Skip to main content

Embankment 36°, method of slices FoS

Short answer

Factor of safety with respect to shear strength: F_s = (c′L + ΣN′ tanφ′)/ΣT = (20×27 + 684×tan18°)/450 = 1.69. Factor of safety with respect to cohesion: c_m = (ΣT − ΣN′ tanφ′)/L = 8.44 kN/m², giving F_c = c′/c_m = 2.37.

An embankment 10 m high is inclined at an angle of 36° to the horizontal. A stability analysis by the method of slices gives the following forces per running meter: Σ Shearing forces = 450 kN; Σ Normal forces = 900 kN; Σ Neutral forces = 216 kN. The length of the failure arc is 27 m. Laboratory tests on the soil indicate the effective values of c' and ϕ′\phi' as 20 kN/m² and 18° respectively. Determine the factor of safety of the slope with respect to (a) shearing strength and (b) cohesion.

Data (per metre run): ΣT=450\Sigma T = 450 kN, ΣN=900\Sigma N = 900 kN, ΣU=216\Sigma U = 216 kN (neutral force, pore pressure force), arc length L=27L = 27 m, c′=20c' = 20 kN/m², ϕ′=18∘\phi' = 18^\circ.

Effective normal force: ΣN′=ΣN−ΣU=900−216=684\Sigma N' = \Sigma N - \Sigma U = 900 - 216 = 684 kN.

(a) Factor of safety with respect to shear strength

The factor of safety is the ratio of the available shear strength to the shear force:

Fs=c′L+(ΣN−ΣU)tan⁡ϕ′ΣT=20(27)+684tan⁡18∘450=540+222.2450=1.69\begin{aligned} F_s &= \frac{c'L + (\Sigma N-\Sigma U)\tan\phi'}{\Sigma T} \\ &= \frac{20(27) + 684\tan18^\circ}{450} \\ &= \frac{540 + 222.2}{450} = 1.69 \end{aligned}

(b) Factor of safety with respect to cohesion

Here the full friction is mobilised (Fϕ=1F_\phi = 1) and only the cohesion is reduced to the value needed for equilibrium:

ΣT=cmL+(ΣN−ΣU)tan⁡ϕ′  ⇒  cm=450−222.227=8.44 kN/m2\Sigma T = c_m L + (\Sigma N - \Sigma U)\tan\phi' \;\Rightarrow\; c_m = \frac{450 - 222.2}{27} = 8.44\ \text{kN/m}^2 Fc=c′cm=208.44=2.37F_c = \frac{c'}{c_m} = \frac{20}{8.44} = 2.37

Answer: (a) Fs≈1.69F_s \approx 1.69; (b) Fc≈2.37F_c \approx 2.37.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Soil Mechanics chapter 11 questions →