Skip to main content

F-V and F-I analogy of two-mass system, X2 output

Short answer

Write equations for M₁ and M₂, solve to get X₂(s)/F(s) = B₁ / [M₁M₂ s³ + (B₁M₁+B₁M₂+B₂M₂)s² + (B₁B₂ + kM₁)s + (B₁+B₂)k]. F–V analogy: F→e, M→L, B→R, k→1/C, i=ẋ. F–I analogy: F→i, M→C, B→1/R, k→1/L, v=ẋ; circuit has C₁=M₁, C₂=M₂, R₁=1/B₁, R₂=1/B₂, L=1/k.

The given mechanical system has force f(t) as input and x1 and x2 as displacement outputs. Draw equivalent f-v and f-I analogous electrical circuit and determine the transfer function with x2 as output. [Figure: fixed wall – spring k – mass M2 (displacement x2) – damper B1 – mass M1 (displacement x1, force F(t) applied); M1 is also connected to the fixed wall through damper B2]

Displacements: x1x_1 for M1M_1 (where FF acts) and x2x_2 for M2M_2. Assume no ground friction other than the dampers shown.

Differential equations

  • M1M_1: inertia, damper B1B_1 (relative to M2M_2), damper B2B_2 to the wall.
  • M2M_2: inertia, damper B1B_1, spring kk to the wall.
M1x¨1+B1(x˙1−x˙2)+B2x˙1=F(t)M2x¨2+B1(x˙2−x˙1)+kx2=0\begin{aligned} M_1\ddot x_1 + B_1(\dot x_1 - \dot x_2) + B_2\dot x_1 &= F(t) \\ M_2\ddot x_2 + B_1(\dot x_2 - \dot x_1) + kx_2 &= 0 \end{aligned}

F-V analogous circuit (mesh)

F→eF\to e, M→LM\to L, B→RB\to R, k→1/Ck\to 1/C, x˙→i\dot x\to i, x→qx \to q.

L1di1dt+R1(i1−i2)+R2i1=eL2di2dt+R1(i2−i1)+1C∫i2 dt=0\begin{aligned} L_1\frac{di_1}{dt} + R_1(i_1 - i_2) + R_2 i_1 &= e \\ L_2\frac{di_2}{dt} + R_1(i_2 - i_1) + \frac{1}{C}\int i_2\,dt &= 0 \end{aligned}

(L1=M1L_1 = M_1, L2=M2L_2 = M_2, R1=B1R_1 = B_1, R2=B2R_2 = B_2, C=1/kC = 1/k)

     L1=M1   R2=B2         L2=M2
  +--LLLL--/\/\/--+--------LLLL--+
  |               |              |
 (~) e         R1 = B1        C = 1/k
  |      i1       |      i2      |
  +---------------+--------------+

F-I analogous circuit (node)

F→iF\to i, M→CM\to C, B→1/RB\to 1/R, k→1/Lk\to 1/L, x˙→v\dot x\to v.

C1dv1dt+v1−v2R1+v1R2=iC2dv2dt+v2−v1R1+1L∫v2 dt=0\begin{aligned} C_1\frac{dv_1}{dt} + \frac{v_1 - v_2}{R_1} + \frac{v_1}{R_2} &= i \\ C_2\frac{dv_2}{dt} + \frac{v_2 - v_1}{R_1} + \frac{1}{L}\int v_2\,dt &= 0 \end{aligned}

(C1=M1C_1 = M_1, C2=M2C_2 = M_2, R1=1/B1R_1 = 1/B_1, R2=1/B2R_2 = 1/B_2, L=1/kL = 1/k)

 v1           R1     v2
 +----+----+--/\/\/--+----+
 |    |    |         |    |
(i)   C1   R2        C2   L
 |    |    |         |    |
 +----+----+---------+----+ gnd

Transfer function X2(s)/F(s)X_2(s)/F(s)

Laplace form:

[M1s2+(B1+B2)s]X1−B1sX2=F−B1sX1+(M2s2+B1s+k)X2=0\begin{aligned} \left[M_1s^2 + (B_1 + B_2)s\right]X_1 - B_1sX_2 &= F \\ -B_1sX_1 + (M_2s^2 + B_1s + k)X_2 &= 0 \end{aligned}

By Cramer's rule:

X2F=B1s[M1s2+(B1+B2)s](M2s2+B1s+k)−B12s2\frac{X_2}{F} = \frac{B_1s}{\left[M_1s^2 + (B_1+B_2)s\right](M_2s^2 + B_1s + k) - B_1^2s^2}

Cancelling the common factor ss:

X2(s)F(s)=B1M1M2s3+(B1M1+B1M2+B2M2)s2+(B1B2+kM1)s+(B1+B2)k\frac{X_2(s)}{F(s)} = \frac{B_1}{M_1M_2s^3 + (B_1M_1 + B_1M_2 + B_2M_2)s^2 + (B_1B_2 + kM_1)s + (B_1 + B_2)k}

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Control Systems chapter 2 questions →