Skip to main content

Two-mass system X2/F and F-I analogy

Short answer

Introduce a massless junction x₃ between K₂ and B₁, write equations, and eliminate x₃ with equivalent stiffness K_eq = K₂B₁s/(K₂+B₁s). Solving yields X₂(s)/F(s) = B₁K₂ / [(K₂+B₁s)(M₁s²+f_c₁s+K₁)(M₂s+f_c₂+B₂) + B₁K₂((M₁+M₂)s²+(f_c₁+f_c₂+B₂)s+K₁)]. F–I analogy: f→i, M→C, B→1/R, K→1/L; nodes v₁, v₂; C₁=M₁, C₂=M₂ to ground, L₁=1/K₁, L₂=1/K₂, R_B1=1/B₁.

Find the transfer X2(s)/F(s) for the given mechanical system. Also develop F-I analogy circuit. [Figure: wall – spring K1 – mass M (force f applied, displacement X1, friction fc1 with ground) – spring K2 in series with damper B1 – mass M (displacement X2, friction fc2 with ground) – damper B2 – wall]

Let x1x_1, x2x_2 be the displacements of the two masses (M1M_1, M2M_2) and x3x_3 the displacement of the massless junction between K2K_2 and B1B_1 (spring on the M1M_1 side).

Differential equations

M1x¨1+fc1x˙1+K1x1+K2(x1−x3)=fK2(x3−x1)+B1(x˙3−x˙2)=0M2x¨2+(fc2+B2)x˙2+B1(x˙2−x˙3)=0\begin{aligned} M_1\ddot x_1 + f_{c1}\dot x_1 + K_1 x_1 + K_2(x_1 - x_3) &= f \\ K_2(x_3 - x_1) + B_1(\dot x_3 - \dot x_2) &= 0 \\ M_2\ddot x_2 + (f_{c2} + B_2)\dot x_2 + B_1(\dot x_2 - \dot x_3) &= 0 \end{aligned}

Eliminating the junction

From the second equation, X3=K2X1+B1sX2K2+B1sX_3 = \dfrac{K_2X_1 + B_1sX_2}{K_2 + B_1 s}. The force through the series spring–damper is then

K2(X1−X3)=Keq(X1−X2),Keq(s)=K2B1sK2+B1sK_2(X_1 - X_3) = K_{eq}(X_1 - X_2), \qquad K_{eq}(s) = \frac{K_2 B_1 s}{K_2 + B_1 s}

So, writing a=M1s2+fc1s+K1a = M_1s^2 + f_{c1}s + K_1 and b=M2s2+(fc2+B2)sb = M_2s^2 + (f_{c2}+B_2)s:

(a+Keq)X1−KeqX2=F−KeqX1+(b+Keq)X2=0\begin{aligned} (a + K_{eq})X_1 - K_{eq}X_2 &= F \\ -K_{eq}X_1 + (b + K_{eq})X_2 &= 0 \end{aligned}

Transfer function

X2(s)F(s)=Keq(a+Keq)(b+Keq)−Keq2=Keqab+Keq(a+b)\frac{X_2(s)}{F(s)} = \frac{K_{eq}}{(a+K_{eq})(b+K_{eq}) - K_{eq}^2} = \frac{K_{eq}}{ab + K_{eq}(a+b)}

Multiplying through by (K2+B1s)(K_2 + B_1 s) and cancelling the common factor ss:

X2(s)F(s)=B1K2(K2+B1s)(M1s2+fc1s+K1)(M2s+fc2+B2)+B1K2[(M1+M2)s2+(fc1+fc2+B2)s+K1]\frac{X_2(s)}{F(s)} = \frac{B_1K_2}{(K_2 + B_1s)(M_1s^2 + f_{c1}s + K_1)(M_2s + f_{c2} + B_2) + B_1K_2\left[(M_1+M_2)s^2 + (f_{c1}+f_{c2}+B_2)s + K_1\right]}

The denominator is a 4th-order polynomial in ss.

F-I analogy

f→if \to i, M→CM \to C, friction/damper B→B \to conductance 1/R1/R, K→1/LK \to 1/L, velocity →\to node voltage. Nodes v1,v3,v2v_1, v_3, v_2 correspond to x˙1,x˙3,x˙2\dot x_1, \dot x_3, \dot x_2.

MechanicalElectrical (F-I)
M1M_1, M2M_2C1=M1C_1 = M_1, C2=M2C_2 = M_2 (node to ground)
fc1f_{c1}, fc2f_{c2}, B2B_2R=1/fc1R = 1/f_{c1}, 1/fc21/f_{c2}, 1/B21/B_2 (node to ground)
K1K_1L1=1/K1L_1 = 1/K_1 (node 1 to ground)
K2K_2L2=1/K2L_2 = 1/K_2 (node 1 to node 3)
B1B_1RB1=1/B1R_{B1} = 1/B_1 (node 3 to node 2)
 v1                L2    v3  RB1   v2
 +----+----+----+--LLLL--+--/\/\/--+----+----+
 |    |    |    |                  |    |    |
(i)   C1   R1   L1                 C2   R2   R3
 |    |    |    |                  |    |    |
 +----+----+----+------------------+----+----+ gnd

(C1=M1C_1 = M_1, R1=1/fc1R_1 = 1/f_{c1}, L1=1/K1L_1 = 1/K_1; L2=1/K2L_2 = 1/K_2, RB1=1/B1R_{B1} = 1/B_1; C2=M2C_2 = M_2, R2=1/fc2R_2 = 1/f_{c2}, R3=1/B2R_3 = 1/B_2.) Node equation at node 1: C1dv1dt+v1R1+1L1∫v1dt+1L2∫(v1−v3)dt=iC_1\dfrac{dv_1}{dt} + \dfrac{v_1}{R_1} + \dfrac{1}{L_1}\int v_1dt + \dfrac{1}{L_2}\int (v_1 - v_3)dt = i, and similarly for nodes 3 and 2 (matching the three mechanical equations).

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Control Systems chapter 2 questions →