- 2081 Bhadra · 3+3 marks
CCI vs ACI and co-channel reuse ratio proof
Short answer
Co‑channel interference: same‑frequency cells; mitigated by large reuse distance (Q = D/R = √(3N)). Adjacent channel interference: neighboring frequencies leak due to imperfect filtering and near‑far effect, reduced by filtering and channel separation. The proof: moving i and j cells in hexagonal lattice, D² = 3R²(i²+ij+j²); from N = i²+ij+j², Q = √(3N).
Explain the difference between co-channel and adjacent channel interference. Prove that the co-channel reuse ratio is given by Q = √(3N), where N = i² + ij + j² is the cluster size.
Co-channel interference (CCI)
- Interference between signals from cells that use the same set of frequencies (co-channel cells) under frequency reuse.
- Cannot be removed by increasing transmitter power, because the interfering signal grows equally. It is reduced only by physically separating co-channel cells by a minimum distance D, i.e. a larger reuse ratio Q = D/R = √(3N), or by sectoring.
- Measured by S/I = (√(3N))ⁿ / i₀ for the first tier of i₀ interferers. AMPS needs S/I ≥ 18 dB, which gives N = 7 with n = 4.
Adjacent channel interference (ACI)
- Interference from signals at frequencies adjacent (next) to the wanted signal, caused by imperfect receiver filters letting nearby frequencies leak into the passband.
- Becomes serious through the near–far effect: a nearby transmitter on an adjacent channel overpowers a weak, distant wanted signal.
- Reduced by careful filtering and channel assignment – not assigning adjacent channels in the same cell, keeping a large frequency separation between channels in a cell (e.g. channels 1, 22, 43, … in AMPS), and power control.
| Point | Co-channel | Adjacent channel |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Same frequency in other cells | Neighbouring frequency |
| Cause | Frequency reuse | Imperfect filtering, near–far effect |
| Remedy | Larger D/R, sectoring | Better filters, channel separation, power control |
| Depends on | Cluster size N | Filter selectivity, channel plan |
Proof of Q = √(3N)
Assumptions: hexagonal cells of radius R (centre to vertex); distance between centres of two adjacent cells = √3 R.
Locating a co-channel cell: in a hexagonal layout, the nearest co-channel cell is found by moving i cells along a chain of hexagons, turning 60° anticlockwise, and moving j cells.
* Co-channel cell
/
/ j cells
/ (after a 60° turn)
A *-------------*
i cells
D = straight-line distance from A to the co-channel cell
The two paths have lengths i√3R and j√3R, and the angle between them (inside the triangle) is 120°. By the cosine rule:
D² = (i√3R)² + (j√3R)² − 2(i√3R)(j√3R) cos 120°
= 3R²i² + 3R²j² + 3R²ij (cos 120° = −1/2)
= 3R² (i² + ij + j²)
Relating to cluster size: the area of a hexagon is proportional to the square of the distance between centres of neighbouring hexagons. A cluster of N cells repeats with centre spacing D, while single cells repeat with spacing √3R, so
N = (D / √3R)² = i² + ij + j²
Substituting:
D² = 3R² N
D = R √(3N)
Q = D / R = √(3N)
| N | i, j | Q = √(3N) |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | 1, 1 | 3.00 |
| 4 | 2, 0 | 3.46 |
| 7 | 2, 1 | 4.58 |
| 12 | 2, 2 | 6.00 |
A larger Q means more separation between co-channel cells, so less co-channel interference but fewer channels per cell (less capacity).
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- CCI/ACI, reuse ratio proof and channels per cell · Wireless Communication, chapter 2
- Co-channel and adjacent channel interference · Wireless Communication, chapter 2
- Derivation of co-channel reuse ratio · Wireless Communication, chapter 2
- Frequency reuse and co-channel reuse ratio · Wireless Communication, chapter 2
- Prove Q = √3N; optimal N for 15 dB S/I (n = 4) · Wireless Communication, chapter 2
- Numerical: co-channel distance for 7-cell reuse · Wireless Communication, chapter 2