computed from frames and a known base length; gives permanent records and classification.
  5. Automatic number-plate / GPS / floating car methods are used for long sections and for travel time.

Sample size is at least 30-50 vehicles, chosen at random; observations are made in off-peak free-flow periods under good weather (IRC:SP:19).

Advantages and limitations of a rotary

Advantages

  • No signals needed; traffic flows continuously, so delay is low at moderate volumes.
  • Crossing conflicts are replaced by weaving, merging and diverging, so crashes are fewer and less severe.
  • Low speeds and low cost of operation and maintenance; no power needed.
  • Suitable for junctions of four or more arms with balanced flows.

Limitations

  • Needs a large area of land, so it is unsuitable in built-up areas.
  • Not suitable for very high traffic (above about 3,000 PCU/h) or a very high share of weaving traffic.
  • Pedestrians cross with difficulty and the detour adds distance to through and turning vehicles.
  • Not suitable where one road is far more important than the other, or where slow vehicles are many.
  • Congestion on one arm can lock up the whole rotary.
  • 2081 Bhadra · 8 marks

At a right-angled intersection of two roads, Road 1 has four lanes with a total width of 14m and Road 2 has two lanes with a total width of 7m. The volume of traffic approaching the intersection during the design hour are 850 and 750 PCU/hr on the two approaches of Road 1 and 200 and 250 PCU/hr on the two approaches of Road 2. Take saturation flow of each direction of road 1 and 2 as 3675 PCU/hr and 1890 PCU/hr respectively. Amber time 3 sec, lost time 2 sec per phase for both the roads.

Answer

Road 1 and Road 2 each run in one phase, so this is a two-phase signal. The design hour flows of the two approaches of each road are given and the saturation flow is the same for both directions of a road (3675 and 1890 PCU/h).

Step 1: Flow ratios

Flow ratio y=q/sy = q/s for each approach; the larger value in a phase is the critical one.

PhaseApproachqsy = q/s
Phase 1Road 1 (850)85036750.231 (critical)
Phase 1Road 1 (750)75036750.204
Phase 2Road 2 (200)20018900.106
Phase 2Road 2 (250)25018900.132 (critical)
Y=0.231+0.132=0.364Y = 0.231 + 0.132 = 0.364

Step 2: Lost time

Lost time per phase = start-up lost time 2 s + amber 3 s = 5 s; no all-red time is given.

L=(2.0+3.0)+(2.0+3.0)=10.0 sL = (2.0+3.0) + (2.0+3.0) = 10.0\ \text{s}

Step 3: Optimum cycle time (Webster)

C0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(10.0)+51−0.364=31.4 sC_0 = \frac{1.5L + 5}{1 - Y} = \frac{1.5(10.0) + 5}{1 - 0.364} = 31.4\ \text{s}

Adopt C = 35 s.

Step 4: Green times

Total effective green =C−L=35−10.0=25.0= C - L = 35 - 10.0 = 25.0 s, divided in proportion to yy:

g1=yY(C−L)=0.2310.364(25.0)=15.9 sg_{1} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.231}{0.364}(25.0) = 15.9\ \text{s} g2=yY(C−L)=0.1320.364(25.0)=9.1 sg_{2} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.132}{0.364}(25.0) = 9.1\ \text{s}

Displayed green G=g+G = g + start-up loss (so that ∑G+∑I+R=C\sum G + \sum I + R = C):

PhaseEffective g (s)Start-up loss (s)Green G (s)Amber (s)
Phase 115.92.0183
Phase 29.12.0113

Check: 18 + 3 + 11 + 3 = 35 s.

Phase diagram

|      P1 green 18       |   A3  | P2 green 11  |   A3  |
  • 2081 Baisakh · 4+4 marks

Define parking accumulation, parking turnover, parking load and parking index. Explain speed-density relation and speed-flow relation with required graphs.

Answer

Parking terms

  • Parking accumulation: the number of vehicles parked in a study area at a given instant. Plotting it against time gives the accumulation curve; its peak gives the demand.
  • Parking volume: total number of vehicles parked in an area during a given period (usually a day); it counts each vehicle once.
  • Parking load: the area under the accumulation curve, in vehicle-hours (or vehicle-minutes) in a given period; it shows the total parking demand in time.
  • Parking duration: the length of time a vehicle stays parked.
  • Parking turnover: the rate of use of a parking space, the number of vehicles parked per bay in a given time.
Turnover=Number of vehicles parked in the periodNumber of parking bays available\text{Turnover} = \frac{\text{Number of vehicles parked in the period}}{\text{Number of parking bays available}}
  • Parking index (occupancy): the ratio of the number of bays occupied to the number of bays available, as a percentage. It measures how well the supply is used.
Parking index=Parking load (vehicle-hours)Parking capacity (bay-hours)×100\text{Parking index} = \frac{\text{Parking load (vehicle-hours)}}{\text{Parking capacity (bay-hours)}} \times 100

where parking capacity = number of bays x hours of study. An index near 100 percent means the supply is exhausted; a very low value means over-supply.

Speed-density relation

Speed falls as density rises. The simplest (Greenshields) model is linear:

v=vf(1−kkj)v = v_f\left(1 - \frac{k}{k_j}\right)

where vfv_f is the free-flow speed (at k→0k \to 0) and kjk_j is the jam density (where v=0v = 0).

 v ^
vf |*
   |   *
   |      *
   |         *
   |            *
   +---------------*--> k
   0               kj

Speed-flow relation

Since q=vkq = vk, eliminating kk gives q=kj(v−v2/vf)q = k_j\left(v - v^2/v_f\right), a parabola with maximum flow qmax=vfkj/4q_{max} = v_f k_j/4 at v=vf/2v = v_f/2.

 v ^
vf |*
   |  *
   |    *   uncongested
vm |- - - -*----- (v = vf/2)
   |       *  congested
   |     *
   +-----|----> q
   0   qmax

The upper branch is stable (uncongested) flow, and the lower branch is forced (congested) flow. Flow rises with density up to km=kj/2k_m = k_j/2 (capacity) and then falls to zero at jam density.

  • 2081 Baisakh · 8 marks

A passenger car of mass 430 kg moving east collides with a truck of mass 1299 kg that is moving south. Initial skid distances of the car and the truck are 15 m and 10 m respectively. After collision they lock together and skid through a distance equal to 8 m in direction 65 degrees south of east before stopping. Compute the initial speeds of the car and the truck. Assume average coefficient of friction as 0.5.

Answer

After the collision the two vehicles move together, so the common post-impact speed comes from the skid distance, the impact speeds from momentum conservation in two directions, and the original speeds from the pre-collision skids.

Given: car m1=430m_1 = 430 kg moving East, truck m2=1299m_2 = 1299 kg moving South, f=0.5f = 0.5, pre-collision skids 15 m (car) and 10 m (truck), post-collision skid d′=8d' = 8 m at 65∘65^\circ South of East.

        N
        ^
        |      car (East) ->
  W ----+----> E
        |\ 65 deg
        | \  locked pair
        v  v (S of E)
        S   truck comes moving South

Step 1: Speed of the locked vehicles after impact

v′=2gfd′=2(9.81)(0.5)(8)=8.859 m/sv' = \sqrt{2gfd'} = \sqrt{2(9.81)(0.5)(8)} = 8.859\ \text{m/s}

Step 2: Momentum conservation

Total mass M=430+1299=1729M = 430 + 1299 = 1729 kg. East component (only the car had eastward momentum) and South component (only the truck had southward momentum):

m1u1=Mv′cos⁡65∘⇒u1=1729(8.859)(0.4226)430=15.054 m/sm2u2=Mv′sin⁡65∘⇒u2=1729(8.859)(0.9063)1299=10.687 m/s\begin{aligned} m_1 u_1 &= M v'\cos 65^\circ \Rightarrow u_1 = \frac{1729(8.859)(0.4226)}{430} = 15.054\ \text{m/s}\\ m_2 u_2 &= M v'\sin 65^\circ \Rightarrow u_2 = \frac{1729(8.859)(0.9063)}{1299} = 10.687\ \text{m/s} \end{aligned}

Step 3: Original speeds

v1=u12+2gf(15)=(15.054)2+2(9.81)(0.5)(15)=19.33 m/sv2=u22+2gf(10)=(10.687)2+2(9.81)(0.5)(10)=14.57 m/s\begin{aligned} v_1 &= \sqrt{u_1^2 + 2gf(15)} = \sqrt{(15.054)^2 + 2(9.81)(0.5)(15)} = 19.33\ \text{m/s}\\ v_2 &= \sqrt{u_2^2 + 2gf(10)} = \sqrt{(10.687)^2 + 2(9.81)(0.5)(10)} = 14.57\ \text{m/s} \end{aligned}

Answer: initial speed of the car = 69.6 km/h and of the truck = 52.5 km/h (impact speeds 54.2 and 38.5 km/h).

  • 2081 Baisakh · 8 marks

What are the advantages of one way traffic movement? Draw a right angle four arm intersection of two roads and show various conflict points, if both roads with two way movements? Classify the type of conflicts.

Answer

Advantages of one-way traffic

  • Fewer conflict points (a four-arm junction of two one-way streets has far fewer than the 32 of two-way streets), so fewer and less severe crashes.
  • Higher capacity (typically 20-50 percent more) as no opposing flow, no right-turn crossing and less need for signal phases.
  • Easier signal coordination and progressive flow; fewer signal phases.
  • Parking and loading can be allowed on both sides without blocking opposing flow.
  • Higher speed and less delay; less glare at night; fewer head-on and sideswipe crashes.
  • Pedestrians only look in one direction when crossing.
  • No central median needed; easier lane use.

Limitations: longer travel distance for some trips, confusion for strangers, and need for a parallel return street.

Conflict points at a four-arm intersection (both roads two-way)

              N
          |  D | M  |
          |    |    |
  ------- X--X-X--X --------
   M D    X  X X  X     D M
  ------- X--X-X--X --------
   D M    X  X X  X     M D
  ------- X--X-X--X --------
          |    |    |
          |  M | D  |
              S
 X = crossing, M = merging, D = diverging
 (4 diverging + 4 merging near arm ends; 
  crossing points in the central area)

Each of the four approaches has through, left-turn and right-turn movements (12 movements in all).

TypeNumber
Crossing conflicts16
Merging conflicts8
Diverging conflicts8
Total32

Classification of conflicts

  1. Diverging: one stream splits into two (a vehicle leaves the approach stream to turn). Least severe; 2 per approach = 8.
  2. Merging: two streams join into one at an exit. Moderately severe; 2 per exit = 8.
  3. Crossing: two streams cut across each other's path (right turners across opposing through traffic, and cross-road through/turning movements). Most severe and most numerous = 16.

Hence crossing conflicts (half of all) are the main target for control by signals, islands, rotary or grade separation.

  • 2080 Bhadra · 8 marks

Explain human-vehicle-environment system. Discuss physical characteristics of driver that affect traffic performance.

Answer

Human-vehicle-environment (HVE) system

The traffic stream is the combined behaviour of three interacting elements: the Human (road user), the Vehicle and the Environment (road and surroundings). Safe and efficient flow needs all three to match.

        +--------------+
        |    HUMAN     |  driver, pedestrian,
        | (perception, |  cyclist, passenger
        |   reaction)  |
        +------+-------+
       controls|    ^ feedback
               v    |
        +------+----+--+      +--------------------+
        |   VEHICLE    |<---->|    ENVIRONMENT     |
        | size, power, |      | road geometry,     |
        | brakes, load |      | surface, signs,    |
        +--------------+      | weather, lighting  |
                              +--------------------+
  • Human: receives information (mostly visual), decides and acts (steering, braking). Errors in perception, judgement or reaction are the main cause of crashes (about 80-90 percent involve human error).
  • Vehicle: its dimensions, weight, power, braking and visibility set the road width, gradient, curve radius and pavement strength required.
  • Environment: road geometry, surface friction, traffic control devices, lighting, weather and adjacent land use affect how the driver sees and responds.

A mismatch in any one (for example a fast vehicle, a sharp curve and a wet surface) causes crashes, so design must fit the "design driver" and "design vehicle" to the road.

Physical characteristics of the driver that affect traffic performance

  • Vision: acuity (about 6/6 needed for a licence), the cone of clear vision (3-5 degrees), the field of vision (clear about 10 degrees, fairly clear about 12-14 degrees, peripheral up to about 120-180 degrees), colour perception (colour blindness for red/green is critical for signals), glare sensitivity, glare recovery and depth perception. Speed narrows the field of vision (at 100 km/h only about 40 degrees).
  • Hearing: horn and siren detection; deafness is partly compensated by vision, but affects awareness of emergency vehicles.
  • Reaction ability: muscle coordination, strength and speed of hand/foot response; fatigue, age and disability reduce it.
  • Age and health: reaction slows and vision/hearing fade in old age; illness, epilepsy and heart conditions are hazards.
  • Fatigue, alcohol and drugs: lengthen reaction time, impair judgement and cause drowsiness; Nepal's Motor Vehicles and Transport Management Act 2049 prohibits driving under the influence.
  • 2080 Bhadra · 2 marks

Define the capacity of a road and list out its types.

Answer

The capacity of a road is the maximum number of vehicles (or PCUs) that can pass a given point or section of a lane or road in one direction (or both directions on a two-lane road) during a given time period (normally one hour) under the prevailing roadway, traffic and control conditions (HCM definition; IRC:106 for urban roads).

Types of capacity:

  1. Basic capacity: the maximum number of passenger cars that can pass in a lane under ideal (best possible) roadway and traffic conditions.
  2. Possible capacity: the maximum number that can pass under the actual (prevailing) roadway and traffic conditions, i.e. after adjusting the basic capacity for lane width, shoulder, gradient, heavy vehicles, etc.
  3. Practical capacity (design capacity): the maximum number that can pass without unreasonable delay or restriction to the drivers' freedom to manoeuvre, at the chosen level of service. It is about 75-80 percent of the possible capacity (design service volume at LOS B for urban roads in IRC:106, and at LOS B for rural roads in IRC:64).
  • 2080 Bhadra · 8 marks

Using the data in the table below, come up with cycle length and actual green for all 2 phase signal. Assume lost time per phase = 3 seconds, yellow time of 3 seconds and all red time of 4 sec.
Veh/hrEastNorthWestSouth
Flow488338115217
Saturation flow1725172517251725

Answer

Two phases: Phase 1 = East-West, Phase 2 = North-South. The question asks for the cycle length and the actual (displayed) green of each phase.

Step 1: Flow ratios

Flow ratio y=q/sy = q/s for each approach; the larger value in a phase is the critical one.

PhaseApproachqsy = q/s
Phase 1East48817250.283 (critical)
Phase 1West11517250.067
Phase 2North33817250.196 (critical)
Phase 2South21717250.126
Y=0.283+0.196=0.479Y = 0.283 + 0.196 = 0.479

Step 2: Lost time

For each phase: start-up lost time 3 s, plus yellow 3 s and all-red 4 s (clearance interval II = 7 s), all treated as lost to traffic movement.

L=(3.0+7.0)+(3.0+7.0)=20.0 sL = (3.0+7.0) + (3.0+7.0) = 20.0\ \text{s}

Step 3: Optimum cycle time (Webster)

C0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(20.0)+51−0.479=67.2 sC_0 = \frac{1.5L + 5}{1 - Y} = \frac{1.5(20.0) + 5}{1 - 0.479} = 67.2\ \text{s}

Adopt C = 70 s.

Step 4: Green times

Total effective green =C−L=70−20.0=50.0= C - L = 70 - 20.0 = 50.0 s, divided in proportion to yy:

g1=yY(C−L)=0.2830.479(50.0)=29.5 sg_{1} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.283}{0.479}(50.0) = 29.5\ \text{s} g2=yY(C−L)=0.1960.479(50.0)=20.5 sg_{2} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.196}{0.479}(50.0) = 20.5\ \text{s}

Displayed green G=g+G = g + start-up loss (so that ∑G+∑I+R=C\sum G + \sum I + R = C):

PhaseEffective g (s)Start-up loss (s)Green G (s)Amber + all-red (s)
Phase 129.53.0337
Phase 220.53.0237

Check: 33 + 7 + 23 + 7 = 70 s.

Phase diagram

|     P1 green 33     |   A7   | P2 green 23  |   A7   |
  • 2080 Bhadra · 2+6 marks

Define PIEV theory. Categorize LOS and discuss the factors need to be considered to evaluate LOS.

Answer

PIEV theory

The PIEV theory explains the time a driver needs to respond to a hazard. The total reaction time is the sum of four stages:

  1. Perception (P): seeing and recognising that a stimulus (such as a stopped vehicle or a signal) exists. It depends on vision and attention.
  2. Intellection (I): understanding the stimulus and its meaning, comparing it with past experience.
  3. Emotion (E): the emotional response, such as fear or anger, which may help or delay the decision.
  4. Volition (V): deciding to act and the actual muscular response (lifting the foot from the accelerator and pressing the brake).
tPIEV=tP+tI+tE+tVt_{PIEV} = t_P + t_I + t_E + t_V

The total is usually 0.5 to 4 s, with 2.5 s adopted in Indian practice (IRC:SP:23 and IRC:66 take 2.5 s for sight-distance design; Nepal Road Standard 2070 also uses 2.5 s). It varies with age, fatigue, alcohol, complexity of the situation and the type of hazard. This time is used to compute stopping and overtaking sight distances.

Categories of LOS

LOSOperating conditionv/c (typical)
AFree flow, very low volume, high speed, driver free to choose speed0.0-0.3
BStable flow, some restriction of speed and manoeuvre0.3-0.5
CStable flow, speed and manoeuvre controlled by traffic0.5-0.7
DApproaching unstable flow, little freedom, small increase in flow causes large drop in speed0.7-0.85
EUnstable flow at or near capacity, speeds low and uniform0.85-1.0
FForced, breakdown flow; stop-and-go; flow below capacityvariable

IRC:106-1990 (urban roads) and IRC:64-1990 (rural roads) give design service volumes, generally at LOS B or C; Nepal Road Standard 2070 also designs for LOS B-C.

Factors considered to evaluate LOS

  1. Roadway (geometric) factors: lane width, lateral clearance (shoulder, kerb), number of lanes, horizontal and vertical alignment, gradient, sight distance, median presence. Narrow lanes (below 3.65 m) reduce capacity.
  2. Traffic factors: composition (share of buses, trucks and slow vehicles), directional distribution of traffic, lane distribution and the presence of pedestrians and cyclists.
  3. Control factors: signals (green time, cycle length, progression), signs, speed limits, and parking restrictions.
  4. Environmental factors: weather (rain, fog), lighting at night, surface condition, side friction (pedestrians, bus stops, parking and roadside activities).
  5. Driver factors: familiarity, behaviour (urban commuters versus tourists), and lane discipline.
  6. Operating (service) measures: speed and travel time, freedom to manoeuvre, comfort, interruptions and safety, v/c ratio, density.
  7. Peaking: the peak hour factor (PHF) and the variation of flow over time.
  • 2080 Baisakh · 8 marks

Explain the importance of vision to Road users. The acceleration of a vehicle is given by the equation below: dv/dt = 2 − 0.04v. Compute the time when the acceleration of the vehicle will be 1.0 m/s² if the vehicle was initially travelling at 100 kph.

Answer

Importance of vision to road users

About 90 percent of the information a road user needs (road alignment, signs, signals, other vehicles, pedestrians and hazards) is received through the eyes, so vision is the most important sense in driving. Defective vision causes late detection, wrong judgement of speed and distance, and crashes.

  • Visual acuity decides the distance at which signs and objects can be read; sign letter heights are fixed for it.
  • Field of vision (clear cone about 3-10 degrees, peripheral to about 120-160 degrees) fixes where signs are placed; it narrows with speed.
  • Colour vision is needed to read red, amber and green signals.
  • Glare vision and recovery affect night driving; they decide anti-glare design and lighting.
  • Depth perception is needed for judging gaps in overtaking and in crossing.
  • Night vision needs street lighting, retro-reflective signs and markings.

