Skip to main content

Stability: HS 310/43, BP 306/31

Short answer

Assume phi=30°. Stereoplot shows bedding plane daylighting with dip 31° (>phi) nearly parallel to face, risking plane failure; and wedges BP-J1 (plunge 31.0° towards 306°) and J1-J2 (34.1° towards 314°) lie between friction circle and face, possible wedge failure. Marginally unstable; reduce slope angle below 31° or reinforce.

Discuss the stability analysis of the given planes. Hill slope = 310°/43° Bedding plane (BP) = 306°/31° Joint (J1) = 350°/40° Joint (J2) = 288°/37° Joint (J3) = 237°/32° [Figure: stereonet]

Method (lower-hemisphere stereonet, equal-angle): plot the great circle of the slope face and of each discontinuity, draw the friction circle of radius ϕ\phi, and mark intersections of great circles. Then apply the kinematic tests below.

Data (dip direction/dip)

HS 310/43; BP 306/31; J1 350/40; J2 288/37; J3 237/32. In dip/dip direction: HS 43/310, BP 31/306, J1 40/350, J2 37/288, J3 32/237. The friction angle is not stated, so ϕ=30∘\phi = 30^\circ is assumed.

Single planes

Plane (dip/dip dir)Diff. of dip dir from slopeDaylights (ψp<ψf\psi_p<\psi_f)ψp>ϕ\psi_p>\phiResult
BP (31/306)4°yesyesPlane failure
J1 (40/350)40°yesyesSafe
J2 (37/288)22°yesyesMarginal (dip dir. off by 22°)
J3 (32/237)73°yesyesSafe

Intersections

PairIntersection plunge/trendFace apparent dip along trendResult
BP x J131.0° / 306°42.9°Wedge failure
BP x J228.3° / 332°40.8°Stable (plunge below ϕ\phi)
BP x J326.8° / 273°36.7°Stable (plunge below ϕ\phi)
J1 x J234.1° / 314°42.9°Wedge failure
J1 x J321.5° / 288°40.8°Stable (plunge below ϕ\phi)
J2 x J331.2° / 251°25.9°Safe (does not daylight)

Result

  • BP dips almost in the same direction as the face (4° difference), daylights (31∘<43∘31^\circ < 43^\circ) and is just above ϕ\phi (31∘>30∘31^\circ > 30^\circ): plane failure along the bedding is marginally possible.
  • J1 (dip direction 40° off) and J2 (22° off) each daylight, but they are outside the ±20∘\pm 20^\circ range for plane failure. J3 dips across the slope at 32° (73° off).
  • The J1 x J2 wedge (plunge 34.1∘34.1^\circ towards 314°) and the BP x J1 wedge (plunge 31.0∘31.0^\circ towards 306°) lie between the friction circle and the slope great circle: wedge failure is possible.

Conclusion: the slope is marginally unstable, with bedding-plane sliding and wedge failure (J1-J2 and BP-J1) as the possible modes. If the true friction angle is 35∘35^\circ or more, all of them become stable. Remedies: reduce the slope angle to less than about 31∘31^\circ, or use rock bolts, benches and drainage.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Engineering Geology II chapter 6 questions →