Skip to main content

5-disc string at 66 kV, ratios 5 and 6

Short answer

For m=0.2 (C=5C1), string efficiency is 54.16%. When distance increases so C=6C1 (m=1/6), efficiency rises to 57.47%. Reducing shunt earth capacitance improves voltage distribution uniformity.

Each conductor at 66 kV is suspended by a string of 5 similar insulators, the capacitance of each disc being 5 times the capacitance to earth. Determine the % string efficiency. If the distance between the insulators and tower structure is increased so as to make the capacitance of the disc 6 times the earth capacitance, what will happen to the string efficiency?

With no guard ring, the voltage across the discs increases towards the line, because each link pin leaks charging current to the tower through its shunt capacitance C1=mCC_1 = mC.

Data

Phase voltage:

V=663=38.105 kVV = \frac{66}{\sqrt 3} = 38.105\ \text{kV}

Number the discs 1 (tower end) to 5 (line end). At each junction, the current through the lower disc equals the current through the upper disc plus the current to earth:

Vk+1=Vk+m(V1+⋯+Vk)V_{k+1} = V_k + m(V_1+\dots+V_k)

Case 1: C=5C1C = 5C_1, so m=0.2m = 0.2

V2=1.2V1V3=V2+0.2(2.2V1)=1.64V1V4=V3+0.2(3.84V1)=2.408V1V5=V4+0.2(6.248V1)=3.6576V1\begin{aligned} V_2 &= 1.2V_1\\ V_3 &= V_2 + 0.2(2.2V_1) = 1.64V_1\\ V_4 &= V_3 + 0.2(3.84V_1) = 2.408V_1\\ V_5 &= V_4 + 0.2(6.248V_1) = 3.6576V_1 \end{aligned}

V=9.9056V1V = 9.9056V_1, so V1=38.105/9.9056=3.847V_1 = 38.105/9.9056 = 3.847 kV.

DisckV (m=1/5m = 1/5)kV (m=1/6m = 1/6)
13.8474.255
24.6164.965
36.3096.501
49.2639.122
5 (line end)14.07013.262
η1=V5V5=38.1055×14.070=54.16 %\eta_1 = \frac{V}{5V_5} = \frac{38.105}{5\times 14.070} = 54.16\ \%

Case 2: C=6C1C = 6C_1, so m=1/6m = 1/6

V2=1.1667V1,V3=1.5278V1V4=2.1435V1,V5=3.1165V1\begin{aligned} V_2 &= 1.1667V_1,\quad V_3 = 1.5278V_1\\ V_4 &= 2.1435V_1,\quad V_5 = 3.1165V_1 \end{aligned}

V=8.9545V1V = 8.9545V_1, so V1=4.255V_1 = 4.255 kV and V5=13.262V_5 = 13.262 kV.

η2=38.1055×13.262=57.47 %\eta_2 = \frac{38.105}{5\times 13.262} = 57.47\ \%

Answer: The string efficiency is 54.16 % when C=5C1C = 5C_1. Moving the insulators further from the tower lowers the shunt capacitance so that C=6C1C = 6C_1. The efficiency then rises to 57.47 %, and the line-end disc voltage falls from 14.07 kV to 13.26 kV. A lower ratio m=C1/Cm = C_1/C always gives a more uniform distribution.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Power System Analysis I chapter 2 questions →