Therefore design provides adequate sight distance (IRC:66, IRC:SP:23), legible signs (IRC:67), lighting and markings (IRC:35).

Numerical

Given dvdt=2−0.04v\dfrac{dv}{dt} = 2 - 0.04v (v in m/s), initial speed v0=100v_0 = 100 km/h =27.78= 27.78 m/s.

Separating variables, a=2−0.04va = 2 - 0.04v obeys dadt=−0.04 dvdt=−0.04a\dfrac{da}{dt} = -0.04\,\dfrac{dv}{dt} = -0.04a, so

a(t)=a0e−0.04t,a0=2−0.04(27.78)=0.889 m/s2a(t) = a_0 e^{-0.04t},\qquad a_0 = 2 - 0.04(27.78) = 0.889\ \text{m/s}^2

For a=1.0a = 1.0 m/s2^2 the speed would have to be v=(2−1)/0.04=25v = (2-1)/0.04 = 25 m/s =90= 90 km/h:

t=10.04ln⁡a01.0=25ln⁡(0.889)=−2.94 st = \frac{1}{0.04}\ln\frac{a_0}{1.0} = 25\ln(0.889) = -2.94\ \text{s}

Answer: the acceleration at the start (100 km/h) is only 0.889 m/s2^2 and it keeps falling as the vehicle speeds up, so it never reaches 1.0 m/s2^2 in the future. The acceleration was 1.0 m/s2^2 about 2.94 s before the 100 km/h instant (t = -2.94 s, when the speed was 90 km/h). The value 1.0 m/s2^2 is reached after time zero only if the vehicle starts below 90 km/h (25 m/s); for example from rest t=25ln⁡2=17.33t = 25\ln 2 = 17.33 s.

  • 2080 Baisakh · 4 marks

Table below shows volume counts on an approach of an urban intersection from 8.30 AM to 10.30 AM.
TimeCount (PCU)
8:30 - 8:45500
8:45 - 9:00390
9:00 - 9:15300
9:15 - 9:30300
9:30 - 9:45260
9:45 - 10:00350
10:00 - 10:15400
10:15 - 10:30490
Determine (i) peak hour (ii) peak hourly volume (iii) peak hour factor, and (iv) the design flow rate for the approach.

Answer

The peak hour is found by adding the 15-minute counts over every four consecutive intervals (a sliding one-hour total) and choosing the largest.

One-hour periodVolume (PCU)
8:30 - 9:301490
8:45 - 9:451250
9:00 - 10:001210
9:15 - 10:151310
9:30 - 10:301500

(i) Peak hour

The largest one-hour total is 1500 PCU, in the period 9:30 - 10:30 AM (the 9:30 to 10:30 hour).

(ii) Peak hourly volume

Peak hour volume = 1500 PCU/h

(iii) Peak hour factor

The highest 15-minute count within the peak hour is 490 PCU (10:15 - 10:30).

PHF=Vpeak hour4×V15,max=15004×490=0.765PHF = \frac{V_{peak\ hour}}{4 \times V_{15,max}} = \frac{1500}{4 \times 490} = 0.765

(iv) Design flow rate

v=VPHF=15000.765=1960 PCU/h(=4×490)v = \frac{V}{PHF} = \frac{1500}{0.765} = 1960\ \text{PCU/h}\quad (= 4 \times 490)

Answer: peak hour 9:30-10:30 AM, peak hour volume 1500 PCU, PHF = 0.765, design flow rate = 1960 PCU/h.

  • 2080 Baisakh · 4 marks

Travel time data (in seconds) of 14 vehicles traversing a two kilometer road segment are: 80, 90, 96, 84.7, 72, 79.1, 120, 97.3, 85.7, 78.3, 80.9, 93.5, 76.6, and 86.7. Estimate (i) the time mean speed and (ii) the space mean speed (iii) What will be the average density of the above traffic stream if the mean headway is 8 sec?

Answer

Speed of each vehicle v=L/tv = L/t with L=2L = 2 km =2000= 2000 m.

VehicleTravel time (s)Speed (km/h)
18090.00
29080.00
39675.00
484.785.01
572100.00
679.191.02
712060.00
897.374.00
985.784.01
1078.391.95
1180.989.00
1293.577.01
1376.693.99
1486.783.04

(i) Time mean speed

vˉt=∑vin=1174.0414=83.86 km/h\bar v_t = \frac{\sum v_i}{n} = \frac{1174.04}{14} = 83.86\ \text{km/h}

(ii) Space mean speed

Mean travel time tˉ=1220.8/14=87.200\bar t = 1220.8/14 = 87.200 s.

vˉs=Ltˉ=200087.200=22.936 m/s=82.57 km/h\bar v_s = \frac{L}{\bar t} = \frac{2000}{87.200} = 22.936\ \text{m/s} = 82.57\ \text{km/h}

(iii) Average density

Mean headway 8 s gives flow q=3600/8=450q = 3600/8 = 450 veh/h. Using q=kvˉsq = k\bar v_s:

k=qvˉs=45082.57=5.45 veh/kmk = \frac{q}{\bar v_s} = \frac{450}{82.57} = 5.45\ \text{veh/km}

Answer: time mean speed = 83.86 km/h; space mean speed = 82.57 km/h; density = 5.45 veh/km. (The space mean speed is lower than the time mean speed, as always.)

  • 2080 Baisakh · 2+6 marks

Mention the need of crash studies. Discuss the steps to design highway lighting system.

Answer

Need of crash studies

  • To find the extent, trend, severity and types of crashes and the cost to the nation.
  • To identify black spots and the contributing causes (human, vehicle, road) so money is spent where it saves most lives.
  • To design suitable remedial measures (engineering, education, enforcement) and rank them by cost-benefit.
  • To judge the effect of measures by before-and-after studies, and for road safety audit and policy (for example Nepal's Road Safety Action Plan and DoR black-spot programme).
  • For legal, insurance and research purposes.

Steps to design a highway lighting system

  1. Classify the road and fix the need: arterial, collector or local; traffic volume, speed, crash record, intersections, bridges, curves and pedestrian crossings. Fix the required average illuminance and uniformity (IS 1944 / CIE: about 30 lux on major roads, 15-20 lux on secondary roads, 8 lux on residential; uniformity min/avg ≥\ge 0.3).
  2. Choose the arrangement: single side, staggered, opposite or central (twin-arm on median) according to the road width.
  3. Select the mounting height HH and luminaire type: cut-off or semi-cut-off to limit glare; HH about 8-12 m on highways, 6-8 m on local roads.
  4. Select the lamp: LED (preferred now), high-pressure sodium or metal halide; get its lumen output FF.
  5. Find the utilisation factor UfU_f and maintenance factor MM (0.7-0.8).
  6. Compute the spacing by the lumen method:
S=F Uf ME WS = \frac{F \, U_f \, M}{E\, W}
  1. Check S/HS/H (3 to 5), uniformity ratio and glare; adjust lamp or height if needed.
  2. Locate the poles: lateral offset at least 0.6 m behind the kerb (1.5 m or more on high-speed roads), use breakaway or frangible poles, and place additional lights at junctions and curves.
  3. Electrical design and economics: cable size, voltage drop, switching (timer or photocell), power and maintenance cost.
  • 2080 Baisakh · 8 marks

Road P is 13.5 m wide and road Q is 10.5 m. An isolated signal with pedestrian indications are to be installed at right angled intersection. The peak volumes per hour for road P and road Q are 250 and 200 respectively. The approaching speeds for road P and Q are 60 kmph and 45 kmph. Design the traffic and pedestrian signal timings.

Answer

Isolated two-phase signal with pedestrian indications for road P (13.5 m) and road Q (10.5 m).

Design basis (IRC:93-1985, Guidelines on Design and Installation of Road Traffic Signals, with Webster's method): two-phase signal, Phase 1 = road P moves, Phase 2 = road Q moves. Pedestrians cross a road while the traffic on the cross road has green. Assumed (not given): saturation flow 1800 PCU/h per lane, start-up lost time 2 s per phase, pedestrian walking speed 1.2 m/s and initial walk (pedestrian start-up) time 5 s.

Step 1: Amber (change) time

Amber I=tr+v2aI = t_r + \dfrac{v}{2a} with reaction time tr=1t_r = 1 s and comfortable deceleration a=3 m/s2a = 3\ \text{m/s}^2, kept within the IRC:93 range of 2-4 s:

IP=1+60/3.62(3)=3.78→4 sIQ=1+45/3.62(3)=3.08→4 s\begin{aligned} I_P &= 1 + \frac{60/3.6}{2(3)} = 3.78 \to 4\ \text{s}\\ I_Q &= 1 + \frac{45/3.6}{2(3)} = 3.08 \to 4\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 2: Pedestrian crossing time

Time to cross = initial walk + width / walking speed:

tp,P=5+13.51.2=16.2 stp,Q=5+10.51.2=13.8 s\begin{aligned} t_{p,P} &= 5 + \frac{13.5}{1.2} = 16.2\ \text{s}\\ t_{p,Q} &= 5 + \frac{10.5}{1.2} = 13.8\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Pedestrians crossing road P walk during Phase 2, so Phase 2 green must be at least 16.2 s. Pedestrians crossing road Q walk during Phase 1, so Phase 1 green must be at least 13.8 s.

Step 3: Webster cycle time from traffic

yP=2501800=0.139,yQ=2001800=0.111,Y=0.250L=(2+4)+(2+4)=12 sC0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(12)+51−0.250=30.7 s\begin{aligned} y_P &= \frac{250}{1800} = 0.139, \quad y_Q = \frac{200}{1800} = 0.111, \quad Y = 0.250\\ L &= (2+4) + (2+4) = 12\ \text{s}\\ C_0 &= \frac{1.5L+5}{1-Y} = \frac{1.5(12)+5}{1-0.250} = 30.7\ \text{s} \end{aligned} gP=0.1390.250(18.7)=10.4 s,GP=gP+2=12.4 sgQ=0.1110.250(18.7)=8.3 s,GQ=gQ+2=10.3 s\begin{aligned} g_P &= \frac{0.139}{0.250}(18.7) = 10.4\ \text{s}, \quad G_P = g_P + 2 = 12.4\ \text{s}\\ g_Q &= \frac{0.111}{0.250}(18.7) = 8.3\ \text{s}, \quad G_Q = g_Q + 2 = 10.3\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 4: Check against pedestrian needs

PhaseGreen from traffic (s)Pedestrian minimum (s)Adopted green (s)
1 (road P)12.413.814
2 (road Q)10.316.217

Adopted cycle length C=14+4+17+4=39C = 14 + 4 + 17 + 4 = 39 s.

Final timings

SignalPhase 1: road PPhase 2: road Q
Vehicle green14 s17 s
Vehicle amber4 s4 s
Vehicle red21 s18 s

Pedestrian signals: pedestrians crossing road Q get WALK for 5 s then flashing (clearance) for 9 s during Phase 1 (total 14 s of 14 s green); pedestrians crossing road P get WALK for 5 s then flashing for 11 s during Phase 2 (total 16 s of 17 s green). All pedestrian indications show DON'T WALK (red man) while their cross traffic moves.

Phase diagram

Cycle = 39 s
Road P: [GREEN 14][A 4][  RED 21  ]
Road Q: [ RED 18 ][GREEN 17][A 4]
Ped crossing Q: [WALK+FLASH 14][DON'T WALK 25]
Ped crossing P: [DON'T WALK 18][WALK+FLASH 17][DW]
  • 2079 Bhadra · 8 marks

Discuss traffic capacity of road and its types. Prepare a neat sketch of a rotary intersection with its geometric elements.

Answer

Traffic capacity of a road

Capacity of a road is the maximum number of vehicles (or PCUs) that can pass a given point or section of a lane or road in one direction (or both directions on a two-lane road) during a given time period (normally one hour) under the prevailing roadway, traffic and control conditions (HCM definition; IRC:106 for urban roads).

Types of capacity:

  1. Basic capacity: the maximum number of passenger cars that can pass in a lane under ideal (best possible) roadway and traffic conditions.
  2. Possible capacity: the maximum number that can pass under the actual (prevailing) roadway and traffic conditions, i.e. after adjusting the basic capacity for lane width, shoulder, gradient, heavy vehicles, etc.
  3. Practical capacity (design capacity): the maximum number that can pass without unreasonable delay or restriction to the drivers' freedom to manoeuvre, at the chosen level of service. It is about 75-80 percent of the possible capacity (design service volume at LOS B for urban roads in IRC:106, and at LOS B for rural roads in IRC:64).

The capacity depends on lane width, lateral clearance, gradient, the share of heavy vehicles, number of lanes and traffic control. Recommended capacity and design service volumes are given in IRC:106-1990 (urban roads), IRC:64-1990 and IRC:SP:73 (rural roads) and in the Nepal Road Standard 2070.

Sketch of a rotary intersection with geometric elements

          Approach road
              |   |
              | | |   <- splitter island
      ________/   \________
     /   Entry curve (R1)   \
 ---+     ,--------.        +---
    |   /  Central  \  <-- weaving
 ---+  |   island    |       +---
    |   \   (Rc)    /   Exit curve
     \___`--------'____/
              |   |
          Approach road

 e1 = entry width    e2 = non-weaving width
 w  = weaving width  l  = weaving length
 (clockwise one-way circulation for left-hand traffic)

Geometric elements: central island radius RcR_c, entry radius R1R_1, exit radius R2R_2, entry width e1e_1, width of non-weaving section e2e_2, weaving width w=(e1+e2)/2+3.5w = (e_1+e_2)/2 + 3.5 m, weaving length ll, and splitter islands.

  • 2079 Bhadra · 8 marks

The design hour traffic and saturation headway at a four-legged intersection are:
ApproachNorth (N)South (S)East (E)West (W)
Design hour flow450430350315
Saturation headway (sec)2.252.332.52.75
Design a two phase signal for the intersection based on Webster method and draw the phase diagram. Use amber time of 2 sec on each phase for clearance and start-up loss time phase per phase of 1.5 sec.

Answer

Phases: Phase 1 = North-South, Phase 2 = East-West. Saturation flow from saturation headway s=3600/hs = 3600/h.

Step 1: Flow ratios

Flow ratio y=q/sy = q/s for each approach; the larger value in a phase is the critical one.

PhaseApproachqsy = q/s
Phase 1North45016000.281 (critical)
Phase 1South43015450.278
Phase 2East35014400.243 (critical)
Phase 2West31513090.241
Y=0.281+0.243=0.524Y = 0.281 + 0.243 = 0.524

Step 2: Lost time

Lost time per phase = start-up loss 1.5 s + amber 2 s = 3.5 s.

L=(1.5+2.0)+(1.5+2.0)=7.0 sL = (1.5+2.0) + (1.5+2.0) = 7.0\ \text{s}

Step 3: Optimum cycle time (Webster)

C0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(7.0)+51−0.524=32.6 sC_0 = \frac{1.5L + 5}{1 - Y} = \frac{1.5(7.0) + 5}{1 - 0.524} = 32.6\ \text{s}

Adopt C = 35 s.

Step 4: Green times

Total effective green =C−L=35−7.0=28.0= C - L = 35 - 7.0 = 28.0 s, divided in proportion to yy:

g1=yY(C−L)=0.2810.524(28.0)=15.0 sg_{1} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.281}{0.524}(28.0) = 15.0\ \text{s} g2=yY(C−L)=0.2430.524(28.0)=13.0 sg_{2} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.243}{0.524}(28.0) = 13.0\ \text{s}

Displayed green G=g+G = g + start-up loss (so that ∑G+∑I+R=C\sum G + \sum I + R = C):

PhaseEffective g (s)Start-up loss (s)Green G (s)Amber (s)
Phase 115.01.5172
Phase 213.01.5142

Check: 17 + 2 + 14 + 2 = 35 s.

Phase diagram

|      P1 green 17      |  A2 |    P2 green 14    |  A2 |
  • 2078 Bhadra · 8 marks

At right angled crossing of road A and road B isolated signal with pedestrain indicators is to be installed. The road A is 14.4m wide and road B is 12m wide and the peak hour volumes are 280 and 230 PCU per hour and the approach speeds are 50 and 35 kmph respectively. Design the vehicular and pedestrian signal timing.

Answer

Isolated two-phase signal with pedestrian indicators for road A (14.4 m) and road B (12 m). Flows of 280 and 230 PCU/h are taken as the heaviest flow per lane.

Design basis (IRC:93-1985, Guidelines on Design and Installation of Road Traffic Signals, with Webster's method): two-phase signal, Phase 1 = road A moves, Phase 2 = road B moves. Pedestrians cross a road while the traffic on the cross road has green. Assumed (not given): saturation flow 1800 PCU/h per lane, start-up lost time 2 s per phase, pedestrian walking speed 1.2 m/s and initial walk (pedestrian start-up) time 5 s.

Step 1: Amber (change) time

Amber I=tr+v2aI = t_r + \dfrac{v}{2a} with reaction time tr=1t_r = 1 s and comfortable deceleration a=3 m/s2a = 3\ \text{m/s}^2, kept within the IRC:93 range of 2-4 s:

IA=1+50/3.62(3)=3.31→4 sIB=1+35/3.62(3)=2.62→3 s\begin{aligned} I_A &= 1 + \frac{50/3.6}{2(3)} = 3.31 \to 4\ \text{s}\\ I_B &= 1 + \frac{35/3.6}{2(3)} = 2.62 \to 3\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 2: Pedestrian crossing time

Time to cross = initial walk + width / walking speed:

tp,A=5+14.41.2=17.0 stp,B=5+121.2=15.0 s\begin{aligned} t_{p,A} &= 5 + \frac{14.4}{1.2} = 17.0\ \text{s}\\ t_{p,B} &= 5 + \frac{12}{1.2} = 15.0\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Pedestrians crossing road A walk during Phase 2, so Phase 2 green must be at least 17.0 s. Pedestrians crossing road B walk during Phase 1, so Phase 1 green must be at least 15.0 s.

Step 3: Webster cycle time from traffic

yA=2801800=0.156,yB=2301800=0.128,Y=0.283L=(2+4)+(2+3)=11 sC0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(11)+51−0.283=30.0 s\begin{aligned} y_A &= \frac{280}{1800} = 0.156, \quad y_B = \frac{230}{1800} = 0.128, \quad Y = 0.283\\ L &= (2+4) + (2+3) = 11\ \text{s}\\ C_0 &= \frac{1.5L+5}{1-Y} = \frac{1.5(11)+5}{1-0.283} = 30.0\ \text{s} \end{aligned} gA=0.1560.283(19.0)=10.4 s,GA=gA+2=12.4 sgB=0.1280.283(19.0)=8.6 s,GB=gB+2=10.6 s\begin{aligned} g_A &= \frac{0.156}{0.283}(19.0) = 10.4\ \text{s}, \quad G_A = g_A + 2 = 12.4\ \text{s}\\ g_B &= \frac{0.128}{0.283}(19.0) = 8.6\ \text{s}, \quad G_B = g_B + 2 = 10.6\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 4: Check against pedestrian needs

PhaseGreen from traffic (s)Pedestrian minimum (s)Adopted green (s)
1 (road A)12.415.015
2 (road B)10.617.017

Adopted cycle length C=15+4+17+3=39C = 15 + 4 + 17 + 3 = 39 s.

Final timings

SignalPhase 1: road APhase 2: road B
Vehicle green15 s17 s
Vehicle amber4 s3 s
Vehicle red20 s19 s

Pedestrian signals: pedestrians crossing road B get WALK for 5 s then flashing (clearance) for 10 s during Phase 1 (total 15 s of 15 s green); pedestrians crossing road A get WALK for 5 s then flashing for 12 s during Phase 2 (total 17 s of 17 s green). All pedestrian indications show DON'T WALK (red man) while their cross traffic moves.

