Skip to main content

Limitations of Mohr-Coulomb theory

Short answer

Limitations: ignores intermediate principal stress; uses a linear envelope (true envelope curved); c and φ are not constants (depend on drainage, density, stress path); does not model stress-strain behavior; neglects strain softening, anisotropy, time effects, and overestimates tensile strength.

Point out the limitations of Mohr-Coulomb theory.

Limitations of the Mohr-Coulomb theory:

  1. Intermediate principal stress is ignored. The criterion depends only on σ1\sigma_1 and σ3\sigma_3, but tests show σ2\sigma_2 has some influence.
  2. Straight-line envelope is an approximation. The true envelope is usually curved, especially at very low or very high stresses, so cc and ϕ\phi are valid only for the stress range tested.
  3. cc and ϕ\phi are not fundamental soil constants. They depend on drainage condition, rate of loading, stress path, density, water content, and the test type.
  4. Does not model stress-strain behaviour. It gives only the strength at failure, not the strains required to reach it.
  5. Strain softening and residual strength are not included. Peak strength may not be available along an existing slip surface.
  6. Anisotropy, fissures and structure are neglected; the soil is assumed isotropic and homogeneous.
  7. Time effects such as creep are not considered.
  8. Tension is not covered properly. The envelope extended to negative normal stress overestimates tensile strength.

✓ Answer checked by Claude Opus 5.5 (high effort)

All Soil Mechanics chapter 10 questions →