Skip to main content

Why closed loop preferred despite cost

Short answer

Closed-loop systems are preferred because they provide accuracy, disturbance rejection, faster response, and can use cheaper components. Feedback compensates for plant variations and stabilizes unstable systems. Examples include hydropower governors, air conditioners, and autopilots, where open-loop would fail under changing conditions.

In spite of cost and complicated design, closed loop control systems are widely preferred over open loop control system. Justify the statement with some examples.

Closed-loop systems need sensors, comparators and more careful design, so they cost more and can become unstable. Still they are widely preferred because their performance advantages are much larger than these costs.

Justification

  1. Accuracy: the output is forced to follow the reference; sensitivity to plant changes is 1/(1+GH)1/(1+GH) instead of 1.
  2. Disturbance rejection: load changes and noise are corrected; their effect is reduced by (1+GH)(1+GH).
  3. Faster response: time constant τ→τ/(1+K)\tau \to \tau/(1+K).
  4. Can use cheaper, less precise plant components: feedback compensates for their tolerance and ageing, which often saves overall cost.
  5. Stabilizes unstable systems and allows full automation with less human labour.
  6. Cheap electronics today: sensors and microcontrollers are inexpensive, so the extra cost is small.

Examples

SystemWhy feedback is needed
Hydropower governorholds 50 Hz under changing load
Air conditioner / refrigeratorholds temperature despite weather and door opening
Automatic voltage regulatorkeeps voltage constant with load
Aircraft autopilot, missilemust track path despite wind
Cruise control in carsholds speed on slopes
Human body temperaturebiological feedback

In each case open-loop control would give large errors whenever load or environment changes, so the extra cost of feedback is justified.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Control Systems chapter 1 questions →