Phase diagram

Cycle = 39 s
Road A: [GREEN 15][A 4][  RED 20  ]
Road B: [ RED 19 ][GREEN 17][A 3]
Ped crossing B: [WALK+FLASH 15][DON'T WALK 24]
Ped crossing A: [DON'T WALK 19][WALK+FLASH 17][DW]
  • 2078 Bhadra · 8 marks

Explain the design factors to be considered in rotary intersection design.

Answer

Design elements/factors for a rotary (IRC:65-1976, Recommended Practice for Traffic Rotaries)

  1. Design speed: about 30 km/h for urban and 40 km/h for rural rotaries (IRC:65 gives 40 km/h for rural and 30 km/h for urban areas).
  2. Radius of the central island and entry/exit curves: the central island radius is about 1.33 times the entry curve radius (IRC:65); entry curve radius about 20 m (urban) to 25 m (rural); exit curves about 1.5 to 2 times the entry curve radius, to speed up exits.
  3. Weaving length and width: the weaving length between the entry and exit of consecutive arms should be at least 4 times the weaving width (IRC:65), and is checked so that w/lw/l lies between 0.12 and 0.4 for the capacity formula.
  4. Width of the rotary carriageway: the width of the weaving section is the entry width plus 3.5 m (w=(e1+e2)/2+3.5w = (e_1 + e_2)/2 + 3.5 m); minimum 7 m for a rotary on two-lane approaches.
  5. Entry and exit widths: the entry width e1e_1 and non-weaving width e2e_2 are provided to suit the approach carriageways (about 0.5-1.0 times the weaving width for e/we/w).
  6. Shape of the central island: circular (preferred), elliptical, tangent or turbine shapes to suit the angles of the approach roads.
  7. Traffic volume and proportion of weaving traffic: the capacity formula depends on this proportion pp (0.4-1.0).
  8. Super-elevation and cross slope: the carriageway is given a reverse camber of about 1.5 to 2 percent (cross fall outward) for drainage; no superelevation inwards.
  9. Sight distance at entries and in the circulating carriageway.
  10. Channelising islands, refuge for pedestrians, markings, signs and lighting.

Capacity check: the practical capacity of the weaving section (IRC:65, TRL formula) is

Qp=280 w(1+ew)(1−p3)1+wl PCU/hQ_p = \frac{280\,w\left(1+\dfrac{e}{w}\right)\left(1-\dfrac{p}{3}\right)}{1+\dfrac{w}{l}}\ \text{PCU/h}

where e=(e1+e2)/2e = (e_1+e_2)/2, ww = weaving width (m), ll = weaving length (m), pp = proportion of weaving traffic to total traffic in the weaving section. The design is valid when 0.4≤e/w≤1.00.4 \le e/w \le 1.0, 0.12≤w/l≤0.40.12 \le w/l \le 0.4, 0.4≤p≤1.00.4 \le p \le 1.0 and ww lies between 6 and 18 m.

  • 2076 Chaitra · 8 marks

Explain different vehicular characteristics that influence traffic performance.

Answer

Vehicular characteristics are the properties of the vehicle that affect the geometric design, traffic flow, safety and pavement design. They are classed as static and dynamic.

Static characteristics

CharacteristicTypical valueEffect on road design
Width2.5 m (trucks, buses)Lane width (3.5 m rural, 3.0-3.25 m urban), parking bay width
Heightup to 4.75 m (IRC)Vertical clearance under bridges and tunnels (5.5 m minimum, IRC:5)
Length11-12 m rigid, up to 18 m semi-trailerParking bays, curve widening, kerb radius, passing and storage lanes
Wheel base and overhang6-7 m (truck)Extra widening on curves, minimum turning radius, tail swing
Ground clearance0.2-0.3 mHump, drain and vertical-curve design
Turning radius12-14 m (truck)Minimum intersection radius, island and median-opening design
Weight and axle load10.2 t legal single axle; 8.16 t standard axle in IRC:37Pavement thickness, bridge loading (IRC:6), width of bridge
Eye and object heightdriver eye 1.2 m, object 0.15 m (IRC:SP:23)Sight distance at crests

Examples: the 2.5 m width and 11 m length of a bus fix the minimum bay size; the 4.75 m height fixes bridge clearance; the large turning radius of trucks fixes the radius of intersection corners; the axle load fixes pavement thickness.

Dynamic characteristics

  • Power and performance: engine power, tractive effort and weight-to-power ratio decide acceleration, gradient ability and the need for climbing lanes.
  • Speed and acceleration: the typical range of speeds and accelerations fixes overtaking sight distance, length of acceleration/deceleration lanes and signal timings.
  • Braking and braking efficiency: deceleration depends on tyre-pavement friction (f about 0.35-0.40); it fixes stopping sight distance.
  • Resistances: air, rolling, grade and curve resistance decide fuel use and the speed on gradients.
  • Turning and stability: centrifugal force limits speed on curves, so superelevation and radius are provided; high centre of gravity vehicles may overturn.
  • Headlight range and visibility: fix night sight distance and vertical-curve length.
  • Vehicle mix: the share of heavy vehicles sets the PCU factors (IRC:106-1990: car 1.0, bus/truck 3.0, motor cycle 0.5, bicycle 0.5, cycle rickshaw 2.0, horse cart 4.0, bullock cart 6.0).

Other characteristics

  • Vehicle composition and PCU: the traffic mix is converted to passenger car units (IRC:106) for capacity and signal design.
  • Visibility from the vehicle: the eye and head-light height decide sight distances.
  • 2076 Chaitra · 8 marks

Discuss different types of intersection. Write down the advantages and limitations of grade separated intersection.

Answer

Intersections are of two kinds: at-grade and grade-separated.

Types of intersection

1. At-grade intersections (roads meet on the same level)

  • Unchannelised: simple junctions (T, Y, cross, skew, staggered, multi-leg) without islands; used at low volume.
  • Flared: extra lanes added near the junction for turning vehicles.
  • Channelised: islands and markings guide each movement into a definite path (IRC:SP:41).
  • Rotary (roundabout): one-way circulation around a central island (IRC:65).
  • Signalised: control by traffic signals (IRC:93).

2. Grade-separated intersections (roads cross at different levels)

  • Overpass/underpass (no connection), trumpet (T-junction), diamond, cloverleaf, directional/stack and rotary interchange.
 T (3-leg)   Cross (4-leg)  Skew      Staggered    Y
    |            |          \ /        |   |       \ /
 ---+---     ----+----       X       ---+   +---     |

Advantages of grade-separated intersections

  • Removes crossing conflicts, so crashes are fewer and less severe.
  • Gives free-flow high speed and large capacity without stops, so delay and fuel use fall.
  • Safe pedestrian movement if combined with an underpass or overbridge.
  • Suitable for expressways and controlled-access highways.

Limitations

  • Very high cost of land and construction; long construction time.
  • Needs a large area and may displace property.
  • Affects the appearance of the area and may increase noise.
  • Complex and expensive to maintain; may confuse unfamiliar drivers; long detours for some movements.
  • Only justified at high volumes.
  • 2076 Chaitra · 4 marks

The vehicle arrivals at the section of road are assumed to be Poisson distributed with an average arrival rate of 1 vehicle every 5 minutes. What is the probability of (i) Exactly 3 vehicles arrive in a 15 minute interval (ii) less than 3 vehicles arrive in a 15 minute interval? (iii) More than 3 vehicles arrive in a 15 minute intervals?

Answer

For Poisson arrivals, the probability of nn arrivals in an interval is P(n)=mne−mn!P(n) = \dfrac{m^n e^{-m}}{n!} where m=λtm = \lambda t is the mean number of arrivals in the interval.

Rate: 1 vehicle per 5 min, so in 15 min m=15/5=3m = 15/5 = 3 vehicles.

(i) Exactly 3 vehicles

P(3)=33e−33!=27(0.04979)6=0.2240P(3) = \frac{3^3 e^{-3}}{3!} = \frac{27(0.04979)}{6} = 0.2240

(ii) Less than 3 vehicles

P(n<3)=P(0)+P(1)+P(2)=0.0498+0.1494+0.2240=0.4232\begin{aligned} P(n<3) &= P(0)+P(1)+P(2)\\ &= 0.0498 + 0.1494 + 0.2240 = 0.4232 \end{aligned}

(iii) More than 3 vehicles

P(n>3)=1−[P(0)+P(1)+P(2)+P(3)]=1−(0.4232+0.2240)=0.3528P(n>3) = 1 - [P(0)+P(1)+P(2)+P(3)] = 1 - (0.4232 + 0.2240) = 0.3528

Answer: (i) 0.2240 (22.4 %), (ii) 0.4232 (42.3 %), (iii) 0.3528 (35.3 %).

  • 2076 Chaitra · 4 marks

Calculate the capacity of rotary with entry and exit width of 8m, the width of non-weaving section is 9m, width of rotary is 12m, length of weaving section is 60m. The ratio of weaving to total traffic in the weaving section is 0.7.

Answer

Capacity of the weaving section of a rotary (IRC:65, based on the TRL/Wardrop formula):

Qp=280 w(1+ew)(1−p3)1+wl PCU/hQ_p = \frac{280\,w\left(1+\dfrac{e}{w}\right)\left(1-\dfrac{p}{3}\right)}{1+\dfrac{w}{l}}\ \text{PCU/h}

Data: weaving width w=12w = 12 m (width of the rotary), entry width e1=8e_1 = 8 m, non-weaving width e2=9e_2 = 9 m, so e=(e1+e2)/2=8.5e = (e_1+e_2)/2 = 8.5 m; l=60l = 60 m; p=0.7p = 0.7.

Check of limits: e/w=0.708e/w = 0.708 (0.4 to 1.0 OK), w/l=0.20w/l = 0.20 (0.12 to 0.4 OK), p=0.7p = 0.7 (0.4 to 1.0 OK).

Qp=280(12)(1+8.512)(1−0.73)1+1260=3360(1.7083)(0.7667)1.2=3667 PCU/h\begin{aligned} Q_p &= \frac{280(12)\left(1+\dfrac{8.5}{12}\right)\left(1-\dfrac{0.7}{3}\right)}{1+\dfrac{12}{60}}\\ &= \frac{3360(1.7083)(0.7667)}{1.2} = 3667\ \text{PCU/h} \end{aligned}

Answer: capacity of the rotary = 3667 PCU/h.

  • 2076 Chaitra · 8 marks

The average normal flow of traffic on the cross roads 1 and 2 during design period are 450 and 350 PCU/hr. The saturation headway on these roads are estimates as 2.5sec and 3.75 sec respectively. The all red time required for pedestrian crossing is 15sec. Design two phase signal by Webster's method with neat phase diagram. Take amber time of 2 sec on each phase for clearance and start-up loss time of 2 sec and 3 sec for roads 1 & 2 respectively.

Answer

Saturation flow from headway: s=3600/hs = 3600/h. Road 1: 3600/2.5 = 1440 PCU/h; Road 2: 3600/3.75 = 960 PCU/h.

Step 1: Flow ratios

Flow ratio y=q/sy = q/s for each approach; the larger value in a phase is the critical one.

PhaseApproachqsy = q/s
Phase 1Road 145014400.312
Phase 2Road 23509600.365
Y=0.312+0.365=0.677Y = 0.312 + 0.365 = 0.677

Step 2: Lost time

Lost time per phase = start-up loss (2 s for road 1, 3 s for road 2) + amber 2 s, plus the all-red period RR = 15 s for pedestrian crossing, which occurs once in the cycle.

L=(2.0+2.0)+(3.0+2.0)+15=24.0 sL = (2.0+2.0) + (3.0+2.0) + 15 = 24.0\ \text{s}

Step 3: Optimum cycle time (Webster)

C0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(24.0)+51−0.677=127.0 sC_0 = \frac{1.5L + 5}{1 - Y} = \frac{1.5(24.0) + 5}{1 - 0.677} = 127.0\ \text{s}

Adopt C = 130 s.

Step 4: Green times

Total effective green =C−L=130−24.0=106.0= C - L = 130 - 24.0 = 106.0 s, divided in proportion to yy:

g1=yY(C−L)=0.3120.677(106.0)=48.9 sg_{1} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.312}{0.677}(106.0) = 48.9\ \text{s} g2=yY(C−L)=0.3650.677(106.0)=57.1 sg_{2} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.365}{0.677}(106.0) = 57.1\ \text{s}

Displayed green G=g+G = g + start-up loss (so that ∑G+∑I+R=C\sum G + \sum I + R = C):

PhaseEffective g (s)Start-up loss (s)Green G (s)Amber (s)
Phase 148.92.0512
Phase 257.13.0602

Check: 51 + 2 + 60 + 2 + 15 = 130 s.

Phase diagram

|    P1 green 51     | A2|      P2 green 60       | A2| R 15|
  • 2076 Asoj · 8 marks

A bicycle racer practices everyday in the morning. Her route includes a ride along 800 m bikeway and back. Since she is traffic engineer, she has made it a habit to count the numbers of cars in lane A that she meets while riding southward, the number of cars in lane A that overtake her while riding northward and the number of cars in lane A that she overtakes while riding northward as shown in table below. Find average traffic flow and time of lane A.
Average Travel speed (km/hr)Nos. of Vehicle metNos. of Overtaken VehicleNos. of Overtaking Vehicle
321171074
34932541
3230155
3370189

Answer

The moving observer method gives flow and mean travel time of lane A from counts made by the rider moving with and against the stream.

Reading of the table: the cars met while riding southward are the northbound stream of lane A (NsN_s). While riding northward, cars overtaking her (NoN_o) and cars she overtakes (NpN_p) are counted. The column "overtaken" is read as cars that overtook her (NoN_o: 10, 25, 15, 18) and "overtaking" as cars she overtook (NpN_p: 74, 41, 5, 9), following the order of the question text.

Average values (4 runs)

Travel time on each run t=0.8/vt = 0.8/v: 90.0, 84.7, 90.0, 87.3 s, giving a mean of tw=ta=88.0t_w = t_a = 88.0 s =1.467= 1.467 min =0.02444= 0.02444 h.

Nˉs=117+93+30+704=77.50Nˉo=17.00,Nˉp=32.25,y=Nˉo−Nˉp=−15.25\begin{aligned} \bar N_s &= \frac{117+93+30+70}{4} = 77.50\\ \bar N_o &= 17.00,\quad \bar N_p = 32.25,\quad y = \bar N_o - \bar N_p = -15.25 \end{aligned}

Flow

q=Nˉs+ytw+ta=77.50+(−15.25)2(0.02444)=1273 veh/hq = \frac{\bar N_s + y}{t_w + t_a} = \frac{77.50 + (-15.25)}{2(0.02444)} = 1273\ \text{veh/h}

Mean travel time of lane A

tˉ=tw−yq=0.02444−(−15.25)1273=0.03642 h=131.1 s\bar t = t_w - \frac{y}{q} = 0.02444 - \frac{(-15.25)}{1273} = 0.03642\ \text{h} = 131.1\ \text{s}

Mean speed =0.8/0.03642=22.0= 0.8/0.03642 = 22.0 km/h.

Answer: average flow of lane A = 1273 veh/h; average travel time = 131.1 s (2.19 min) over the 800 m, i.e. a stream speed of 22.0 km/h.

  • 2076 Asoj · 8 marks

List out the importance of parking and ill effect of illegal parking. Explain about different types of On-Street and Off-street parking facilities with their pros and cons.

Answer

Importance of parking

  • Vehicles spend most of their life parked, so the city must give them space; the supply of parking affects the economic life of the central area and the use of public transport.
  • Planned parking keeps the carriageway free for moving traffic; a lack of parking space forces vehicles onto the road.
  • Parking studies give the demand (accumulation, duration, turnover) needed to plan size, location, fees and regulation of parking.

Ill effects of illegal parking

  • It reduces road capacity by taking the kerb lane and blocks the visibility of drivers and pedestrians.
  • It causes congestion and delay, especially at intersections, bus stops and narrow streets.
  • It raises crash risk: parked vehicles hide pedestrians, doors open into traffic, and vehicles pulling out cut across traffic.
  • It blocks emergency vehicles (fire, ambulance) and service access.
  • It harms the environment (extra emission by cruising for a space, noise) and damages the appearance of the street and footpath.
  • It blocks footpaths, forcing pedestrians into the carriageway.

On-street and off-street parking facilities

A. On-street parking (vehicles park along the kerb):

TypeArrangementRemarks
ParallelVehicles parked along the kerb, bay about 5.0-5.5 m x 2.0-2.5 mLeast road width needed, safest, but fewest cars per length
30 degree angleFront end towards the kerbModerate capacity, easy entry
45 degree angleFront in or back inGood capacity, easy to park
60 degree angleFront inHigh capacity, needs wider bay
90 degree (right angle)Perpendicular to the kerbMost vehicles per length, most road width, high risk to through traffic
 Parallel            45 degree           90 degree
 ______________     \ \ \ \ \          | | | | | |
 [car] [car] [car]   \_\_\_\_\_         |_|_|_|_|_|
 ========= kerb      ===== kerb          ===== kerb

B. Off-street parking:

  • Surface parking lots: open areas near markets or terminals; low cost, require land.
  • Multi-storey (multi-level) parking: several floors; best use of costly land, high construction cost; ramp or mechanical access.
  • Underground parking: below buildings or public squares; keeps surface free, expensive.
  • Mechanical or automated parking: lifts and stackers, used where land is very scarce.
  • Park-and-ride facilities: at city edges, linked to public transport.

Nepal practice: on-street parking is regulated by the Metropolitan/Municipal offices and Traffic Police (parallel parking on one side, paid parking zones), and off-street parking is required in new buildings by the Nepal National Building Code (NBC 206 / municipal building bye-laws).

Pros and cons

AspectOn-streetOff-street
LocationOn the carriageway edgeIn lots, garages, basements
CostVery low (markings, signs, meters)High (land, construction, staff)
ConvenienceVery close to the destinationSlightly further to walk
Effect on trafficReduces road capacity and safetyNo effect on road capacity
CapacitySmallLarge, especially multi-level
Safety and securityLower; risk of theft/damageBetter supervision and security
ControlHard; often illegal parkingEasy; gates, tickets, fees
Pedestrian effectObstructs footpathProtects footpath
  • 2076 Asoj · 2+3+3 marks

What are the factors affecting Night Visibility? What are the different types of road marking and traffic island used to regulate and control traffic flow? Explain.

Answer

Factors affecting night visibility

  • Headlight intensity, beam type and alignment; glare from opposing lights and glare recovery time.
  • Street lighting level and uniformity.
  • Contrast and reflectance of the object and the pavement (a wet or dark pavement reflects little).
  • Vehicle speed, age and eyesight of the driver, weather (fog, rain) and a dirty windscreen.
  • Presence of retro-reflective signs, markings and delineators.

Road markings (IRC:35)

  • Pavement markings: centre line, lane lines, edge lines, no-overtaking (barrier) lines, stop and give-way lines, zebra crossings, arrows and words, hatching.
  • Kerb markings: black/yellow bands for no-parking or no-stopping.
  • Object markers: black-white or yellow-black bands on piers, abutments and poles.
  • Parking bay markings.

Colours: white for lane and edge lines, yellow for no-overtaking and kerb restrictions. Thermoplastic paint with glass beads is used for night visibility.

