- Asked 4/19
- 2069 Bhadra (old course) · 8 marks
- 2070 Magh · 4 marks
- 2072 Asoj
- 2065 Baisakh (old course)
Preventive maintenance is better than corrective
Short answer
Yes, preventive maintenance is better because it costs less, reduces breakdowns, improves safety, and extends asset life. For example, regularly waterproofing a roof prevents leaks and major structural damage, unlike corrective repair after failure.
"Preventive maintenance is better than corrective maintenance" / "Prevention is better than cure". Do you agree with this statement? Explain with suitable example.
Yes, I agree. Preventive maintenance means inspecting, servicing and repairing parts at planned intervals before they fail. Corrective maintenance means repairing only after failure has occurred. In most cases the first is cheaper, safer and more reliable, which is the meaning of "prevention is better than cure".
Reasons
- Lower total cost: small, planned jobs are cheaper than major repairs; a damaged part left to fail often damages other parts too.
- Fewer breakdowns and less downtime: the facility stays in use; there is no sudden stoppage of work or services.
- Safety: defects such as cracks, corrosion, or faulty wiring are found before they cause accidents.
- Longer service life of structures and equipment.
- Planned work: labour, materials and funds can be arranged in advance, and the work can be done at convenient times, not in a rush at higher cost.
- Better performance and appearance, and higher property value.
- Predictable budget compared with unexpected emergency expenditure.
Comparison
| Point | Preventive | Corrective |
|---|---|---|
| Timing | Before failure | After failure |
| Cost | Low, regular | High, irregular |
| Disruption | Small | Large |
| Safety | High | Risk of accident |
Examples
- Roof: cleaning gutters and applying waterproofing every few years costs little; ignoring a small leak leads to rusted reinforcement, spalled concrete and a major rehabilitation.
- Road: crack sealing and fog sealing of a pavement cost a fraction of the cost of full-depth reconstruction when potholes and base failure appear.
- Machine: changing oil and filters of an excavator on schedule avoids engine failure and expensive downtime.
Corrective maintenance is still needed for sudden failures, but a good plan keeps these few.
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Preventive, corrective and breakdown maintenance · Construction Management, chapter 9 · asked 3×
- Preventive maintenance in roads and buildings · Construction Management, chapter 9
- Why Kaiser window is better than fixed windows · Digital Signal Analysis and Processing, chapter 5 · asked 2×
- Closed loop better than open loop (cruise) · Embedded System, chapter 7
- When wet process is better than dry · Civil Engineering Materials, chapter 5
- T/F: HVDC better for longer lines · Transmission and Distribution System Design, chapter 1