Skip to main content

Derivative feedback in second order time response

Short answer

Derivative feedback feeds back a signal proportional to the output rate, increasing the effective damping ratio to ζ + (Kt ωn)/2 without changing ωn. This reduces overshoot and settling time, but it increases the steady-state error to ramp inputs.

Describe working of derivative feedback controller in time response of second order system.

In derivative (rate/tachometer) feedback control, a signal proportional to the rate of change of the output, Kt c˙(t)K_t\,\dot c(t), is fed back negatively in an inner loop, besides the main unity feedback. In a motor position system, a tachogenerator on the shaft provides this velocity signal.

R --(+)--->(+)--> wn^2/(s(s+2z wn)) --+--> C
     ^-     ^-                        |
     |      +------[ Kt s ]<----------+
     +--------------------------------+

Analysis

Inner loop:

G1(s)=ωn2s(s+2ζωn+Ktωn2)G_1(s)=\frac{\omega_n^2}{s(s+2\zeta\omega_n+K_t\omega_n^2)}

Closed loop:

C(s)R(s)=ωn2s2+(2ζωn+Ktωn2)s+ωn2\frac{C(s)}{R(s)}=\frac{\omega_n^2}{s^2+(2\zeta\omega_n+K_t\omega_n^2)s+\omega_n^2} ζeff=ζ+Ktωn2,ωn unchanged\zeta_{eff}=\zeta+\frac{K_t\omega_n}{2},\qquad\omega_n\ \text{unchanged}

Working / effect on time response

  1. When the output moves fast towards the reference, the feedback signal Ktc˙K_t\dot c is large and subtracts from the actuating signal, braking the system early. This is extra damping.
  2. Overshoot falls as ζeff\zeta_{eff} rises; ts=4/(ζeffωn)t_s=4/(\zeta_{eff}\omega_n) falls.
  3. ωn\omega_n is unchanged and no zero is added, so the response is smooth (unlike PD, whose zero can add overshoot).
  4. Ramp error increases: Kv=ωn2ζ+KtωnK_v=\dfrac{\omega_n}{2\zeta+K_t\omega_n}; this is offset by raising the amplifier gain.
PropertyEffect
Dampingincreases
MpM_p, tst_sdecrease
ωn\omega_nsame
Ramp errorincreases

Example: ωn=5\omega_n=5 rad/s, ζ=0.2\zeta=0.2 (Mp=52.7%M_p=52.7\%). With Kt=0.12K_t=0.12: ζeff=0.2+0.3=0.5\zeta_{eff}=0.2+0.3=0.5, Mp=16.3%M_p=16.3\%.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Control Systems chapter 7 questions →