Traffic islands

  1. Channelising islands: triangular or teardrop islands that guide vehicles into definite paths and prevent wrong movements, usually at the junction of a minor road with a major road.
  2. Dividing (separating) islands / medians: separate opposing traffic flows on the approaches of a junction or a divided road and reduce head-on conflicts.
  3. Pedestrian refuge islands: safe place in the middle of the carriageway for pedestrians to wait while crossing. At least 1.5 m wide (preferably 2.0 m) and 1.2 to 1.5 m long.
  4. Rotary (central) island: the central island of a roundabout around which vehicles circulate.
  5. Splitter islands: at the entry of a rotary on each approach, to keep traffic on its own side and reduce the speed.
  6. Traffic control islands: for signs, signals and luminaires.
  7. Loading and bus-stop islands.

Islands are made of kerbed concrete or masonry with a mountable or barrier kerb, painted with reflective markings; the nose is offset about 0.5 m from the edge of the carriageway (IRC:SP:41).

  • 2075 Chaitra · 8 marks

What are the basic requirements of intersection at grade? Write down the design steps of rotary intersection.

Answer

Basic requirements of an intersection at grade

  1. Safety first: reduce the number and severity of conflict points; give drivers clear sight of each other (sight triangle, IRC:66 and IRC:SP:41).
  2. Adequate capacity: the junction must carry the design hour volume of all movements without long delays.
  3. Simple, clear layout: drivers should understand the movements at once; avoid complex or multiple-road junctions; avoid skew (angle between roads should be about 90 degrees, not less than 60 degrees).
  4. Minimum conflict area: keep the paved area small and channelise movements with islands, so vehicles cannot wander.
  5. Good visibility: approach sight distance and sight triangles should be free of obstructions.
  6. Separation of conflicts by space (islands, channelisation), by time (signals) or by level (grade separation).
  7. Suitable geometry: correct approach gradients (flat, not more than about 4 percent), corner radii for the design vehicle, adequate turning lanes and pedestrian facilities.
  8. Proper traffic control devices: signs, markings, signals or rotary where needed.
  9. Pedestrians and cyclists need crossings, refuge and signal time.
  10. Economy: the cost of land, construction and operation should match the benefit.
  11. Drainage and lighting for safe all-weather and night use.

Design steps of a rotary (IRC:65)

  1. Collect data: peak-hour volume of each movement (PCU), traffic composition, approach speeds, land available; check that a rotary suits the junction (4 or more arms, volume between about 500 and 3000 PCU/h entering).
  2. Fix the design speed: 30 km/h (urban) or 40 km/h (rural).
  3. Choose the entry curve radius R1R_1 (about 20 m urban, 25 m rural), exit radius R2=1.5R_2 = 1.5-2R12R_1, and central island radius Rc≈1.33R1R_c \approx 1.33R_1.
  4. Fix widths: entry width e1e_1 and non-weaving width e2e_2 from the approach carriageways; weaving width w=(e1+e2)/2+3.5w = (e_1+e_2)/2 + 3.5 m.
  5. Fix the weaving length ll: at least 4 times ww (usually 30-90 m); the length is measured between the ends of the splitter islands of successive arms.
  6. Compute the weaving traffic proportion pp from the turning volumes: p=(b+c)/(a+b+c+d)p = (b + c)/(a+b+c+d) (the crossing streams over the total).
  7. Check the capacity of the weaving section:
Qp=280 w(1+e/w)(1−p/3)1+w/lQ_p = \frac{280\,w(1+e/w)(1-p/3)}{1+w/l}

and confirm Qp≥Q_p \ge the actual weaving traffic; if not, increase ww or ll and repeat. Check the limits for e/we/w, w/lw/l and pp. 8. Design the details: entry and exit curves, splitter islands, cross fall (outward 1.5-2 %), sight distance at entries, pedestrian crossings, signs, markings and lighting.

  • 2075 Chaitra · 8 marks

In a field survey of spot speed measurement, the following twenty observations were taken. Find time mean speed, and space mean speed.
50, 40, 60, 54, 45, 31, 72, 58, 43, 52, 46, 56, 43, 65, 33, 69, 34, 51, 47, 41.
Also, assuming these vehicle speeds are fixed over a half km segment, calculate the corresponding travel times and show that the space mean speed calculated using travel times is equal to the point estimate.

Answer

Time mean speed

The time mean speed is the arithmetic mean of the spot speeds:

vˉt=∑vin=99020=49.50 km/h\bar v_t = \frac{\sum v_i}{n} = \frac{990}{20} = 49.50\ \text{km/h}

Space mean speed

The space mean speed is the harmonic mean of the spot speeds:

vˉs=n∑(1/vi)=200.42600=46.95 km/h\bar v_s = \frac{n}{\sum (1/v_i)} = \frac{20}{0.42600} = 46.95\ \text{km/h}

Travel times over 0.5 km

ti=0.5/vi×3600t_i = 0.5/v_i \times 3600 s:

VehicleSpeed (km/h)Travel time (s)
15036.00
24045.00
36030.00
45433.33
54540.00
63158.06
77225.00
85831.03
94341.86
105234.62
114639.13
125632.14
134341.86
146527.69
153354.55
166926.09
173452.94
185135.29
194738.30
204143.90

Mean travel time tˉ=766.80/20=38.340\bar t = 766.80/20 = 38.340 s =0.010650= 0.010650 h.

vˉs=Ltˉ=0.50.010650=46.95 km/h\bar v_s = \frac{L}{\bar t} = \frac{0.5}{0.010650} = 46.95\ \text{km/h}

This equals the harmonic mean of the spot speeds (46.95 km/h), because L/tˉ=L/(1n∑L/vi)=n/∑(1/vi)L/\bar t = L/\left(\frac{1}{n}\sum L/v_i\right) = n/\sum(1/v_i).

Answer: time mean speed = 49.50 km/h; space mean speed = 46.95 km/h (same from travel times). The space mean speed is lower than the time mean speed.

  • 2075 Chaitra · 8 marks

What are the causes of accident and how accident can be prevented? Describe briefly the factors influencing street light design.

Answer

Causes of accidents

  1. Road user (human) factors: over-speeding, drunk or drowsy driving, overtaking in unsafe places, ignoring signals, jaywalking, lack of experience or training, fatigue, using mobile phones. These account for about 80-90 percent of crashes.
  2. Vehicle factors: brake failure, tyre burst, steering defects, overloading, defective lights, poor maintenance and lack of fitness tests.
  3. Road and geometric factors: sharp curves, poor sight distance, narrow carriageways and bridges, insufficient superelevation, slippery or damaged pavement, absence of shoulders, poor intersection design.
  4. Traffic control factors: missing or confusing signs, signals and markings, absent or poor lighting.
  5. Environmental factors: rain, fog, snow, landslides and flooding (especially important in Nepal's hilly roads); night-time.
  6. Other causes: animals on the road, poor enforcement of law and lack of emergency services.

Preventive measures — the 5 E's

  • Engineering: safe geometric design, adequate sight distance, proper superelevation, signs, markings, guard rails, crash barriers, street lighting, speed humps, pedestrian crossings and bridges, black-spot treatment, road safety audit.
  • Education: driver training and licensing, school programmes, public awareness campaigns and media.
  • Enforcement: speed and drunk-driving checks, helmet and seat-belt laws, vehicle fitness inspection, penalty and demerit points under the Motor Vehicles and Transport Management Act 2049.
  • Encouragement: reward safe drivers; promote safety culture and use of protective equipment.
  • Emergency services: quick ambulance and first aid, trauma care and a good crash reporting system (IRC:53 forms A-1 and A-4).

Factors influencing street light design

  1. Type of road and traffic volume: arterial, collector or local street decides the illumination level (lux) and uniformity (about 30 lux on important roads, 15 lux on secondary, 8 lux on residential roads in Indian practice).
  2. Mounting height (H): usually 8-10 m on main roads, 6-7.5 m on minor roads; higher poles give more uniform light and reduce glare but need more power.
  3. Spacing (S): typically 3 to 5 times the mounting height; the spacing-to-height ratio controls uniformity.
  4. Lamp type and luminous flux: LED, high-pressure sodium or mercury; wattage and lumen output.
  5. Luminaire type, light distribution and tilt (cut-off, semi-cut-off, non-cut-off).
  6. Arrangement of the lamps: single side, staggered, opposite, central (median) or suspended.
  7. Lateral offset or overhang: the position of the post from the carriageway edge (about 0.6 m minimum clear from the kerb; 1.5 m or more on high-speed roads).
  8. Uniformity ratio: minimum-to-average illuminance, about 0.3 to 0.4.
  9. Glare control, maintenance factor (about 0.7-0.8), cost, local environment (trees, dust), and power availability.
  • 2075 Chaitra · 8 marks

The average normal flow of traffic on cross roads A and B, of width 7m both, during design period are 400 and 250 PCU/hr; the saturation flow values on these roads are estimated as 1250 and 1000 PCU per hour respectively. The all-red time is provided for pedestrian crossing with speed 1 m/sec and initial walk time 6 sec. Design two phase traffic signal.

Answer

Both roads are 7 m wide. Pedestrian crossing time (all-red period RR): initial walk 6 s + width/speed = 6+7/1.0=136 + 7/1.0 = 13 s.

Step 1: Flow ratios

Flow ratio y=q/sy = q/s for each approach; the larger value in a phase is the critical one.

PhaseApproachqsy = q/s
Phase 1Road A40012500.320
Phase 2Road B25010000.250
Y=0.320+0.250=0.570Y = 0.320 + 0.250 = 0.570

Step 2: Lost time

Lost time is not given; it is taken as 2 s per phase (start-up loss with an amber of 2 s) as in the usual Webster design, plus the all-red pedestrian period RR = 13 s. Since the 2 s lost time equals the amber, the displayed green equals the effective green.

L=(0.0+2.0)+(0.0+2.0)+13=17.0 sL = (0.0+2.0) + (0.0+2.0) + 13 = 17.0\ \text{s}

Step 3: Optimum cycle time (Webster)

C0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(17.0)+51−0.570=70.9 sC_0 = \frac{1.5L + 5}{1 - Y} = \frac{1.5(17.0) + 5}{1 - 0.570} = 70.9\ \text{s}

Adopt C = 75 s.

Step 4: Green times

Total effective green =C−L=75−17.0=58.0= C - L = 75 - 17.0 = 58.0 s, divided in proportion to yy:

g1=yY(C−L)=0.3200.570(58.0)=32.6 sg_{1} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.320}{0.570}(58.0) = 32.6\ \text{s} g2=yY(C−L)=0.2500.570(58.0)=25.4 sg_{2} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.250}{0.570}(58.0) = 25.4\ \text{s}

Displayed green G=g+G = g + start-up loss (so that ∑G+∑I+R=C\sum G + \sum I + R = C):

PhaseEffective g (s)Start-up loss (s)Green G (s)Amber (s)
Phase 132.60.0332
Phase 225.40.0252

Check: 33 + 2 + 25 + 2 + 13 = 75 s.

Phase diagram

|     P1 green 33      | A2|   P2 green 25   | A2|  R 13  |
  • 2075 Asoj · 8 marks

What are the basic requirements of intersection at grade? Mention the importance of street lighting.

Answer

Basic requirements of an intersection at grade

  1. Safety first: reduce the number and severity of conflict points; give drivers clear sight of each other (sight triangle, IRC:66 and IRC:SP:41).
  2. Adequate capacity: the junction must carry the design hour volume of all movements without long delays.
  3. Simple, clear layout: drivers should understand the movements at once; avoid complex or multiple-road junctions; avoid skew (angle between roads should be about 90 degrees, not less than 60 degrees).
  4. Minimum conflict area: keep the paved area small and channelise movements with islands, so vehicles cannot wander.
  5. Good visibility: approach sight distance and sight triangles should be free of obstructions.
  6. Separation of conflicts by space (islands, channelisation), by time (signals) or by level (grade separation).
  7. Suitable geometry: correct approach gradients (flat, not more than about 4 percent), corner radii for the design vehicle, adequate turning lanes and pedestrian facilities.
  8. Proper traffic control devices: signs, markings, signals or rotary where needed.
  9. Pedestrians and cyclists need crossings, refuge and signal time.
  10. Economy: the cost of land, construction and operation should match the benefit.
  11. Drainage and lighting for safe all-weather and night use.

Importance of street lighting

  • It improves night visibility so that drivers see the road, obstacles, pedestrians and other vehicles in time to stop.
  • It reduces crashes and the severity of crashes at intersections, curves, bridges, and pedestrian crossings.
  • It improves personal security and reduces crime in urban areas.
  • It increases the capacity and speed of the road after dark by raising the confidence of the driver.
  • It helps traffic flow and the economic life of commercial areas (night shopping, tourism).
  • It gives guidance to the driver on road alignment, junctions and the edge of the pavement, and it enhances the look of the city.
  • 2075 Asoj · 8 marks

Explain different types of traffic islands? How accident study is carried out?

Answer

Types of traffic islands

  1. Channelising islands: triangular or teardrop islands that guide vehicles into definite paths and prevent wrong movements, usually at the junction of a minor road with a major road.
  2. Dividing (separating) islands / medians: separate opposing traffic flows on the approaches of a junction or a divided road and reduce head-on conflicts.
  3. Pedestrian refuge islands: safe place in the middle of the carriageway for pedestrians to wait while crossing. At least 1.5 m wide (preferably 2.0 m) and 1.2 to 1.5 m long.
  4. Rotary (central) island: the central island of a roundabout around which vehicles circulate.
  5. Splitter islands: at the entry of a rotary on each approach, to keep traffic on its own side and reduce the speed.
  6. Traffic control islands: for signs, signals and luminaires.
  7. Loading and bus-stop islands.

Islands are made of kerbed concrete or masonry with a mountable or barrier kerb, painted with reflective markings; the nose is offset about 0.5 m from the edge of the carriageway (IRC:SP:41).

How an accident study is carried out

  1. Collection of data: the police report at the site records date, time, location, vehicles, persons, injuries, weather, road condition and cause. IRC:53 specifies standard forms (A-1 for the on-site report and A-4 for the full record). Data come from police stations, hospitals, insurance firms and road agencies; Nepal Traffic Police and the DoR keep the records.
  2. Storing and analysis: data are coded and stored (database/GIS). Analysis includes tabulation by year, month, time of day, location, vehicle type, age and cause.
  3. Condition diagram: a to-scale plan of the site showing geometry, signs and the location of the crash.
  4. Collision diagram: a schematic of the crashes in the site over a period (3 years), with arrows showing the paths of vehicles, using standard symbols; it helps recognise patterns.
  5. Spot (location) map: pins or GIS points showing crash locations; clusters identify black spots.
  6. Statistical measures: crash rate per 100 million vehicle-km, per 10,000 vehicles or per 100,000 population; severity indices; comparison with the average.
  7. Site investigation and cause analysis: field visit, traffic observation and conflict study; checking sight distances, friction and signs.
  8. Remedial measures: engineering, education and enforcement; their cost-benefit evaluation and priority.
  9. Follow-up (before/after study): monitoring to see if the measures work.
  • 2075 Asoj · 8 marks

Two vehicles A and B approaching at right angle. Vehicle A from West and vehicle B from south collides each other. After the collision, vehicle A skids in 49° N of W and vehicle B skids 27° E of N. The initial skid distance of vehicle A and B are 37 m and 19 m respectively before collision. If weight of vehicle A is 4 tonne and weight of vehicle B is 6 tonne. The skid distances after collision for vehicle A is 15 m and for vehicle B is 36 m. calculate the initial speeds of the vehicles if the average skid resistance of the pavement is found to be 0.55.

Answer

A collision on a flat road is solved by (i) finding each vehicle's speed just after impact from its post-collision skid, (ii) applying conservation of linear momentum as a vector equation to get the speeds just before impact, and (iii) adding back the energy lost in the pre-collision skid.

Given: WA=4W_A = 4 t, WB=6W_B = 6 t, f=0.55f = 0.55, g=9.81 m/s2g = 9.81\ \text{m/s}^2. Pre-collision skids: dA=37d_A = 37 m, dB=19d_B = 19 m. Post-collision skids: dA′=15d_A' = 15 m, dB′=36d_B' = 36 m.

Vehicle A (4 t) comes from the West (moving East). Vehicle B (6 t) comes from the South (moving North). After impact A slides 49 degrees North of West and B slides 27 degrees East of North.

where θ\theta is the bearing from North, clockwise: θA=90∘\theta_A = 90^\circ, θB=0∘\theta_B = 0^\circ (travel directions) and θA′=311∘\theta_A' = 311^\circ, θB′=27∘\theta_B' = 27^\circ (skid directions after impact).

   before impact          after impact
   A: bearing 90 deg       A': bearing 311 deg
   B: bearing 0 deg       B': bearing 27 deg
   (bearing measured clockwise from North)

Step 1: Speeds just after collision

From work-energy, v′=2gfd′v' = \sqrt{2 g f d'}:

vA′=2(9.81)(0.55)(15)=12.72 m/svB′=2(9.81)(0.55)(36)=19.71 m/s\begin{aligned} v_A' &= \sqrt{2(9.81)(0.55)(15)} = 12.72\ \text{m/s}\\ v_B' &= \sqrt{2(9.81)(0.55)(36)} = 19.71\ \text{m/s} \end{aligned}

Step 2: Momentum balance (vector form)

Take xx = East and yy = North, and let uA,uBu_A, u_B be the speeds just before impact. Weights are proportional to masses, so they can be used directly.

WAuAsin⁡θA+WBuBsin⁡θB=WAvA′sin⁡θA′+WBvB′sin⁡θB′WAuAcos⁡θA+WBuBcos⁡θB=WAvA′cos⁡θA′+WBvB′cos⁡θB′\begin{aligned} W_A u_A \sin\theta_A + W_B u_B \sin\theta_B &= W_A v_A' \sin\theta_A' + W_B v_B' \sin\theta_B' \\ W_A u_A \cos\theta_A + W_B u_B \cos\theta_B &= W_A v_A' \cos\theta_A' + W_B v_B' \cos\theta_B' \end{aligned}

Substituting the numbers:

4 uA(1.0000)+6 uB(0.0000)=4(12.723)(−0.7547)+6(19.710)(0.4540)=15.2814 uA(0.0000)+6 uB(1.0000)=4(12.723)(0.6561)+6(19.710)(0.8910)=138.756\begin{aligned} 4\,u_A(1.0000) + 6\,u_B(0.0000) &= 4(12.723)(-0.7547) + 6(19.710)(0.4540) = 15.281 \\ 4\,u_A(0.0000) + 6\,u_B(1.0000) &= 4(12.723)(0.6561) + 6(19.710)(0.8910) = 138.756 \end{aligned}

Solving: uA=3.82 m/s=13.8 km/hu_A = 3.82\ \text{m/s} = 13.8\ \text{km/h} and uB=23.13 m/s=83.3 km/hu_B = 23.13\ \text{m/s} = 83.3\ \text{km/h} at the instant of impact.

Step 3: Original speeds (before the pre-collision skid)

v0=u2+2gfdv_0 = \sqrt{u^2 + 2 g f d}:

vA=(3.82)2+2(9.81)(0.55)(37)=20.34 m/svB=(23.13)2+2(9.81)(0.55)(19)=27.20 m/s\begin{aligned} v_A &= \sqrt{(3.82)^2 + 2(9.81)(0.55)(37)} = 20.34\ \text{m/s}\\ v_B &= \sqrt{(23.13)^2 + 2(9.81)(0.55)(19)} = 27.20\ \text{m/s} \end{aligned}

Answer: original speed of vehicle AA = 73.2 km/h and of vehicle BB = 97.9 km/h (speeds at impact: 13.8 and 83.3 km/h).

  • 2075 Asoj · 8 marks

A four-legged right angled intersection is to be signalized with a fixed time 2-phase signal. The design hour flow and saturation flow are as under:
North (N)South (S)East (E)West (W)
Design hour flow900500800700
Saturation flow2500200032003000
The lost time is 2 seconds per phase due to starting delays and amber time for north-south and east-west are 3 seconds and 4 seconds respectively. Determine the optimum cycle time. Allocate the green times to the two phases.

