- Practice · 5 marks
Hydraulic and pneumatic load cells
Short answer
Hydraulic load cell converts force to oil pressure p=F/A; pneumatic load cell balances force by air pressure on a diaphragm. Both need no electrical power and are safe for hazardous areas, but have slower response and lower accuracy than strain-gauge cells, which require excitation but are faster and more accurate.
Explain the working of a hydraulic load cell and a pneumatic load cell. State their advantages and limitations compared with strain gauge load cells.
Both cells convert force into a fluid pressure, which is measured by a pressure gauge or transducer.
Hydraulic load cell
The force acts on a piston that bears on a liquid (oil) held in a chamber and sealed by a rolling diaphragm. The fluid pressure rises:
and the pressure gauge, calibrated in force units, shows the load.
F
v
[=======] <- loading plate
|piston |
|-------| diaphragm seal
| oil |---> pressure gauge / transducer
|_______|
- Almost frictionless because of the diaphragm.
- Needs no electric power, so it is suitable for hazardous areas.
- Useful for heavy loads (tank weighing, bridge testing, truck scales) and remote reading.
- Temperature changes affect the oil volume and pressure.
Pneumatic load cell
The force is balanced by air pressure acting on a diaphragm. The force pushes the diaphragm (flapper) toward a nozzle, which restricts the air bleed, so the pressure under the diaphragm rises until the balancing force is reached. This back pressure is read on a gauge and is proportional to the force.
Air supply --[restrictor]--+--> gauge
|
nozzle |
======== flapper moved by F
F v
[diaphragm]
- Intrinsically safe, clean and inexpensive.
- Relatively insensitive to temperature, unlike hydraulic cells; no liquid to leak.
- Typical for food and pharmaceutical work and for weighing small loads (up to about 20 kN) with good accuracy.
- Limited by response lag (compressible air, tubing volume) and needs a clean, dry air supply.
Comparison with strain gauge cells
| Point | Hydraulic/pneumatic | Strain gauge |
|---|---|---|
| Power | Not required | Electrical excitation |
| Hazardous area | Safe | Needs approved design |
| Signal | Pressure, remote reading | Electrical, easy for data logging |
| Response | Slow | Fast |
| Accuracy | About 0.25-0.5% | About 0.03-0.1% |
| Overload | Robust | Can be damaged |
✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)
Related questions
- Elastic transducers and strain gauge load cells · Instrumentation and Measurement, chapter 7
- Derivation of strain gauge factor · Instrumentation and Measurement, chapter 6
- Ballast circuit for a strain gauge · Instrumentation and Measurement, chapter 6
- Full-bridge cantilever load cell output · Instrumentation and Measurement, chapter 6
- Piezoelectric load cell and charge amplifier · Instrumentation and Measurement, chapter 7
- Working principle and types of fuel cells · Energy Resources, chapter 6
- Hydraulic and air brake systems compared · Automotive Technology, chapter 7
- Short note: Strain gauge · Basic Electronics Engineering, chapter 7 · asked 6×
- Gauge factor of resistance strain gauge · Instrumentation I, chapter 3