Answer

Phase 1 = North-South, Phase 2 = East-West.

Step 1: Flow ratios

Flow ratio y=q/sy = q/s for each approach; the larger value in a phase is the critical one.

PhaseApproachqsy = q/s
Phase 1North90025000.360 (critical)
Phase 1South50020000.250
Phase 2East80032000.250 (critical)
Phase 2West70030000.233
Y=0.360+0.250=0.610Y = 0.360 + 0.250 = 0.610

Step 2: Lost time

Lost time per phase = start-up loss 2 s + amber (3 s for N-S, 4 s for E-W).

L=(2.0+3.0)+(2.0+4.0)=11.0 sL = (2.0+3.0) + (2.0+4.0) = 11.0\ \text{s}

Step 3: Optimum cycle time (Webster)

C0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(11.0)+51−0.610=55.1 sC_0 = \frac{1.5L + 5}{1 - Y} = \frac{1.5(11.0) + 5}{1 - 0.610} = 55.1\ \text{s}

Adopt C = 60 s.

Step 4: Green times

Total effective green =C−L=60−11.0=49.0= C - L = 60 - 11.0 = 49.0 s, divided in proportion to yy:

g1=yY(C−L)=0.3600.610(49.0)=28.9 sg_{1} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.360}{0.610}(49.0) = 28.9\ \text{s} g2=yY(C−L)=0.2500.610(49.0)=20.1 sg_{2} = \frac{y}{Y}(C-L) = \frac{0.250}{0.610}(49.0) = 20.1\ \text{s}

Displayed green G=g+G = g + start-up loss (so that ∑G+∑I+R=C\sum G + \sum I + R = C):

PhaseEffective g (s)Start-up loss (s)Green G (s)Amber (s)
Phase 128.92.0313
Phase 220.12.0224

Check: 31 + 3 + 22 + 4 = 60 s.

Phase diagram

|       P1 green 31       | A3 |   P2 green 22   |  A4  |
  • 2074 Asoj · 8 marks

What are the basic requirements of intersection at grade? Describe grade separated intersection with its advantages and disadvantages.

Answer

Basic requirements of an intersection at grade

  1. Safety first: reduce the number and severity of conflict points; give drivers clear sight of each other (sight triangle, IRC:66 and IRC:SP:41).
  2. Adequate capacity: the junction must carry the design hour volume of all movements without long delays.
  3. Simple, clear layout: drivers should understand the movements at once; avoid complex or multiple-road junctions; avoid skew (angle between roads should be about 90 degrees, not less than 60 degrees).
  4. Minimum conflict area: keep the paved area small and channelise movements with islands, so vehicles cannot wander.
  5. Good visibility: approach sight distance and sight triangles should be free of obstructions.
  6. Separation of conflicts by space (islands, channelisation), by time (signals) or by level (grade separation).
  7. Suitable geometry: correct approach gradients (flat, not more than about 4 percent), corner radii for the design vehicle, adequate turning lanes and pedestrian facilities.
  8. Proper traffic control devices: signs, markings, signals or rotary where needed.
  9. Pedestrians and cyclists need crossings, refuge and signal time.
  10. Economy: the cost of land, construction and operation should match the benefit.
  11. Drainage and lighting for safe all-weather and night use.

Grade-separated intersection

Types

  • Overpass / underpass (simple flyover or underpass) with no connection between the roads; used for crossings of major roads, railways and pedestrians.
  • Trumpet interchange: for three-leg (T) junctions; one loop ramp.
  • Diamond interchange: four-leg junction; four ramps, two at-grade junctions on the minor road; compact and economical.
  • Cloverleaf interchange: four loops for left (right in left-hand traffic) turns; all turns are free-flowing, large land need and weaving problems.
  • Partial cloverleaf, directional (stack) and rotary interchange: used for high volumes; stack has fully directional ramps and is the most expensive.
   Overpass            Diamond
   ---------- main      \   |   /
   ====//==== road       \  |  /
     /  \ minor        ---+----+---
   cross road           /  |  \

Advantages

  • Removes crossing conflicts, so fewer and less severe crashes.
  • Greater capacity and higher speeds; free-flow without stopping.
  • Reduces delay, fuel use, noise and vehicle emission over time.
  • Gives safe pedestrian crossing if an underpass/overbridge is included.

Disadvantages / limitations

  • High cost of land and construction, and often needs a long construction period.
  • Large land requirement and displacement of buildings.
  • Needs space for ramps and may harm the appearance of the city.
  • Long detour for some turning vehicles; weaving on short sections; heavy maintenance.
  • Not justified at low volumes (usually considered when volume exceeds roughly 10,000-15,000 PCU per hour at the junction, IRC:92).
  • 2074 Asoj · 8 marks

Spot speed observation at a particular link provides the following data, calculate maximum speed limit, minimum speed limit, design speed and modal speed for regulation of traffic.
Speed range (kmph)Frequency
6-101
10-144
14-187
18-2220
22-2644
26-3080
30-3482
34-3879
38-4249
42-4636
46-5026
50-549
54-5810
58-623

Answer

Speed limits for regulation are read from the cumulative frequency distribution (IRC:SP:41 / standard speed-study practice): the 85th percentile speed is the maximum (upper) speed limit, the 15th percentile speed is the minimum (lower) speed limit, and the 98th percentile speed is the design speed. The modal speed is the speed with the highest frequency.

Total observations N=450N = 450.

Speed class (km/h)FrequencyCumulative frequencyCumulative %
6-10110.2
10-14451.1
14-187122.7
18-2220327.1
22-26447616.9
26-308015634.7
30-348223852.9
34-387931770.4
38-424936681.3
42-463640289.3
46-502642895.1
50-54943797.1
54-581044799.3
58-623450100.0

By interpolation within the class, vp=L+(pN/100−Fprev)f hv_p = L + \dfrac{(pN/100 - F_{prev})}{f}\,h:

Maximum speed limit (85th percentile)

v85=42+382.5−36636(4)=43.8 km/hv_{85} = 42 + \frac{382.5 - 366}{36}(4) = 43.8\ \text{km/h}

Minimum speed limit (15th percentile)

v15=22+67.5−3244(4)=25.2 km/hv_{15} = 22 + \frac{67.5 - 32}{44}(4) = 25.2\ \text{km/h}

Design speed (98th percentile)

v98=54+441.0−43710(4)=55.6 km/hv_{98} = 54 + \frac{441.0 - 437}{10}(4) = 55.6\ \text{km/h}

Modal speed

The modal class is 30-34 (f = 82), with the class before f0=80f_0 = 80 and after f2=79f_2 = 79:

vmode=L+f1−f02f1−f0−f2 h=30+82−802(82)−80−79(4)=31.6 km/hv_{mode} = L + \frac{f_1 - f_0}{2f_1 - f_0 - f_2}\,h = 30 + \frac{82-80}{2(82)-80-79}(4) = 31.6\ \text{km/h}

Answer: maximum speed limit = 43.8 km/h, minimum speed limit = 25.2 km/h, design speed = 55.6 km/h, modal speed = 31.6 km/h. (In practice limits are rounded to 45, 25 and 55 km/h.)

  • 2074 Asoj · 8 marks

Describe highway capacity. Explain the factors which affect capacity and level of service.

Answer

Highway capacity

Capacity of a road is the maximum number of vehicles (or PCUs) that can pass a given point or section of a lane or road in one direction (or both directions on a two-lane road) during a given time period (normally one hour) under the prevailing roadway, traffic and control conditions (HCM definition; IRC:106 for urban roads).

Types of capacity:

  1. Basic capacity: the maximum number of passenger cars that can pass in a lane under ideal (best possible) roadway and traffic conditions.
  2. Possible capacity: the maximum number that can pass under the actual (prevailing) roadway and traffic conditions, i.e. after adjusting the basic capacity for lane width, shoulder, gradient, heavy vehicles, etc.
  3. Practical capacity (design capacity): the maximum number that can pass without unreasonable delay or restriction to the drivers' freedom to manoeuvre, at the chosen level of service. It is about 75-80 percent of the possible capacity (design service volume at LOS B for urban roads in IRC:106, and at LOS B for rural roads in IRC:64).

Level of service

LOSOperating conditionv/c (typical)
AFree flow, very low volume, high speed, driver free to choose speed0.0-0.3
BStable flow, some restriction of speed and manoeuvre0.3-0.5
CStable flow, speed and manoeuvre controlled by traffic0.5-0.7
DApproaching unstable flow, little freedom, small increase in flow causes large drop in speed0.7-0.85
EUnstable flow at or near capacity, speeds low and uniform0.85-1.0
FForced, breakdown flow; stop-and-go; flow below capacityvariable

IRC:106-1990 (urban roads) and IRC:64-1990 (rural roads) give design service volumes, generally at LOS B or C; Nepal Road Standard 2070 also designs for LOS B-C.

Factors affecting capacity and level of service

  1. Roadway (geometric) factors: lane width, lateral clearance (shoulder, kerb), number of lanes, horizontal and vertical alignment, gradient, sight distance, median presence. Narrow lanes (below 3.65 m) reduce capacity.
  2. Traffic factors: composition (share of buses, trucks and slow vehicles), directional distribution of traffic, lane distribution and the presence of pedestrians and cyclists.
  3. Control factors: signals (green time, cycle length, progression), signs, speed limits, and parking restrictions.
  4. Environmental factors: weather (rain, fog), lighting at night, surface condition, side friction (pedestrians, bus stops, parking and roadside activities).
  5. Driver factors: familiarity, behaviour (urban commuters versus tourists), and lane discipline.
  6. Operating (service) measures: speed and travel time, freedom to manoeuvre, comfort, interruptions and safety, v/c ratio, density.
  7. Peaking: the peak hour factor (PHF) and the variation of flow over time.
  • 2074 Asoj · 8 marks

Assuming linear Speed-density relationship of V=60−0.43KV = 60 - 0.43K a) Draw V-K, V-Q and Q-K diagram showing critical value b) Find the saturation flow? c) Find speed and density at flow of 1000 veh/hr

Answer

For the linear model V=Vf−bKV = V_f - bK with Vf=60V_f = 60 km/h and b=0.43b = 0.43, the jam density is where V=0V = 0:

kj=600.43=139.5 veh/kmk_j = \frac{60}{0.43} = 139.5\ \text{veh/km}

The flow is Q=VK=60K−0.43K2Q = VK = 60K - 0.43K^2, so the critical (maximum-flow) values are at dQ/dK=0dQ/dK = 0:

Km=kj2=69.8 veh/kmVm=Vf2=30 km/hQmax=Vfkj4=60×139.54=2093 veh/h\begin{aligned} K_m &= \frac{k_j}{2} = 69.8\ \text{veh/km}\\ V_m &= \frac{V_f}{2} = 30\ \text{km/h}\\ Q_{max} &= \frac{V_f k_j}{4} = \frac{60 \times 139.5}{4} = 2093\ \text{veh/h} \end{aligned}

(a) Diagrams with critical values

v-k diagram (straight line)
 v (km/h)
   60 |*
      |   *
   30 |- - - *   <- at q max
      |         *
      +-----------*--- k (veh/km)
      0    69.8     139.5

q-k diagram (parabola)
 q (veh/h)
2093.0 |        _ * _   <- q max
      |     *         *
      |   *             *
      +--*-------|-------*-- k
      0        69.8       139.5

v-q diagram (half parabola)
 v (km/h)
   60 |*
      |  *
   30 |- - - *  <- q max (nose)
      |     *
      |   *   (congested branch)
      +--------|--------- q (veh/h)
      0       2093.0

(b) Saturation flow

The saturation flow is the maximum flow (capacity) at the critical density:

Saturation flow = QmaxQ_{max} = 2093 veh/h

(c) Speed and density at a flow of 1000 veh/h

0.43K2−60K+1000=0⇒K=60±602−4(0.43)(1000)2(0.43)=60±43.360.860.43K^2 - 60K + 1000 = 0 \Rightarrow K = \frac{60 \pm \sqrt{60^2 - 4(0.43)(1000)}}{2(0.43)} = \frac{60 \pm 43.36}{0.86} K1=19.35 veh/km,K2=120.18 veh/kmK_1 = 19.35\ \text{veh/km},\quad K_2 = 120.18\ \text{veh/km}
  • Uncongested: K=19.35K = 19.35 veh/km, V=60−0.43(19.35)=51.68V = 60 - 0.43(19.35) = 51.68 km/h.
  • Congested: K=120.18K = 120.18 veh/km, V=8.32V = 8.32 km/h.

Answer: at 1000 veh/h the speed is 51.7 km/h at a density of 19.4 veh/km (stable flow); in congested flow it is 8.3 km/h at 120.2 veh/km.

  • 2073 Shrawan · 8 marks

Define traffic engineering. Explain road user characteristics and human-vehicle-environment system.

Answer

Definition of traffic engineering

Traffic engineering is the branch of transportation engineering that deals with the planning, geometric design, operation and control of roads, their networks, terminals and adjacent land use, so that people and goods move safely, quickly, comfortably, economically and with least harm to the environment. (Institute of Transportation Engineers definition, as used in Khanna and Justo.)

Its scope covers traffic characteristics, traffic studies (volume, speed, O-D, parking, accident), traffic regulation and control, geometric design, traffic signs, markings and signals, road lighting, and traffic planning and management, including the Nepal Motor Vehicles and Transport Management Act and the Department of Roads (DoR) rules for enforcement.

Road user characteristics

  1. Physical: vision (acuity, field of vision, colour vision, glare), hearing, strength and agility. They fix sign sizes, letter heights, lighting, sight distances and footpath gradients.
  2. Mental and psychological: attention, judgement, emotional stability and attitude. They influence overtaking decisions, gap acceptance and compliance with signals.
  3. Reaction time (PIEV): about 2.5 s is used for stopping sight distance, headlight sight distance and intersection sight distance (IRC:SP:23, IRC:66, Nepal Road Standard 2070).
  4. Pedestrian characteristics: walking speed about 1.2 m/s (IRC:103 and IRC:93 use 1.2 m/s; slower, about 0.9 m/s, for children and the elderly); space needed about 0.5-0.75 m² per person; they need footpaths, crossings, refuge islands and signal time.
  5. Cyclists: speed 10-25 km/h, need separate lanes and safe turning at intersections.
  6. Age and gender, fatigue, intoxication and disability: these add to variation, so design uses the 85th-percentile or a conservative value (for example the 15th-percentile pedestrian speed for crossing time).
  7. Behaviour and compliance: lane discipline, helmet and seat-belt use, jaywalking and parking habits vary by country and must be reflected in the design and enforcement plan (in Nepal mixed traffic is common).
  8. Mixed traffic: in Nepal slow and fast vehicles share the carriageway, so wider shoulders and segregation are required.

Human-vehicle-environment system

The traffic stream is the combined behaviour of three interacting elements: the Human (road user), the Vehicle and the Environment (road and surroundings). Safe and efficient flow needs all three to match.

        +--------------+
        |    HUMAN     |  driver, pedestrian,
        | (perception, |  cyclist, passenger
        |   reaction)  |
        +------+-------+
       controls|    ^ feedback
               v    |
        +------+----+--+      +--------------------+
        |   VEHICLE    |<---->|    ENVIRONMENT     |
        | size, power, |      | road geometry,     |
        | brakes, load |      | surface, signs,    |
        +--------------+      | weather, lighting  |
                              +--------------------+
  • Human: receives information (mostly visual), decides and acts (steering, braking). Errors in perception, judgement or reaction are the main cause of crashes (about 80-90 percent involve human error).
  • Vehicle: its dimensions, weight, power, braking and visibility set the road width, gradient, curve radius and pavement strength required.
  • Environment: road geometry, surface friction, traffic control devices, lighting, weather and adjacent land use affect how the driver sees and responds.

A mismatch in any one (for example a fast vehicle, a sharp curve and a wet surface) causes crashes, so design must fit the "design driver" and "design vehicle" to the road.

  • 2073 Shrawan · 8 marks

What is the importance of parking studies? Describe different types of parking.

Answer

Importance of parking studies

Parking studies collect and analyse data on the demand and supply of parking. They are important because:

  • Vehicles spend most of their life parked, so the city must give them space; the supply of parking affects the economic life of the central area and the use of public transport.
  • Planned parking keeps the carriageway free for moving traffic; a lack of parking space forces vehicles onto the road.
  • Parking studies give the demand (accumulation, duration, turnover) needed to plan size, location, fees and regulation of parking.
  • They give the parking inventory (number, location and type of bays), the demand (accumulation, duration, turnover, parking load and index) and the characteristics of parkers (trip purpose, walking distance).
  • They help to fix parking fees and time limits, to decide where to ban parking, and to size new off-street facilities.
  • They show the gap between demand and supply and its effect on congestion and crashes.

Types of parking

Parking is classified as on-street (on the carriageway edge) and off-street (away from the carriageway).

A. On-street parking (vehicles park along the kerb):

TypeArrangementRemarks
ParallelVehicles parked along the kerb, bay about 5.0-5.5 m x 2.0-2.5 mLeast road width needed, safest, but fewest cars per length
30 degree angleFront end towards the kerbModerate capacity, easy entry
45 degree angleFront in or back inGood capacity, easy to park
60 degree angleFront inHigh capacity, needs wider bay
90 degree (right angle)Perpendicular to the kerbMost vehicles per length, most road width, high risk to through traffic
 Parallel            45 degree           90 degree
 ______________     \ \ \ \ \          | | | | | |
 [car] [car] [car]   \_\_\_\_\_         |_|_|_|_|_|
 ========= kerb      ===== kerb          ===== kerb

B. Off-street parking:

  • Surface parking lots: open areas near markets or terminals; low cost, require land.
  • Multi-storey (multi-level) parking: several floors; best use of costly land, high construction cost; ramp or mechanical access.
  • Underground parking: below buildings or public squares; keeps surface free, expensive.
  • Mechanical or automated parking: lifts and stackers, used where land is very scarce.
  • Park-and-ride facilities: at city edges, linked to public transport.

Nepal practice: on-street parking is regulated by the Metropolitan/Municipal offices and Traffic Police (parallel parking on one side, paid parking zones), and off-street parking is required in new buildings by the Nepal National Building Code (NBC 206 / municipal building bye-laws).

  • 2073 Shrawan · 8 marks

A vehicle hits a bridge abutment at a speed estimated by investigations as 20kmph. Skid marks of 30 m on the pavement (f=0.35) followed by skid marks of 60 m on the gravel shoulder approaching the abutment (f=0.50). What was the initial speed of vehicle?

Answer

The vehicle skidded 30 m on the pavement, left the pavement and skidded another 60 m on the gravel shoulder, and then hit the abutment at 20 km/h. Working backwards by the work-energy equation v12=v22+2gfdv_1^2 = v_2^2 + 2gfd over each stretch:

 start -> [ 30 m pavement f=0.35 ] -> [ 60 m gravel f=0.50 ] -> abutment
 v0                                  v1                        20 km/h

Data: vabutment=20v_{abutment} = 20 km/h =5.556= 5.556 m/s.

Step 1: Speed at the start of the gravel shoulder

v1=va2+2gf2d2=(5.556)2+2(9.81)(0.50)(60)=24.889 m/s=89.6 km/hv_1 = \sqrt{v_a^2 + 2 g f_2 d_2} = \sqrt{(5.556)^2 + 2(9.81)(0.50)(60)} = 24.889\ \text{m/s} = 89.6\ \text{km/h}

Step 2: Initial speed at the start of the pavement skid

v0=v12+2gf1d1=(24.889)2+2(9.81)(0.35)(30)=28.731 m/sv_0 = \sqrt{v_1^2 + 2 g f_1 d_1} = \sqrt{(24.889)^2 + 2(9.81)(0.35)(30)} = 28.731\ \text{m/s}

Answer: initial speed of the vehicle = 28.73 m/s = 103.4 km/h.

(Check with the IRC/Indian field formula v=254(f1d1+f2d2)+va2=254(0.35×30+0.5×60)+202=103.4v = \sqrt{254(f_1d_1+f_2d_2)+v_a^2} = \sqrt{254(0.35\times30 + 0.5\times60) + 20^2} = 103.4 km/h.)

  • 2072 Chaitra · 8 marks

Describe various types of traffic control devices. Write down the advantages and disadvantages of traffic signal.

Answer

Types of traffic control devices

  1. Traffic signs: regulatory, warning and informatory.
  2. Road markings: pavement markings (centre line, edge line, lane lines, stop line, zebra crossing, arrows, hatching), kerb markings and object markers (IRC:35).
  3. Traffic signals: fixed-time, vehicle-actuated and area-wide (coordinated) control, pedestrian signals, flashing beacons.
  4. Other devices: traffic islands, speed breakers/humps (IRC:99), delineators, guard rails, barricades and variable message signs.
TypePurposeShape and colour
Regulatory (mandatory)Tell the driver what to do or not do (stop, give way, no entry, speed limit, no parking)Circular, red border, white background; STOP is an octagon, GIVE WAY an inverted triangle
Cautionary (warning)Warn of a hazard ahead (curve, steep descent, junction, school, narrow bridge)Equilateral triangle, red border, white background, black symbol
Informatory (guide)Give directions, place names, distances, facilities (hospital, parking, fuel)Rectangular; blue (facilities) or green (direction on highways) background, white letters

Subdivisions: informatory signs include direction signs, place identification, route markers, facility information and parking signs.

Placement: within the cone of clear vision, 3 m lateral clearance from the edge, with a mounting height of 2.0-2.5 m above the ground; legends in a size that can be read at the speed of the road.

  1. Carriageway (pavement) markings
    • Centre line: separates the two directions (broken white or yellow, continuous at no-overtaking zones).
    • Lane lines: broken white lines that separate lanes in the same direction.
    • Edge lines: continuous white lines marking the carriageway edge.
    • No-overtaking (barrier) lines: continuous (single or double) yellow/white lines at sharp curves and crests.
    • Stop line and give-way line: at signals and intersections.
    • Pedestrian crossings: zebra (black and white bars).
    • Arrows, words and symbols: direction arrows, "STOP", "SLOW", "SCHOOL".
    • Hatching and chevrons: painted islands, approach to obstructions.
  2. Kerb markings: black/yellow or white bands on kerbs to show no parking, no stopping.
  3. Object markers: painted black-white or yellow-black bands on poles, abutments and piers.
  4. Parking markings: bay outlines.

Markings must be visible at night (thermoplastic paint with glass beads), durable, skid resistant and uniform.

Types of traffic signals

  • Fixed-time (pre-timed): fixed cycle and splits; cheap, suited to steady flows.
  • Vehicle-actuated: detectors change the green time according to demand.
  • Coordinated/area control: linked signals give a green wave (progressive flow).
  • Pedestrian signals and flashing beacons.

Advantages of traffic signals

  • Give orderly movement of traffic and reduce right-angle (crossing) crashes.
  • Increase the capacity of an intersection that is not suitable for a rotary.
  • Allow pedestrians to cross safely.
  • Can be coordinated to give continuous (progressive) flow on arterial roads.
  • Give right of way to heavy flow, and can be modified in timing as the volume changes.

Disadvantages

  • Rear-end crashes and delay (stop-start) at low volumes may increase.
  • Initial and maintenance costs, with power or battery dependence.
  • Failure of power or equipment can cause total chaos.
  • Red-light violation, driver impatience and extra fuel use.
  • Poor timing causes large delays and queues.
  • 2072 Chaitra · 8 marks

What are the importance of street lighting? Describe the factors affecting street light design.

Answer

Importance of street lighting

  • It improves night visibility so that drivers see the road, obstacles, pedestrians and other vehicles in time to stop.
  • It reduces crashes and the severity of crashes at intersections, curves, bridges, and pedestrian crossings.
  • It improves personal security and reduces crime in urban areas.
  • It increases the capacity and speed of the road after dark by raising the confidence of the driver.
  • It helps traffic flow and the economic life of commercial areas (night shopping, tourism).
  • It gives guidance to the driver on road alignment, junctions and the edge of the pavement, and it enhances the look of the city.

Factors affecting street light design

  1. Type of road and traffic volume: arterial, collector or local street decides the illumination level (lux) and uniformity (about 30 lux on important roads, 15 lux on secondary, 8 lux on residential roads in Indian practice).
  2. Mounting height (H): usually 8-10 m on main roads, 6-7.5 m on minor roads; higher poles give more uniform light and reduce glare but need more power.
  3. Spacing (S): typically 3 to 5 times the mounting height; the spacing-to-height ratio controls uniformity.
  4. Lamp type and luminous flux: LED, high-pressure sodium or mercury; wattage and lumen output.
  5. Luminaire type, light distribution and tilt (cut-off, semi-cut-off, non-cut-off).
  6. Arrangement of the lamps: single side, staggered, opposite, central (median) or suspended.
  7. Lateral offset or overhang: the position of the post from the carriageway edge (about 0.6 m minimum clear from the kerb; 1.5 m or more on high-speed roads).
  8. Uniformity ratio: minimum-to-average illuminance, about 0.3 to 0.4.
  9. Glare control, maintenance factor (about 0.7-0.8), cost, local environment (trees, dust), and power availability.
  • 2072 Chaitra · 8 marks

Assuming a linear speed-density relationship, the mean free speed is observed to be 80 km/h near zero density and the corresponding jam density is 130 veh/km. Assume that the average length of vehicles is 6 m. i) Write down the speed-density and flow-density equations ii) Compute speed and density corresponding to flow of 1000 veh/hr. iii) Compute the average headways, spacing, clearance and gaps when the flow is maximum

Answer

(i) Speed-density and flow-density equations

For a linear (Greenshields) relation, speed falls from the free-flow speed vfv_f at zero density to zero at jam density kjk_j:

v=vf(1−kkj)=80(1−k130)=80−0.6154 kv = v_f\left(1-\frac{k}{k_j}\right) = 80\left(1-\frac{k}{130}\right) = 80 - 0.6154\,k

Since q=v kq = v\,k:

q=vf k(1−kkj)=80 k−0.6154 k2q = v_f\,k\left(1-\frac{k}{k_j}\right) = 80\,k - 0.6154\,k^2

Critical values and diagrams

Setting dq/dk=0dq/dk = 0 gives km=kj/2k_m = k_j/2, vm=vf/2v_m = v_f/2 and qmax=vfkj/4q_{max} = v_f k_j/4:

km=130/2=65 veh/kmvm=80/2=40 km/hqmax=80×1304=2600 veh/h\begin{aligned} k_m &= 130/2 = 65\ \text{veh/km}\\ v_m &= 80/2 = 40\ \text{km/h}\\ q_{max} &= \frac{80 \times 130}{4} = 2600\ \text{veh/h} \end{aligned}
v-k diagram (straight line)
 v (km/h)
   80 |*
      |   *
   40 |- - - *   <- at q max
      |         *
      +-----------*--- k (veh/km)
      0    65     130

q-k diagram (parabola)
 q (veh/h)
 2600 |        _ * _   <- q max
      |     *         *
      |   *             *
      +--*-------|-------*-- k
      0        65       130

v-q diagram (half parabola)
 v (km/h)
   80 |*
      |  *
   40 |- - - *  <- q max (nose)
      |     *
      |   *   (congested branch)
      +--------|--------- q (veh/h)
      0       2600

(ii) Speed and density for a flow of 1000 veh/h

Substitute in q=vfk−(vf/kj)k2q = v_f k - (v_f/k_j)k^2:

0.6154k2−80k+1000=0⇒k=80±802−4(0.6154)(1000)2(0.6154)0.6154k^2 - 80k + 1000 = 0 \quad\Rightarrow\quad k = \frac{80 \pm \sqrt{80^2 - 4(0.6154)(1000)}}{2(0.6154)} k1=14.01 veh/km,k2=115.99 veh/kmk_1 = 14.01\ \text{veh/km},\quad k_2 = 115.99\ \text{veh/km}
  • Uncongested (stable) state: k=14.0k = 14.0 veh/km and v=80(1−14.01/130)=71.4v = 80(1-14.01/130) = 71.4 km/h.
  • Congested (forced) state: k=116.0k = 116.0 veh/km and v=8.6v = 8.6 km/h.

Answer: for 1000 veh/h, speed = 71.4 km/h at density = 14.0 veh/km (stable flow); the congested alternative is 8.6 km/h at 116.0 veh/km.

(iii) Headway, spacing, clearance and gap at maximum flow

At qmax=2600q_{max} = 2600 veh/h, km=65k_m = 65 veh/km, vm=40v_m = 40 km/h:

Average headway h=3600qmax=36002600=1.38 sAverage spacing s=1000km=100065=15.38 mClearance =s−L=15.38−6=9.38 mGap (time) =h−Lvm=1.38−611.111=0.84 s\begin{aligned} \text{Average headway}\ h &= \frac{3600}{q_{max}} = \frac{3600}{2600} = 1.38\ \text{s}\\ \text{Average spacing}\ s &= \frac{1000}{k_m} = \frac{1000}{65} = 15.38\ \text{m}\\ \text{Clearance}\ &= s - L = 15.38 - 6 = 9.38\ \text{m}\\ \text{Gap (time)}\ &= h - \frac{L}{v_m} = 1.38 - \frac{6}{11.111} = 0.84\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Answer: headway = 1.38 s, spacing = 15.38 m, clearance = 9.38 m, gap = 0.84 s.

  • 2072 Chaitra · 8 marks

The following data collected after the floating car method study for a section of road 25.5 km long during the floating car method study. Assuming the equivalency factor of 1, 2 and 3 for each car bus and truck respectively, Calculate the flow in per/hr journey speed and running speed in both direction of flow.
DirectionJourney time (min)Journey time (sec)Stopped delay (min)Stopped delay (sec)Opposite: CarOpposite: BusOpposite: TruckSame direction: OvertakingSame direction: Overtaken
N-S42512402431
S-N42115212323
N-S41013151242
S-N41415205161
N-S430145213233
S-N416115252122
N-S412118274252
S-N410155281311
N-S410113203223
S-N420150292143
N-S450142261322
S-N440135253311

Answer

In the floating car (moving observer) method, for each direction the flow is q=na+yta+twq = \dfrac{n_a + y}{t_a + t_w} where nan_a = vehicles met while running against the stream (in PCU), yy = vehicles overtaking the test car minus vehicles overtaken by it during the run with the stream, twt_w = journey time with the stream and tat_a = journey time against the stream. The mean stream journey time is tˉ=tw−y/q\bar t = t_w - y/q.

Data treatment: PCU factors car 1, bus 2, truck 3 are applied to the opposing counts (nan_a = cars + 2 buses + 3 trucks). Overtaking and overtaken counts are used as numbers of vehicles (types are not given). Section length L=25.5L = 25.5 km as given. Times are converted to seconds.

Data per trip (journey time, stopped delay in s; opposing in PCU)

N-S tripJourneyDelayOpposingOvertakingOvertaken
1265625631
2250632342
32701053333
4252784152
5250733223
62901023722
S-N tripJourneyDelayOpposingOvertakingOvertaken
1261653423
2254653361
3256753222
42501153911
52601103643
6280954011

Flow in the N-S direction

The vehicles met on the S-N trips form the N-S stream. Averages over 6 trips: na=35.67n_a = 35.67 PCU, ta=4.336t_a = 4.336 min, tw=4.381t_w = 4.381 min, y=1.00y = 1.00.

qNS=na+yta+tw=35.67+1.004.336+4.381=4.21 veh/min=252 veh/hq_{NS} = \frac{n_a + y}{t_a + t_w} = \frac{35.67 + 1.00}{4.336 + 4.381} = 4.21\ \text{veh/min} = 252\ \text{veh/h}

Flow in the S-N direction

Averages: na=37.00n_a = 37.00 PCU, ta=4.381t_a = 4.381 min, tw=4.336t_w = 4.336 min, y=0.83y = 0.83.

qSN=37.00+0.834.381+4.336=4.34 veh/min=260 veh/hq_{SN} = \frac{37.00 + 0.83}{4.381 + 4.336} = 4.34\ \text{veh/min} = 260\ \text{veh/h}

Journey time, journey speed and running speed

Mean stopped delay: N-S 1.342 min, S-N 1.458 min.

tˉNS=tw−yq=4.381−1.004.21=4.143 min,tˉSN=4.336−0.834.34=4.144 minVj=Ltˉ:Vj,NS=369.3 km/h, Vj,SN=369.2 km/hVr=Ltˉ−delay:Vr,NS=546.2 km/h, Vr,SN=569.7 km/h\begin{aligned} \bar t_{NS} &= t_w - \frac{y}{q} = 4.381 - \frac{1.00}{4.21} = 4.143\ \text{min}, & \bar t_{SN} &= 4.336 - \frac{0.83}{4.34} = 4.144\ \text{min}\\ V_j &= \frac{L}{\bar t}: & V_{j,NS} &= 369.3\ \text{km/h},\ V_{j,SN} = 369.2\ \text{km/h}\\ V_r &= \frac{L}{\bar t - \text{delay}}: & V_{r,NS} &= 546.2\ \text{km/h},\ V_{r,SN} = 569.7\ \text{km/h} \end{aligned}

Answer:

DirectionFlow (veh/h)Journey speed (km/h)Running speed (km/h)
N-S252369.3546.2
S-N260369.2569.7

Note: a section of 25.5 km run in about 4.4 minutes implies unrealistic speeds, so the length is probably 2.55 km. Flows are unaffected; the speeds would then be one-tenth of those above (36.9 and 36.9 km/h journey speed, 54.6 and 57.0 km/h running speed).

  • 2071 Chaitra · 8 marks

Define traffic engineering. Describe road users and vehicular characteristics.

Answer

Traffic engineering

Traffic engineering is the branch of transportation engineering that deals with the planning, geometric design, operation and control of roads, their networks, terminals and adjacent land use, so that people and goods move safely, quickly, comfortably, economically and with least harm to the environment. (Institute of Transportation Engineers definition, as used in Khanna and Justo.)

Its scope covers traffic characteristics, traffic studies (volume, speed, O-D, parking, accident), traffic regulation and control, geometric design, traffic signs, markings and signals, road lighting, and traffic planning and management, including the Nepal Motor Vehicles and Transport Management Act and the Department of Roads (DoR) rules for enforcement.

Road users

  1. Physical: vision (acuity, field of vision, colour vision, glare), hearing, strength and agility. They fix sign sizes, letter heights, lighting, sight distances and footpath gradients.
  2. Mental and psychological: attention, judgement, emotional stability and attitude. They influence overtaking decisions, gap acceptance and compliance with signals.
  3. Reaction time (PIEV): about 2.5 s is used for stopping sight distance, headlight sight distance and intersection sight distance (IRC:SP:23, IRC:66, Nepal Road Standard 2070).
  4. Pedestrian characteristics: walking speed about 1.2 m/s (IRC:103 and IRC:93 use 1.2 m/s; slower, about 0.9 m/s, for children and the elderly); space needed about 0.5-0.75 m² per person; they need footpaths, crossings, refuge islands and signal time.
  5. Cyclists: speed 10-25 km/h, need separate lanes and safe turning at intersections.
  6. Age and gender, fatigue, intoxication and disability: these add to variation, so design uses the 85th-percentile or a conservative value (for example the 15th-percentile pedestrian speed for crossing time).
  7. Behaviour and compliance: lane discipline, helmet and seat-belt use, jaywalking and parking habits vary by country and must be reflected in the design and enforcement plan (in Nepal mixed traffic is common).
  8. Mixed traffic: in Nepal slow and fast vehicles share the carriageway, so wider shoulders and segregation are required.

Vehicular characteristics

CharacteristicTypical valueEffect on road design
Width2.5 m (trucks, buses)Lane width (3.5 m rural, 3.0-3.25 m urban), parking bay width
Heightup to 4.75 m (IRC)Vertical clearance under bridges and tunnels (5.5 m minimum, IRC:5)
Length11-12 m rigid, up to 18 m semi-trailerParking bays, curve widening, kerb radius, passing and storage lanes
Wheel base and overhang6-7 m (truck)Extra widening on curves, minimum turning radius, tail swing
Ground clearance0.2-0.3 mHump, drain and vertical-curve design
Turning radius12-14 m (truck)Minimum intersection radius, island and median-opening design
Weight and axle load10.2 t legal single axle; 8.16 t standard axle in IRC:37Pavement thickness, bridge loading (IRC:6), width of bridge
Eye and object heightdriver eye 1.2 m, object 0.15 m (IRC:SP:23)Sight distance at crests

Examples: the 2.5 m width and 11 m length of a bus fix the minimum bay size; the 4.75 m height fixes bridge clearance; the large turning radius of trucks fixes the radius of intersection corners; the axle load fixes pavement thickness.

  • Power and performance: engine power, tractive effort and weight-to-power ratio decide acceleration, gradient ability and the need for climbing lanes.
  • Speed and acceleration: the typical range of speeds and accelerations fixes overtaking sight distance, length of acceleration/deceleration lanes and signal timings.
  • Braking and braking efficiency: deceleration depends on tyre-pavement friction (f about 0.35-0.40); it fixes stopping sight distance.
  • Resistances: air, rolling, grade and curve resistance decide fuel use and the speed on gradients.
  • Turning and stability: centrifugal force limits speed on curves, so superelevation and radius are provided; high centre of gravity vehicles may overturn.
  • Headlight range and visibility: fix night sight distance and vertical-curve length.
  • Vehicle mix: the share of heavy vehicles sets the PCU factors (IRC:106-1990: car 1.0, bus/truck 3.0, motor cycle 0.5, bicycle 0.5, cycle rickshaw 2.0, horse cart 4.0, bullock cart 6.0).
  • 2071 Chaitra · 8 marks

What are the uses of origin and destination study? Briefly explain the methods of conducting this study.

Answer

Uses of an origin and destination study

Uses

  • Planning new highways, by-passes, bridges and flyovers, and deciding their location from desire lines.
  • Finding the share of through traffic that can be diverted to a by-pass.
  • Planning traffic management measures (one-way streets, junction improvements).
  • Planning terminals, parking facilities and public transport routes and schedules.
  • Forecasting trip generation and distribution for traffic and land-use planning.
  • Giving the pattern of freight and passenger movement.
  • Determining road priorities and staged construction.
  • Evaluating economic viability of improvements.

Methods of conducting the study

  1. Roadside interview method: vehicles are stopped at the survey station (a cordon or screen line) and the driver is asked origin, destination, purpose, vehicle type and load. Traffic Police assist. It gives direct and accurate data but disturbs traffic; sampling (a fraction of vehicles) is used when volume is high.
  2. License plate method: registration numbers of vehicles are noted at entry and exit points, with the time; matching gives route and trip time. Good for short-range studies and by-pass studies but no trip purpose.
  3. Return post-card method: prepaid cards with questions are handed to drivers or posted to owners; the response is poor (15-30 percent) but cheap.
  4. Tag-on-car method: coloured tags are attached to the vehicles at the entry station and read at the exit, to know the entry-exit pairs. Good for the cordon of a small area.
  5. Home interview method: households in the study area are surveyed for all trips of members, which gives detail about trip purpose, mode and time (best for urban planning).
  6. Work-place and public-transport (on-board) interviews: at offices, factories, schools and in buses/trains.
  7. Automatic and video methods: number-plate recognition, GPS and mobile-phone data are modern options.

Results are presented as an O-D matrix, desire-line diagram and contour or zone map.

  • 2071 Chaitra · 8 marks

Average trip time for office is 30 minutes with standard deviation of 5 min. Assuming normal distribution of trip time, calculate the followings: a) Probability of trip time being at least 35 minutes b) If the working hour starts at 10:00 AM and trip starts at 9:40 AM what is the probability of being late?

Answer

Trip time TT is normally distributed with mean μ=30\mu = 30 min and standard deviation σ=5\sigma = 5 min. Use the standard normal variable z=(T−μ)/σz = (T - \mu)/\sigma.

(a) Probability that the trip time is at least 35 minutes

z=35−305=1.00,P(T≥35)=1−Φ(1.00)=1−0.8413=0.1587z = \frac{35 - 30}{5} = 1.00,\quad P(T \ge 35) = 1 - \Phi(1.00) = 1 - 0.8413 = 0.1587

Answer (a): 0.1587 (about 15.9 %).

(b) Probability of being late

Work starts at 10:00 AM and the trip starts at 9:40 AM, so only 20 minutes are available. The person is late if the trip takes more than 20 minutes:

z=20−305=−2.00,P(T>20)=1−Φ(−2.00)=Φ(2.00)=0.9772z = \frac{20 - 30}{5} = -2.00,\quad P(T > 20) = 1 - \Phi(-2.00) = \Phi(2.00) = 0.9772

Answer (b): 0.9772 (about 97.7 %). Leaving at 9:40 makes the person late almost every day; a trip starting before 9:15 would be needed to be on time with 95 percent confidence (30 + 1.645 x 5 = 38.2 min).

  • 2070 Chaitra · 8 marks

List the objectives of accident study. Explain briefly causes and preventive measures of accident.

Answer

Objectives of crash (accident) study

  • To find the number, severity, types and causes of crashes.
  • To identify hazardous locations (black spots) and the accident-prone times and vehicle types.
  • To study the factors (human, vehicle, road) that contribute.
  • To design remedial measures (engineering, education, enforcement) and to rank them by priority and cost-benefit.
  • To evaluate the effect of safety measures by before-and-after comparison.
  • To support policy, planning, traffic law and insurance decisions and to give a base for safety audits.
  • To compute crash rates and costs.

Causes of accidents and preventive measures

  1. Road user (human) factors: over-speeding, drunk or drowsy driving, overtaking in unsafe places, ignoring signals, jaywalking, lack of experience or training, fatigue, using mobile phones. These account for about 80-90 percent of crashes.
  2. Vehicle factors: brake failure, tyre burst, steering defects, overloading, defective lights, poor maintenance and lack of fitness tests.
  3. Road and geometric factors: sharp curves, poor sight distance, narrow carriageways and bridges, insufficient superelevation, slippery or damaged pavement, absence of shoulders, poor intersection design.
  4. Traffic control factors: missing or confusing signs, signals and markings, absent or poor lighting.
  5. Environmental factors: rain, fog, snow, landslides and flooding (especially important in Nepal's hilly roads); night-time.
  6. Other causes: animals on the road, poor enforcement of law and lack of emergency services.

Preventive measures — the 5 E's

  • Engineering: safe geometric design, adequate sight distance, proper superelevation, signs, markings, guard rails, crash barriers, street lighting, speed humps, pedestrian crossings and bridges, black-spot treatment, road safety audit.
  • Education: driver training and licensing, school programmes, public awareness campaigns and media.
  • Enforcement: speed and drunk-driving checks, helmet and seat-belt laws, vehicle fitness inspection, penalty and demerit points under the Motor Vehicles and Transport Management Act 2049.
  • Encouragement: reward safe drivers; promote safety culture and use of protective equipment.
  • Emergency services: quick ambulance and first aid, trauma care and a good crash reporting system (IRC:53 forms A-1 and A-4).
  • 2070 Chaitra · 8 marks

Describe channelized intersections with their advantages and disadvantages.

Answer

A channelised intersection is an at-grade junction in which traffic movements are guided into definite paths by raised or painted islands, kerbs and markings, so that conflicts are separated and the paved area is reduced (IRC:SP:41).

        |  |  |
        |  |  |  <- splitter island
   _____|  |  |_____
  /     \  \  /     \
 ---  triangular      ---
  \_____/ island \_____/
        |  |  |

How it works

  • Islands (triangular, divisional, refuge) force vehicles into turning or through lanes.
  • Turning roadways with large radius give free left turns (for left-hand traffic), so those vehicles do not wait for the signal.
  • Markings, signs and signals work together with the islands.

Advantages

  • Reduces the number and severity of conflicts, so crashes fall.
  • Separates movements and fixes the vehicle path, so there is less confusion and wrong-way driving.
  • Reduces the large paved area, which limits vehicle wandering and speed.
  • Provides refuge for pedestrians and a place for signs, signals and lighting.
  • Increases capacity (free turns, separate turn lanes) and reduces delay.
  • Gives control of speed and angle of merging; allows protected turning lanes.

Disadvantages

  • Higher cost of construction and kerbs, and more land for turning roadways.
  • Islands are hazards if poorly marked or lit, especially at night; vehicles may hit them.
  • Hard for large vehicles to turn if radii or lane widths are too small.
  • Too much channelisation can confuse drivers and block snow or debris clearing, and complicates future widening.
  • Long walking distance for pedestrians if they must cross many lanes.
  • 2070 Chaitra · 8 marks

The data collected after speed and delay studies by floating car method on a stretch of road 3.2 km long are given below. Determine the average values of volume, journey speed and running speed of the traffic stream along either direction.
TripDirection of tripJourney time (min)Total stopped delay (min)OvertakingOvertakenFrom opposite direction
1C-D6.501.5847270
2D-C7.481.7254250
3C-D6.921.6254300
4D-C7.821.8233275
5C-D6.331.4032295
6D-C8.132.1021280
7C-D6.711.7344300
8D-C7.401.8533230
9C-D6.231.6042275
10D-C6.981.7821242

Answer

For each direction, the floating car (moving observer) method gives the flow q=na+yta+twq = \dfrac{n_a + y}{t_a + t_w} where nan_a = vehicles counted from the opposite direction while running against the stream (these are the vehicles of the direction being studied), yy = overtaking minus overtaken during the run with the stream, twt_w = journey time with the stream and tat_a = journey time against it. Odd trips are C-D and even trips are D-C; L=3.2L = 3.2 km.

Direction C-D (stream moving C to D)

Averages of 5 trips: tw=6.538t_w = 6.538 min (this direction), ta=7.562t_a = 7.562 min (opposite direction), opposing vehicles na=255.4n_a = 255.4, overtaking 4.0, overtaken 3.8 so y=0.2y = 0.2, mean stopped delay 1.586 min.

q=na+yta+tw×60=255.4+(0.2)7.562+6.538×60=1088 veh/htˉ=tw−yq=6.538−0.218.13=6.527 minVj=Ltˉ=3.2×606.527=29.4 km/hVr=Ltˉ−delay=3.2×606.527−1.586=38.9 km/h\begin{aligned} q &= \frac{n_a + y}{t_a + t_w} \times 60 = \frac{255.4 + (0.2)}{7.562 + 6.538} \times 60 = 1088\ \text{veh/h}\\ \bar t &= t_w - \frac{y}{q} = 6.538 - \frac{0.2}{18.13} = 6.527\ \text{min}\\ V_j &= \frac{L}{\bar t} = \frac{3.2 \times 60}{6.527} = 29.4\ \text{km/h}\\ V_r &= \frac{L}{\bar t - \text{delay}} = \frac{3.2 \times 60}{6.527 - 1.586} = 38.9\ \text{km/h} \end{aligned}

Direction D-C (stream moving D to C)

Averages of 5 trips: tw=7.562t_w = 7.562 min (this direction), ta=6.538t_a = 6.538 min (opposite direction), opposing vehicles na=288.0n_a = 288.0, overtaking 3.0, overtaken 2.4 so y=0.6y = 0.6, mean stopped delay 1.854 min.

q=na+yta+tw×60=288.0+(0.6)6.538+7.562×60=1228 veh/htˉ=tw−yq=7.562−0.620.47=7.533 minVj=Ltˉ=3.2×607.533=25.5 km/hVr=Ltˉ−delay=3.2×607.533−1.854=33.8 km/h\begin{aligned} q &= \frac{n_a + y}{t_a + t_w} \times 60 = \frac{288.0 + (0.6)}{6.538 + 7.562} \times 60 = 1228\ \text{veh/h}\\ \bar t &= t_w - \frac{y}{q} = 7.562 - \frac{0.6}{20.47} = 7.533\ \text{min}\\ V_j &= \frac{L}{\bar t} = \frac{3.2 \times 60}{7.533} = 25.5\ \text{km/h}\\ V_r &= \frac{L}{\bar t - \text{delay}} = \frac{3.2 \times 60}{7.533 - 1.854} = 33.8\ \text{km/h} \end{aligned}

Average of the two directions

DirectionVolume (veh/h)Journey speed (km/h)Running speed (km/h)
C-D108829.438.9
D-C122825.533.8
Average115827.536.3

Answer: C-D: volume 1088 veh/h, journey speed 29.4 km/h, running speed 38.9 km/h; D-C: volume 1228 veh/h, journey speed 25.5 km/h, running speed 33.8 km/h. Average of both: 1158 veh/h, 27.5 km/h and 36.3 km/h.

  • 2070 Chaitra (old course) · 8 marks

What do you mean by Origin and Destination Study? Explain the various applications of Origin and Destination studies.

Answer

Origin and destination (O-D) study

An origin and destination study determines, for a given area and period, where trips start (origin) and end (destination), together with trip purpose, mode, vehicle type, time and route. The result is shown as an O-D matrix, desire-line diagram or zone map. It is the basic survey for transport planning, and is done by roadside interviews, licence plate, home interview, postcard, tag-on-car and similar methods (IRC:SP:19).

Applications

Uses

  • Planning new highways, by-passes, bridges and flyovers, and deciding their location from desire lines.

  • Finding the share of through traffic that can be diverted to a by-pass.

  • Planning traffic management measures (one-way streets, junction improvements).

  • Planning terminals, parking facilities and public transport routes and schedules.

  • Forecasting trip generation and distribution for traffic and land-use planning.

  • Giving the pattern of freight and passenger movement.

  • Determining road priorities and staged construction.

  • Evaluating economic viability of improvements.

  • In Nepal, O-D surveys of the DoR are used in feasibility studies of new strategic roads and in traffic demand forecasting for road projects.

  • 2070 Chaitra (old course) · 6 marks

Compare on-street and off-street parking. Draw neat sketches showing parallel and angle kerb (on-street) parking geometry.

Answer

Comparison of on-street and off-street parking

AspectOn-streetOff-street
LocationOn the carriageway edgeIn lots, garages, basements
CostVery low (markings, signs, meters)High (land, construction, staff)
ConvenienceVery close to the destinationSlightly further to walk
Effect on trafficReduces road capacity and safetyNo effect on road capacity
CapacitySmallLarge, especially multi-level
Safety and securityLower; risk of theft/damageBetter supervision and security
ControlHard; often illegal parkingEasy; gates, tickets, fees
Pedestrian effectObstructs footpathProtects footpath

Parallel parking geometry

Bay size for a car: about 5.0 m long x 2.0-2.5 m wide (6.0 m long for buses and trucks, 2.5 m wide). The car is parked parallel to the kerb, needing the least road width but giving the fewest bays.

  carriageway
 --------------------------------------
   <- traffic ->
 ======================================== kerb line
  _____5.0 m_____  _____5.0 m_____
 |   car   | gap |   car   |        2.0-2.5 m
 |_________|     |_________|
 ======================================== kerb

Angle parking geometry (30, 45, 60, 90 degrees)

The vehicle is parked at an angle to the kerb, front end first (or reversed in). A larger angle gives more cars per length of kerb but needs a wider strip of road and a wider aisle.

 45 degree parking                     
  carriageway   <- traffic ->
 ======================================
   \  \  \  \  \  \     stall width along kerb
   \__\__\__\__\__\     = 2.5 / sin(angle)
 ====================================== kerb
Angle to kerbKerb length per carDepth of the bay from kerb
0 (parallel)5.5-6.0 m2.0-2.5 m
30 degreesabout 5.0 mabout 4.7 m
45 degreesabout 3.5 mabout 5.3 m
60 degreesabout 2.9 mabout 5.6 m
90 degreesabout 2.5 mabout 5.0 m

(For a car 2.5 m wide x 5.0 m long: kerb length per car = 2.5/sin(angle); bay depth = 5.0 sin(angle) + 2.5 cos(angle).) The aisle width kept for manoeuvring is larger for 90-degree parking (about 6 m).

  • 2070 Chaitra (old course) · 10 marks

An isolated signal with pedestrian indicators to be installed on a right angled intersection with road A of 15 m and road B of 7 m respectively. The heaviest volume per hour for each lane of road A and road B are 350 and 250. The approaching speeds for road A and road B are 60 kmph and 45 kmph. Design the traffic and pedestrian signal timings. (Take amber period for yellow light signal as 2 to 4 secs and pedestrian walking speed of 1.0 m/sec)

Answer

Isolated two-phase signal with pedestrian indicators for road A (15 m) and road B (7 m); the pedestrian walking speed is 1.0 m/s and the amber is taken within 2-4 s.

Design basis (IRC:93-1985, Guidelines on Design and Installation of Road Traffic Signals, with Webster's method): two-phase signal, Phase 1 = road A moves, Phase 2 = road B moves. Pedestrians cross a road while the traffic on the cross road has green. Assumed (not given): saturation flow 1800 PCU/h per lane, start-up lost time 2 s per phase, pedestrian walking speed 1.0 m/s and initial walk (pedestrian start-up) time 5 s.

Step 1: Amber (change) time

Amber I=tr+v2aI = t_r + \dfrac{v}{2a} with reaction time tr=1t_r = 1 s and comfortable deceleration a=3 m/s2a = 3\ \text{m/s}^2, kept within the IRC:93 range of 2-4 s:

IA=1+60/3.62(3)=3.78→4 sIB=1+45/3.62(3)=3.08→4 s\begin{aligned} I_A &= 1 + \frac{60/3.6}{2(3)} = 3.78 \to 4\ \text{s}\\ I_B &= 1 + \frac{45/3.6}{2(3)} = 3.08 \to 4\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 2: Pedestrian crossing time

Time to cross = initial walk + width / walking speed:

tp,A=5+151.0=20.0 stp,B=5+71.0=12.0 s\begin{aligned} t_{p,A} &= 5 + \frac{15}{1.0} = 20.0\ \text{s}\\ t_{p,B} &= 5 + \frac{7}{1.0} = 12.0\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Pedestrians crossing road A walk during Phase 2, so Phase 2 green must be at least 20.0 s. Pedestrians crossing road B walk during Phase 1, so Phase 1 green must be at least 12.0 s.

Step 3: Webster cycle time from traffic

yA=3501800=0.194,yB=2501800=0.139,Y=0.333L=(2+4)+(2+4)=12 sC0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(12)+51−0.333=34.5 s\begin{aligned} y_A &= \frac{350}{1800} = 0.194, \quad y_B = \frac{250}{1800} = 0.139, \quad Y = 0.333\\ L &= (2+4) + (2+4) = 12\ \text{s}\\ C_0 &= \frac{1.5L+5}{1-Y} = \frac{1.5(12)+5}{1-0.333} = 34.5\ \text{s} \end{aligned} gA=0.1940.333(22.5)=13.1 s,GA=gA+2=15.1 sgB=0.1390.333(22.5)=9.4 s,GB=gB+2=11.4 s\begin{aligned} g_A &= \frac{0.194}{0.333}(22.5) = 13.1\ \text{s}, \quad G_A = g_A + 2 = 15.1\ \text{s}\\ g_B &= \frac{0.139}{0.333}(22.5) = 9.4\ \text{s}, \quad G_B = g_B + 2 = 11.4\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 4: Check against pedestrian needs

PhaseGreen from traffic (s)Pedestrian minimum (s)Adopted green (s)
1 (road A)15.112.016
2 (road B)11.420.020

Adopted cycle length C=16+4+20+4=44C = 16 + 4 + 20 + 4 = 44 s.

Final timings

SignalPhase 1: road APhase 2: road B
Vehicle green16 s20 s
Vehicle amber4 s4 s
Vehicle red24 s20 s

Pedestrian signals: pedestrians crossing road B get WALK for 5 s then flashing (clearance) for 7 s during Phase 1 (total 12 s of 16 s green); pedestrians crossing road A get WALK for 5 s then flashing for 15 s during Phase 2 (total 20 s of 20 s green). All pedestrian indications show DON'T WALK (red man) while their cross traffic moves.

Phase diagram

Cycle = 44 s
Road A: [GREEN 16][A 4][  RED 24  ]
Road B: [ RED 20 ][GREEN 20][A 4]
Ped crossing B: [WALK+FLASH 16][DON'T WALK 28]
Ped crossing A: [DON'T WALK 20][WALK+FLASH 20][DW]
  • 2070 Chaitra (old course) · 4 marks

Write a short note on importance of road lighting.

Answer

  • It improves night visibility so that drivers see the road, obstacles, pedestrians and other vehicles in time to stop.
  • It reduces crashes and the severity of crashes at intersections, curves, bridges, and pedestrian crossings.
  • It improves personal security and reduces crime in urban areas.
  • It increases the capacity and speed of the road after dark by raising the confidence of the driver.
  • It helps traffic flow and the economic life of commercial areas (night shopping, tourism).
  • It gives guidance to the driver on road alignment, junctions and the edge of the pavement, and it enhances the look of the city.
  • 2070 Chaitra (old course) · 4 marks

Write a short note on thirtieth highest hourly traffic volume.

Answer

The thirtieth highest hourly volume (30 HV) is the hourly traffic volume that is exceeded in only 29 hours of the year. It is obtained by counting the traffic in every hour of the year (8,760 hours), arranging the hourly volumes in descending order, and taking the 30th value.

 Hourly volume
 (% of AADT)
 |*
 | *
 |   *
 |      *___        <- knee at about the 30th hour
 |          `--.___
 +--------------------> hours (ranked)
   1   30    100   ...  8760

Why it is used

  • On a graph of ranked hourly volume (as a percentage of AADT) against rank, the curve is steep up to about the 30th hour and then flattens (the "knee"). Designing for a higher hour gives little benefit, while designing for a lower rank (for example the 1st or 5th highest hour) is uneconomical because the road would be under-used almost all the time.
  • Designing for the 30th hour means the road is congested for fewer than 30 hours in a year, a reasonable economic balance.
  • For rural roads the 30th highest hourly volume, called the design hourly volume (DHV), is commonly about 8-15 percent of the AADT (the factor KK), and the capacity (design service volume) of the road is fixed to carry it:
DHV=K×AADTDHV = K \times AADT
  • It is also used in the planning of highways in Nepal (Nepal Road Standard 2070) and by IRC practice (IRC:SP:19) for the number of lanes, while for urban roads the peak hour volume and PHF are used instead.
  • 2068 Baisakh · 6 marks

Define traffic capacity. Describe the factors affecting capacity and level of service.

Answer

Traffic capacity

Capacity of a road is the maximum number of vehicles (or PCUs) that can pass a given point or section of a lane or road in one direction (or both directions on a two-lane road) during a given time period (normally one hour) under the prevailing roadway, traffic and control conditions (HCM definition; IRC:106 for urban roads).

Types of capacity:

  1. Basic capacity: the maximum number of passenger cars that can pass in a lane under ideal (best possible) roadway and traffic conditions.
  2. Possible capacity: the maximum number that can pass under the actual (prevailing) roadway and traffic conditions, i.e. after adjusting the basic capacity for lane width, shoulder, gradient, heavy vehicles, etc.
  3. Practical capacity (design capacity): the maximum number that can pass without unreasonable delay or restriction to the drivers' freedom to manoeuvre, at the chosen level of service. It is about 75-80 percent of the possible capacity (design service volume at LOS B for urban roads in IRC:106, and at LOS B for rural roads in IRC:64).

Factors affecting capacity and level of service

  1. Roadway (geometric) factors: lane width, lateral clearance (shoulder, kerb), number of lanes, horizontal and vertical alignment, gradient, sight distance, median presence. Narrow lanes (below 3.65 m) reduce capacity.
  2. Traffic factors: composition (share of buses, trucks and slow vehicles), directional distribution of traffic, lane distribution and the presence of pedestrians and cyclists.
  3. Control factors: signals (green time, cycle length, progression), signs, speed limits, and parking restrictions.
  4. Environmental factors: weather (rain, fog), lighting at night, surface condition, side friction (pedestrians, bus stops, parking and roadside activities).
  5. Driver factors: familiarity, behaviour (urban commuters versus tourists), and lane discipline.
  6. Operating (service) measures: speed and travel time, freedom to manoeuvre, comfort, interruptions and safety, v/c ratio, density.
  7. Peaking: the peak hour factor (PHF) and the variation of flow over time.

Level of service

LOS is the quality of traffic flow, graded from A (free flow) to F (breakdown) by speed, travel time, freedom to move, comfort and safety (HCM; IRC:106 and IRC:64). Capacity is reached at LOS E; roads are designed for LOS B to C so that traffic flows without undue delay.

  • 2068 Baisakh · 10 marks

Design the timing of traffic and pedestrian signals of an isolated signal to be installed at a right angle intersection when road P and Q cross. The data available are:
Road PRoad Q
i) Width14.0010.50
ii) Peak hour traffic volume, Vehicle/hour/lane210120
iii) Approach speed, Kmph5035

Answer

Isolated two-phase signal with pedestrian indications for road P (14 m wide) and road Q (10.5 m wide).

Design basis (IRC:93-1985, Guidelines on Design and Installation of Road Traffic Signals, with Webster's method): two-phase signal, Phase 1 = road P moves, Phase 2 = road Q moves. Pedestrians cross a road while the traffic on the cross road has green. Assumed (not given): saturation flow 1800 PCU/h per lane, start-up lost time 2 s per phase, pedestrian walking speed 1.2 m/s and initial walk (pedestrian start-up) time 5 s.

Step 1: Amber (change) time

Amber I=tr+v2aI = t_r + \dfrac{v}{2a} with reaction time tr=1t_r = 1 s and comfortable deceleration a=3 m/s2a = 3\ \text{m/s}^2, kept within the IRC:93 range of 2-4 s:

IP=1+50/3.62(3)=3.31→4 sIQ=1+35/3.62(3)=2.62→3 s\begin{aligned} I_P &= 1 + \frac{50/3.6}{2(3)} = 3.31 \to 4\ \text{s}\\ I_Q &= 1 + \frac{35/3.6}{2(3)} = 2.62 \to 3\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 2: Pedestrian crossing time

Time to cross = initial walk + width / walking speed:

tp,P=5+141.2=16.7 stp,Q=5+10.51.2=13.8 s\begin{aligned} t_{p,P} &= 5 + \frac{14}{1.2} = 16.7\ \text{s}\\ t_{p,Q} &= 5 + \frac{10.5}{1.2} = 13.8\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Pedestrians crossing road P walk during Phase 2, so Phase 2 green must be at least 16.7 s. Pedestrians crossing road Q walk during Phase 1, so Phase 1 green must be at least 13.8 s.

Step 3: Webster cycle time from traffic

yP=2101800=0.117,yQ=1201800=0.067,Y=0.183L=(2+4)+(2+3)=11 sC0=1.5L+51−Y=1.5(11)+51−0.183=26.3 s\begin{aligned} y_P &= \frac{210}{1800} = 0.117, \quad y_Q = \frac{120}{1800} = 0.067, \quad Y = 0.183\\ L &= (2+4) + (2+3) = 11\ \text{s}\\ C_0 &= \frac{1.5L+5}{1-Y} = \frac{1.5(11)+5}{1-0.183} = 26.3\ \text{s} \end{aligned} gP=0.1170.183(15.3)=9.8 s,GP=gP+2=11.8 sgQ=0.0670.183(15.3)=5.6 s,GQ=gQ+2=7.6 s\begin{aligned} g_P &= \frac{0.117}{0.183}(15.3) = 9.8\ \text{s}, \quad G_P = g_P + 2 = 11.8\ \text{s}\\ g_Q &= \frac{0.067}{0.183}(15.3) = 5.6\ \text{s}, \quad G_Q = g_Q + 2 = 7.6\ \text{s} \end{aligned}

Step 4: Check against pedestrian needs

PhaseGreen from traffic (s)Pedestrian minimum (s)Adopted green (s)
1 (road P)11.813.814
2 (road Q)7.616.717

Adopted cycle length C=14+4+17+3=38C = 14 + 4 + 17 + 3 = 38 s.

Final timings

SignalPhase 1: road PPhase 2: road Q
Vehicle green14 s17 s
Vehicle amber4 s3 s
Vehicle red20 s18 s

Pedestrian signals: pedestrians crossing road Q get WALK for 5 s then flashing (clearance) for 9 s during Phase 1 (total 14 s of 14 s green); pedestrians crossing road P get WALK for 5 s then flashing for 12 s during Phase 2 (total 17 s of 17 s green). All pedestrian indications show DON'T WALK (red man) while their cross traffic moves.

Phase diagram

Cycle = 38 s
Road P: [GREEN 14][A 4][  RED 20  ]
Road Q: [ RED 18 ][GREEN 17][A 3]
Ped crossing Q: [WALK+FLASH 14][DON'T WALK 24]
Ped crossing P: [DON'T WALK 18][WALK+FLASH 17][DW]
  • 2068 Baisakh · 8 marks

Define rotary intersection. What are the advantages and disadvantages of rotary intersection?

Answer

Rotary intersection

A rotary (roundabout) is a one-way circulatory intersection at which all vehicles move around a central island in one direction (clockwise, because traffic keeps left in Nepal and India) and merge, weave and diverge.

A rotary is a special type of at-grade intersection in which all traffic moves in one direction (clockwise in Nepal, where traffic keeps left) around a central island, and the conflicts are converted into weaving (merge-diverge) movements at the approaches. Rotaries are designed to IRC:65-1976.

          |  |
        __|  |__
      /          \
 ----  ( central  ) ----
      \ ( island ) /
        --|  |--
          |  |
   one-way circulation (clockwise)

Advantages and disadvantages

Advantages

  • Removes the need for signals; traffic flows continuously, so delay is small at moderate volumes.
  • Converts all conflicts to merging, weaving and diverging, which are less severe, so crashes are fewer and less serious.
  • Low speed (about 25-40 km/h) gives safe operation; fewer injuries.
  • Suitable for junctions of 4 or more arms, and for equal-volume roads.
  • Low operating and maintenance cost, no power needed, no signal failure.
  • Can be used for traffic with large turning volumes.

Disadvantages / limitations

  • Needs a large area of land; not suitable where land is costly or limited.
  • Not suitable for very high volumes (more than about 3,000 PCU/h entering) or when pedestrian volume is high.
  • Pedestrian crossing is unsafe and difficult; the diameter forces longer paths.
  • The detour adds travel distance for through and right-turning vehicles.
  • Not suitable for heavy slow traffic or where one road is much more important than the others.
  • Difficult to give priority to emergency vehicles; speed on straight approaches is reduced.
  • Performance fails when the approach flows are unbalanced.
  • 2068 Baisakh · 8 marks

A vehicle skids through a distance of 40m before colliding with another parked vehicle, the weight of which is 75 percent of the former. After collision both the vehicles skid through 14m before stopping. Compute the initial speed of moving vehicle. Assume coefficient of friction of 0.62.

Answer

The moving vehicle (weight WW) skids 40 m, hits the parked vehicle (weight 0.75W0.75W) and both skid together 14 m. Work backwards: speed after impact, then momentum, then the 40 m skid.

Step 1: Speed after the collision (both vehicles together)

v′=2gfd′=2(9.81)(0.62)(14)=13.050 m/sv' = \sqrt{2gfd'} = \sqrt{2(9.81)(0.62)(14)} = 13.050\ \text{m/s}

Step 2: Momentum conservation

The parked vehicle has zero speed before impact. With impact speed uu of the moving vehicle:

W u+0.75W (0)=(W+0.75W) v′⇒u=1.75 v′=1.75(13.050)=22.837 m/sW\,u + 0.75W\,(0) = (W + 0.75W)\,v' \Rightarrow u = 1.75\,v' = 1.75(13.050) = 22.837\ \text{m/s}

Step 3: Initial speed before the 40 m skid

v0=u2+2gfd=(22.837)2+2(9.81)(0.62)(40)=31.751 m/sv_0 = \sqrt{u^2 + 2gfd} = \sqrt{(22.837)^2 + 2(9.81)(0.62)(40)} = 31.751\ \text{m/s}

Answer: initial speed of the moving vehicle = 31.75 m/s = 114.3 km/h (speed at impact 82.2 km/h).

  • 2068 Baisakh · 4 marks

Write a short note on fixed delay and operational delay.

Answer

Delay is the extra travel time lost compared with free travel; it is a measure of the level of service of an intersection or road section. Total delay has two parts.

Fixed delay

  • Caused by traffic control devices or physical features and not by other vehicles. It occurs even when there is no interference from other traffic.
  • Examples: stopping at a traffic signal, stop sign, railway level crossing, toll plaza or check post.
  • It is found by comparing the travel time of a single vehicle running in free flow with the minimum time it must lose at the device, and depends mainly on the cycle length and green split.

Operational delay

  • Caused by interference of one component of traffic with another, so it grows with traffic volume.
  • Examples: side friction from pedestrians and parked or stopping vehicles, slow vehicles, turning vehicles, merging and weaving, and queuing behind accidents.
  • Includes stopped-time delay (time the vehicle is standing), and travel-time delay (difference between actual and ideal travel time).
Total delay=Fixed delay+Operational delay\text{Total delay} = \text{Fixed delay} + \text{Operational delay}

Both are measured by the floating-car method or by a stopped-delay (point sample) study and are used to evaluate level of service and the benefit of improvements.

  • 2068 Baisakh · 4 marks

Write a short note on spacing and head way.

Answer

Spacing is the distance between the front of one vehicle and the front of the next vehicle in the same lane, measured in metres. Average spacing ss is related to density kk (veh/km) by

s=1000k ms = \frac{1000}{k}\ \text{m}

Headway is the time between the passage of the front of one vehicle and the front of the next vehicle at a fixed point, in seconds. Average headway hh is related to flow qq (veh/h) by

h=3600q sh = \frac{3600}{q}\ \text{s}

Spacing and headway are linked by speed: s=v hs = v\,h (vv in m/s).

 |<------- spacing (m) ------->|
 [==== car 1 ====]     <-gap->  [==== car 2 ====]
 front              rear        front
 |<------ headway (s) at a point ------>|
  • The gap is the time between the rear of one vehicle and the front of the next, and the clearance is the corresponding distance. So h=h = gap + (vehicle length / speed) and s=s = clearance + vehicle length.
  • Headways are used in capacity (saturation headway about 2 s per vehicle at a signal gives 1800 veh/h), safety and queue analysis; short headways (below about 1 s) are unsafe. Spacing is used to compute density and to find the storage space needed for queues.
  • For random arrivals the headways follow a negative exponential distribution.
  • 2066 Bhadra · 4+2 marks

Describe the road user characteristics. Explain their importance in traffic engineering.

Answer

Road user characteristics

  1. Physical: vision (acuity, field of vision, colour vision, glare), hearing, strength and agility. They fix sign sizes, letter heights, lighting, sight distances and footpath gradients.
  2. Mental and psychological: attention, judgement, emotional stability and attitude. They influence overtaking decisions, gap acceptance and compliance with signals.
  3. Reaction time (PIEV): about 2.5 s is used for stopping sight distance, headlight sight distance and intersection sight distance (IRC:SP:23, IRC:66, Nepal Road Standard 2070).
  4. Pedestrian characteristics: walking speed about 1.2 m/s (IRC:103 and IRC:93 use 1.2 m/s; slower, about 0.9 m/s, for children and the elderly); space needed about 0.5-0.75 m² per person; they need footpaths, crossings, refuge islands and signal time.
  5. Cyclists: speed 10-25 km/h, need separate lanes and safe turning at intersections.
  6. Age and gender, fatigue, intoxication and disability: these add to variation, so design uses the 85th-percentile or a conservative value (for example the 15th-percentile pedestrian speed for crossing time).
  7. Behaviour and compliance: lane discipline, helmet and seat-belt use, jaywalking and parking habits vary by country and must be reflected in the design and enforcement plan (in Nepal mixed traffic is common).
  8. Mixed traffic: in Nepal slow and fast vehicles share the carriageway, so wider shoulders and segregation are required.

Importance in traffic engineering

  • They are the basis for design values: perception-reaction time for sight distance, walking speed for crossing and signal timing, eye height and visibility for signs and lighting.
  • They explain the cause of most crashes, so help to select safety measures (education, enforcement and engineering).
  • They help in choosing traffic control devices (size, colour, location) and the timing of signals.
  • They allow design for all users, including pedestrians, cyclists, children, the elderly and disabled.
  • 2066 Bhadra · 3+3+4 marks

The following speed data were collected during a two-minute segment of a spot speed study (speed in kmph).
45, 55, 48, 52, 60, 48, 60, 42, 52, 65, 64, 63, 58, 56, 68, 54, 68, 64, 66, 70
Calculate: (i) The time mean speed; (ii) The space mean speed. What will be the average density of the above traffic stream if the mean headway is 4.5 sec?

Answer

(i) Time mean speed

The arithmetic mean of the 20 spot speeds:

vˉt=∑vin=115820=57.90 km/h\bar v_t = \frac{\sum v_i}{n} = \frac{1158}{20} = 57.90\ \text{km/h}

(ii) Space mean speed

The harmonic mean of the spot speeds:

vˉs=n∑1/vi=200.35265=56.71 km/h\bar v_s = \frac{n}{\sum 1/v_i} = \frac{20}{0.35265} = 56.71\ \text{km/h}

(iii) Average density

Mean headway 4.5 s gives the flow q=3600/4.5=800q = 3600/4.5 = 800 veh/h. From q=k vˉsq = k\,\bar v_s:

k=qvˉs=80056.71=14.11 veh/kmk = \frac{q}{\bar v_s} = \frac{800}{56.71} = 14.11\ \text{veh/km}

Answer: time mean speed = 57.90 km/h; space mean speed = 56.71 km/h; density = 14.1 veh/km.

  • 2066 Bhadra · 1+3+4 marks

What is grade separation? Mention their types with sketches. Draw a right angle four legged intersection of two roads and show their various types of conflict points if (i) both roads are with two way movements; (ii) one road is with one-way and another is with two way movements.

Answer

Grade separation

Grade separation means carrying crossing roads (or a road and a railway, or pedestrians) at different levels by a flyover, underpass, bridge or tunnel, so that the crossing conflicts are removed. The roads are linked by ramps where turning is needed (an interchange).

Types with sketches

1. Overpass (flyover) and underpass: one road passes over or under the other, with no connection.

  ===========//=========  upper road
        ______/  \______
  ------------------------ lower road

2. Trumpet interchange (three legs): one loop ramp for the turn.

        main road
  ========+=========
          |  \
          |   ) loop
        branch

3. Diamond interchange (four legs): four ramps; the minor road meets the ramps at-grade.

     minor road
        \  |  /
  =======\-+-/======= main road (over/under)
        /  |  \

4. Cloverleaf interchange: four loops carry the turns that would cross; free flow but large area.

    ()   ||   ()
      \  ||  /
  ======X====X======
      /  ||  \
    ()   ||   ()

5. Directional (stack) and rotary interchange for high-volume junctions.

Conflict points at a four-leg intersection

Count for the through, left and right movements from each entering approach (a pair of movements gives a diverging, merging or crossing conflict).

(i) Both roads two-way (4 approaches, 12 movements)

TypeNumber
Crossing16
Merging8
Diverging8
Total32

(ii) One road one-way, the other two-way (3 entering approaches, 9 movements)

TypeNumber
Crossing8
Merging5
Diverging6
Total19
 (i) two-way x two-way         (ii) one-way x two-way
        N                              N (two-way)
     D\ | /M                        D\ |  /M
  M-----+-----D                   ----+----->  (one-way road,
     X X X X  16 crossing             X X X     enters from W only)
  D-----+-----M                   ----+----
     M/ | \D                        M/ |  \D
        S                              S
 X crossing  M merging  D diverging

Classification: diverging (one stream splits), merging (two streams join) and crossing (two streams cut across), in increasing order of severity. A one-way system removes the opposing-flow conflicts and cuts the total from 32 to 19, and to 9 if both roads are one-way. Grade separation removes the crossing conflicts altogether.

  • 2066 Bhadra · 4 marks

Write a short note on traffic flow parameters.

Answer

Traffic flow is described by three basic macroscopic parameters, which are related to each other, and several microscopic ones.

1. Flow or volume (qq): the number of vehicles passing a section per unit time, in veh/h or PCU/h. Related measures: AADT, peak hour volume, design hourly volume, PHF and rate of flow.

2. Speed (vv): the distance covered per unit time.

  • Spot speed: at a point.
  • Time mean speed: average of spot speeds, vˉt=1n∑vi\bar v_t = \frac{1}{n}\sum v_i.
  • Space mean speed: average over a length, vˉs=n∑1/vi=L/tˉ\bar v_s = \frac{n}{\sum 1/v_i} = L/\bar t.
  • Running speed (excluding stops) and journey speed (including stops).

3. Density (kk): the number of vehicles per unit length of road, in veh/km. It is related to occupancy.

Fundamental relation

q=k vˉsq = k\,\bar v_s

With a linear model v=vf(1−k/kj)v = v_f(1 - k/k_j) the capacity is qmax=vfkj/4q_{max} = v_f k_j/4 at k=kj/2k = k_j/2.

4. Time headway (hh) and space headway or spacing (ss): h=3600/qh = 3600/q and s=1000/ks = 1000/k; they describe how vehicles are spaced in the stream.

5. Other parameters: capacity, level of service, v/c ratio, gap, clearance, platoon size and composition.

These parameters are measured by traffic surveys (volume count, spot speed, floating car) and used for design of roads and signals.

  • 2066 Bhadra · 4 marks

Write a short note on reverse or tidal flow operation.

Answer

Reverse (tidal) flow operation is a traffic management technique in which the number of lanes available to each direction is changed with the time of day, so that more lanes are given to the heavier direction at peak hours. It is used where the peak flow in one direction is much larger than in the other (for example inbound in the morning and outbound in the evening on a commuter corridor).

 Morning peak (to city):     Evening peak (from city):
  --> --> -->  (3 lanes)      --> (1 lane)
  <--          (1 lane)       <-- <-- <--  (3 lanes)

Conditions for use

  • A directional split of about 65:35 or more in the peak period, and a road with at least three or four lanes.
  • Roadside access and turning movements limited.

Methods of control

  • Overhead lane-control signals (green arrow / red cross).
  • Movable (zipper) barriers, cones or lane-markers placed by crews.
  • Signs and markings; enforcement by Traffic Police.

Advantages: uses existing road width more efficiently, increases capacity in the peak direction without new construction, and is cheap compared with widening.

Disadvantages: safety risk of head-on conflict if drivers do not follow signals, cost of signals and staff, confusion of drivers, and difficulty in turning movements at junctions.

Questions from Old Question Collection (CE 703) (IOE exam papers from 2066 to 2082 (20 papers)). Answers are written for this site; check them against your class notes.

Chapter titles and hours from the IOE syllabus ↗